amber is so underrated, it hurts me. I'm not a big fan of fx but this woman right here deserve to be recognized for her composition skills

Amber is beautiful her voice is like honey omg i love you amber

At this point I don't understand how people can hate her

When Amber sings, she sounds like an angel. 😍 And when she raps, she sounds so gangsta. 😎 Get a woman who can do both. Only talents 👏🏼💞💕

her voice is just so peaceful

YOU ARE A BEAUTIFUL LLAMA AND YOU ARE LIKE ONE OF MY BIGGEST ROLE MODELS. AGH. LOVE YOU SO MUCH.

I just came here after "Shake That Brass" and DAMN when she started singing I was like "wait I thought this was Amber". I'm not the biggest f(x) fan so I haven't really heard her sing until now, and geeeeeez she is talented.

There is nothing about Amber that you can hate. She is absolute perfection

I hope all the people that hate her realize that she's just an unique and beautiful person with an awesome personality that can sing,rap,and write songs. She is truly an inspiration for me and I would love to meet her. Hope you keep you head up Amber and realize why we love you. I will be your supporter now and always. Just remember to be unique and be yourself.

My goal is to just meet Amber and just hug her and thank her for everything she has done.

I CAN SMELL COMEBACK!!!!

Still someone in 2020? This is literally one of the masterpiece of my lady crush .

Happy birthday to our beautiful Amber!

MY HEART FLUTTERS WHENEVER SHE LOOKS AT THE CAMERA I LOVE HER

can we also appreciate the fact that it is Christian [ a.k.a Rome, if you didn't know ] shot the video. Like one of her best friends shot this and that's why I think the shots are even a 1000 times better. He knows her so well and therefore he was able to capture her at her most beautiful times. I don't know; might just be me..

Why havent i hear about this before?? It so *beautiful* that my eyes r sweating

Happy birthday, Amber!!

AMBER YOUR FUCKING VOICE GOT MY HEART I LOVE IT WOW IM SPEECHLESS

DANG SM LITERALLY YOU ARE ON FIRE THIS YEAR

I'm a 16 years old tomboy n I live in India. My hair is shorter than Amber's. I'm so boyish that people mistake me for a boy ( that's not a problem but it happens in public toilets too). People always tell me to change my dress and grow more hair cuz it isn't our tradition. But I never listen to them. I'm just being me. I really thought many times whether I should really change myself- like they say. But this song gives me courage. Thanks Amber. Thank you so much. Wish I could meet you.

Who cares if this video doesn't have as many views as other artists, to the people who did watch it - it means everything and is everything Kpop should strive to become. There aren't many Kpop songs that have meaning and there aren't many that aren't about boy/girl love, and I'm just glad that Amber has given something to cherish forever. That is, she's given us beauty. Because beauty is different and weird. Thank you, Amber, for everything.

Every time I listen to her songs, I get this huge sense of being strong. She is such a strong and independent person, and she sings her songs with that voice and soul. Her most recent song, "Borders" shows this side a lot as well. I believe in her, and in a way, I feel she believes in us.

Sort of unrelated to this perfect video but my life will not be complete until I see Amber in a drama.. or even a reality show, if she was on We Got Married I could die happy

waiting for the second solo

This was so beautiful, I'm so in love with this song, I'm happy that they released an mv for it, cries ;-; you go Amber!!!!!

Amber's smile gives me life

Being a rapper doesn't mean you can't sing :) Well done, AMBER!!!!

I just love this little baby to death. She has had to worked even harder than most trainees. I appreciate the fact that she is so comfortable being the girl we see. a girl who gets on the stage with the rest of her group but she doesn't wear the costumes that includes dresses oy skirts. And I think that she is pretty in her own way. But I really love her singing voice. She is just amazing.

People: never forget that our perfect llama got into S.M. through singing not rapping 😊 so don't be surprised lol she just happens to be multitalented

This is the kind of role model we need in the k-pop world.

TBH people always hate more than appreciate... I see no one giving props to SM for giving Amber such a gift of having a special video for her amazing song. Happy Birthday Llama.

It's 2024 and I'm here again. Years ago it helped me with my anorexia. Amber, love u ❤ Thank u.x

Amber songs are one of the song that when you go on long walks and you listen to these kind of songs and you reflect yourself.

