Amber was 16 almost 17, Luna was 16, Sulli 15 and Krystal 14. I'm barely 17 and I'm a potato

@@88Manel88 and Victoria ? :'(

@@Jade-tv3rm I didn't mention her because she was 22 and that's not really young as the rest.

@@88Manel88 ah okay thank you :)

ajolbby mood

@추 ಥ‿ಥ니니 the fandom name was given when they were almost in hiatus and I don't know why SM treated them this way😭

@추 ಥ‿ಥ니니 fx did have a light stick, do they not?

their fandom name is MEu but i think they had a tour in asia if I'm not wrong

@@Skinnerville no they didn't

Actuall, we do have a name, we are called *MeUs* but we finally got it after 7 years of debut :") and yeah, we don't have a lightstick :") I really hate SM so much, you can't imagine how much i hate them for treating my girls this way.....

ㅇㅈ

요즘 아이돌은 개성도 없고 공장에서 찍어내듯 똑같음

@@뿌우-u2l 시대보정임 저 때가 춘추전국시대긴해서 폭발적이긴 했는데 fx만 독특하다 했지 죄다 후크송에 식상하단 얘기 있었음

@@unknown-tw1fn 포미닛 미스에이 2ne1 개성 충만했는데요?

@@asdasddcax 그당시는 소속사만의 개성이 뚜렸했는데 지금은 다 똑같음 ㅇㅈ?

Had to rewatch the MV myself. 10 years ago already...she looked so young( and still was)

I was literally listening to this song when I scrolled down my FB feed and saw that she had committed suicide...

😭💔

come here for song long time just for sulli

:( :(

yes! my favorite live performance ever, they all looked so happy that day

I'm remember and proud and love so much f(x).

Best performance ever!!!

Yeah.. I love their performance

*i c o n i c*

But tbh i wanna see another GG do this boyish concept. The world wasnt ready and receptive to this kinda concept back then. Now that girlcrush is milked to the bone, a concept like this would be ICONIC✨ Also NU ABO is iconic no one would top that.

@@pyreworks5210 I agree, f(x) are LEGENDS

@@pyreworks5210 No one can do this concept well expect f(x) bcz they have Amber and every member has a special touch not copy paste

True but i like the most snsd and then all the other gg. For me snsd still queens with 2ne1 on there.🥺 like them all though.

@@pyreworks5210 to be honest there will NEVER be a group that can be like f(x), and SM ruined that opportunity with them

i mis sulli

argee❤

​@@guadalupelazof91317ㅍ

ㅂ777ㅍ

Sulli 💜

Miss Sulli so much..

@DiscoOtter 7456 she left the group

Luna: excuse me ？？？

She died today RIP Sulli 😢

@@quincykongstrong vocals

I feel so bad for second gen kpop groups, most of them got crappy management.

They were def unique, which is why I fell for them

Literally the blueprint for all of the groups marketed as “different” or “unique from others” and they got done dirty. Me-U forever

amen

they’re not even from a nugu company either. These companies always treat their GGs a lot worse than their BGs. They’re not given equal opportunities. They push their BGs but the GGs have to prove their popularity before they do, and they treat them worse than their flop bgs

God😣

T-T

May the souls of the deceased refrain 😥

😢

She was just 14 when this song was released :'(

Kiara Rose I think the purpose is disrupted for you to think of her in that way because that wasn’t who she was. The point is she had to act that way because that was the persona that her company gave her. In reality, she deserved recognition for being a real person that went through things and a person who needed the help she desperately cried out for.

Nana Smith As a person who has struggled with depression for the last 3 years, I disagree with your comment. I think its wrong to think she was her depression. Her mental illness does not define her; her strength and personality does. Although it deeply saddens me that Sulli receieved hate and did not recieve the right help, I want to remember her as the amazing person she was. I believe that there was times that she was truly happy and I want to cherish those moments.

Anyway you can see on her face that she is not a bad person

To me she seems really gentle and sympathetic

For me, I will always remember her as 1:40

Goddess Romsae/Love Bomb SKKSSKSK y u gotta play my girl like that 😂💀💀

LMAOOOOO

Lol

😂😂

OMG 😂😂😂

F(x)*

It's bop

@@baklangtwoah8705 😘😘😘😘

Bops never ages

솔직히 인정!! 루나누나가 1번이긴 했지만 설리누나보고 저 누나 누구길레 저리 이쁘냐고 생각듬

이젠 설리를 못보는게 넘 슬픔... 편하게 쉬렴... 내 애기...