I think amber is not like any other female Kpop idol because she has her own tomboy style and other female Kpop idols wear like high heels, girly, cute and sexy clothing and that's what I love about Amber she is different than other female kpop artist. I wished she just singed more in f(x) she has a beautiful voice.

She almost sounds like two different people :O her range is amazing

ENGLISH LYRICS: I hung my head low, avoiding the sky, hiding The nights were endless in my dark heart, yeah yeah I couldn’t spread my wings in this world that was like a small birdcage With struggling movements, I’ll sing for you, who will come to me some day So my dreams that spread its wings can shine even more in the blue sky So my coldly shut heart can beat again, I’ll go up in the sky to the stars Outside the door, I always had anxious scars I can only fly if I endured through the pain Those hurtful words deeply cut into my heart It hurt but I bit my tongue and endured I know I’m gonna heal and I’m always looking up Even if it’s dark, I’m gonna find the light I will smile, I will keep smiling I’m a fighter, I won’t ever give up I’ll keep flying, fly, fly again My dreams wrap around the future me I’ma just be me yeah only me I’ma just be me yeah yeah I can fly higher without fear, even when I’m trapped in darkness Any kind of scar is beautiful to me I’m just happy, I’m happy to be myself I’m happy to be myself

WHAT!??!!! I had no idea that Amber had such amazing vocals. Like what the what. Her voice is so pure and sweet. Wow!

THIS IS NOT FROM SM THIS IS FROM DPR, DPR IS THE GROUP AMBER IS A PART OF WHICH INCLUDES CHRISTIAN YU (ROME FROM C-CLOWN), so yes. This is a special gift. DPR produced and filmed because DPR is awesome. SM step your game up

How in the world did I miss this video?! Omg, I feel like I just wronged Amber.

Who is still listening to this beautiful masterpiece?

_“I personally believe girls and boys are not limited to one specific look. Beauty comes in all shapes and sizes. We are all different. If we all sang the same melody how can there be harmony? Dont judge someone just because they’re different. Hopefully we can all grow to respect each other’s differences."_ *You are inspiration , Amber. I really hope one day I can meet her. She is a beautiful talented woman is who I respect.*

Holy llamas this is beautiful. I'm glad that this song finally got an mv.

Amber should seriously come out with an solo album, her voice is so heavenly. I love Amber so much!

solo debut 10 years anniversary always love u Amber❤

*HOW CAN ONE DISLIKE THIS?!?!?*

Her voice is so beautiful and soft! I wish there were more songs of Amber like this one and Borders. They are really wonderful!

It's crazy how she has like 2 different voices. One harsher voice for rapping and that really nice voice for singing.

Amber truly is beautiful inside and out. I love that she puts that message out there to be yourself.

omg yes

She is beautiful in every single way. I'm not ashamed to be myself just like her. She has done a lot for me even if she doesn't know me and I'm really really in love with her.

This song is so important

She debuted as solo on her b'day :") It's been a month since her 28th birthday 💜 love ya llama ✨🦙

THIS SHOULD HAVE MORE VIEWS

Wah~ I didn't expect this... a bit late for the mv but i'm not complaining hahahha

Her music hits you so hard, harder then a bts comeback like damn, she's incredible, you just can't help but feel like a beautiful person after you listen to her music as if anything bad you've ever done, any negative thoughts are no longer there because her positivity and inspiring nature just uplifts you. She such a incredible inspiration

Almost 10 years later and I'm still madly in love with this song

I've officially fallen in love with Amber, holy shit

Amber's voice is so perfect for songs like this. Hitting me in the feels.

Wow... Completely opposite of Shake That Brass. I love both side of her. Dare to be different Ms. Amber. you're beautiful just the way you are. Be happy to be yourself as your lyrics state.

엠버 진짜 너무 좋아 취향저격

SM in next level now, after our DINO genius SHINee Kim Jonghyun NOW our LlAMA beautiful F(X) Amber.Right now no one can judge SM artis because their are super talented idol not just as a group but as a individual too, I'm so proud, their deserve what their have right now. SMfamily jjang!!! ^_^

Absolutely love her! She reminds me of myself!!!!

I am so speechless.

Fact: This wasn't recommended by youtube and you prolly had to search for it because you know how amazing this song and Amber is.

*when this MVs came out* ''Oh~ Amber's back, guess she's gonna rap again.'' . . . *after listening* I'M SO DONE SH*T I DIDN'T KNOW SHE HAS SUCH ANGELIC VOICE KILL ME THIS IS TOO BEAUTIFUL BLESS HER I LOVE HER @$%#%&!^*.......

Am I the only one who shed a tear cause it was so beautiful?

gosh...i didn't know her singing voice sounded like this :OOO it's really beautiful :*

one thing really annoys me. the few kpop songs that actually have a message in the song and mean something get the least amount of views but some of the utter garbage gets millions of views.

Am I the only one who wants her to go on king of masked singer?

Amber is and will always be my female bias💕💕💕

Im in love with Amber and this song. I love the song and the lyrics so much it's one of the songs that I identify with so much I cry when I hear it. Amber is a hot cutie and I wanna kiss her and her adorable face and be dorky with her!!!

中学生の時死ぬほど聞いてた大大大好きなこの歌をふと思い出して聴きにきたら、このMVを見てあの時の記憶が一瞬で蘇った🥲 大学4年生になった2022年22歳、大学で韓国語を学んで今になって歌詞の意味がスッと入ってきて、あの時とは違った感じ方でもっと深くアンバーの歌を聴くことができています。私達はありのままで美しい。 f(x)は私の青春、f(x)に出会えて幸せです。 LOVE U AMBER!!! 미유는 영원하다!! また聴きにこよーっ🥹

Amber, you're my ultimate female bias forever~

Amber, you are beautiful ❤️

I can't help but keep listening to her voice and the message within her lyrics. So beautiful.

갑자기 생각나서 찾아 왔는데 엠버언니의 목소리가 넘 예쁘네요ㅜㅜ마지막으로 만난지 벌써 5년이 됐네요>

Giving Amber a solo was the best thing SM could have ever done. I am so in love with her and her songs. I love this MV. Thank you Amber and Christian

Watch it in 1.25 speed. Its amazing as well!

THE SHIVERS. This is why Amber is my queen

who's still listening this masterpiece in 2024?? mee!!

One thing that I truly admire about SM is that they let Amber be in charge of herself as an artist and an idol. She did not have to be packaged with badass image and untouchable aura. She did not have to diss anyone to get attention. She just had to be Amber, underrated but truly beloved by many fans from many fandoms and many artists from many companies. She isn't pretty, she's beautiful. She's a good role model for many rookies because after all the fame, she knows who she is and she shows who she is.

I feel like the 499 people who disliked this song need to reevaluate their lives.

This is honestly one of the most beautiful MVs SM has ever made. EDIT: Oops, it's by DPRegime, not SM - my mistake!! Still a hella beautiful work of art though, props to them - what an amazing video for an amazing song! :D

I️ just discovered Amber, and I’m a blown away! She’s so talented and what a beautiful person with a beautiful soul!

I'm honestly so happy Amber got to do her solo, the first time i heard her sing was when she sang with Henry for that Christmas special...I've always been an fx fan, so I'm glad Amber got her solo ♡

never know her voice was so girlish her voice so is beatiful

I really, really like her voice is so perfect:3

노래 진짜 좋다..

im very very glad that SM let her show her own colors, break the feminine stereotype over the kpop girl group. They didn't make a mistake when they find Amber. She is truly a treasure

who are these 500 disliking the song , really this is a master piece

SHE NEED TO BE IN KING MASK SINGER

私はAmberのこと、ちゃんと分かってなかった。 もっと早くこの歌に出会いたかったけど、今出会ったということは「今がその時」なのかも。 こんなふうに、自分の思いや姿勢をメロディーと歌詞にしてオープンにしてくれるAmberを尊敬する。勇気を貰いました。

No matter what people said,she still strong 👏🏻👏🏻👍🏻💪🏻💪🏻 that's our Amber J Liu

Perfect Voice Perfect Rap Perfect Girl She is a one of the most perfect girls in the world! Love you Amber ♥♥♥

Does anyone know why suddenly a special video ? ^^ btw love this song, and it's written by Amber so I love it even more, she's truly so talented

Beautiful Amber

at this point im gonna fight for short haired girl no matter what. cuz almost all of them are great!! all hail AMBER!!!

I'm so proud of everything Amber has achieved and become. Happy birthday, lil llama, we all love you ❤️

FINALLY THEY LET THIS BEAUTIFUL VOICE OF A LLAMA HAVE A MV

Amber's voice is sooo beautiful omo