@@고규혁-x7w 그래도 넘 슬픈말보단 지금도 곁에 있는것처럼 애정주는게 그게 설리누나도 그렇고 나머지 함수누나들도 위한일이 아닐까요...

@@지개수호두콩 맞는 말이네요... ㅜㅜ 저 역시 팬으로써 훨씬 위로가 되는 댓글 감사합니다...

@@고규혁-x7w 저도 솔직히 많은 그룹을 사랑했던 13년차 음방팬으로써 그 그룹 중 한팀이 함수누나들이었는데 솔직히 진리누나가 나가고나서 안좋은 시선을 본 건 사실이지만... 어떤 인간이 이렇게 되길 바라겠어요... 그래도 진리누나가 이왕 이리된 거 그 위치에서 열심히 살아가길 빌었는데 이리 되니까....

yeah like they are begging for likes after this disaster...

oof. yeah.

But are u not here too beacuse u found out the news about her

@@aneesunisabegum7366 Yes but we're talking about the people who are specifically asking just to get some likes. There's a difference

i was going to say that

then sulli died

@@kaiyuls What is wrong with you? That sounded rude.

@@doodoo7207 not in the same street as f(x) in term of talent

@@doodoo7207 art director, not producer

@@doodoo7207those 2 groups are so different, beside same art director they have nothing in common

Sulli was 15

Sulli is adorable

I'm really jealous because Krystal and Sulli (also Suzy) debuted when they were 14-15 years old but it's already 2018 and i'm turning 15 on April and nothing is happening in my life.

SHIMMIE SHIMMIE KOKOBOP WE GOT THAT POWER ikr

Dinah Graham And here in 2018 they barely aged.

it’s never too late for f(xh

OMG!!! You just blew my mind right now!!!!! I never realized that!!! I feel so stupid now. LOL!!

OMGJCSO!?

Hahaha, you're right. Didn't notice that either. Am I a bad fan now?

Ellen Verbunt Nah. I watched this MV literally over 100 times and just realised them things a few days ago.. >.

I noticed the moon but not the crystals xD

Yeah. Victoria didn't renew her contract too. Today she left sm.

@@АлимаОсмонова-д5к sm said that they’re talking to victoria abt contract renewal but i doubt she will resign lol. also, luna’s contract expired. so krystal is the only one officially signed to sm & that’s only because her contract’s not expired yet. atleast they’ve got their freedom now ☹️

@@portiapagdanganan8096 I hope they will release single until disbanding for funs with sully too. It could be perfect. P.s: when will end Luna's, Krystal's contracts?

@@АлимаОсмонова-д5к i doubt that because sulli doesnt really want to be associated with f(x) anymore + sm is trash i doubt they’d let them do that this year. nonetheless, i wish in the future they can comeback considering the fact that there was no disbandment notice so they’re technically is still f(x). luna’s contract is already expired. with krystal there’s no specific date that they’ve indicated but pretty sure that would be within this year

@@АлимаОсмонова-д5к maybe in a ffew months or maybe YEARS!!!???

IRENE BAE same :(( #prayforsulli

Dulce Ibarra and Victoria was in the replay mv too! It was meant to be lol

They're also both the middle children.

the fact that Amber looked like Jonghyun made it better lol

Snsd is super junior female ver, redvelvet is exo female ver, and f(x) is SHINee female ver 😂

Haha yeah they literally are

Omg same

Same

Same

@Đức KUMAHA SIA

@Đức blackpapa juga

All of Sm boy groups and girl groups debut songs are not cutesy or sexual.

itsthelasttime13 😭👏👏👏👏💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

Damn this comment makes me really cry. I just cant 2009 was one of the best years for me. 2015 was the worst. I dont want to give anyone a bad feeling, I love f(4) too so much but what now? What now after Sulli is gone? im so sure that 4 walls was only because Sm wanted to show that f(x) are also a group without Sulli. Its true but it just doesnt work. Its not the same. What is SM even doing? "yeah f(x) isnt famous anymore" THEY ARE. And for those who say that f(x) are underrated, its NOT true. f(x) still have so many fans they are one of the most famous groups in korea but Sm doesnt realise it? I mean since Sulli is still in SM she is able to come back to f(x) and who knows, maybe she is going to do that since shes doing better after her problems, and Im sure if she would do that when f(x) gets active (THIS IS MY OPINION IM JUST THINKING THIS). I mean she didnt leave because of acting. I just wanted to say this. SM is too stupid to realise, Sm is like "rv rv, snsd snsd, taeyeon taeyeon, even hyoyeon hyeon and money. MeUs keep supporting f(4) and Sulli anything could happen♥

PREACH!!!

Ankit Pant Asians don't crack honey ;)

At long last! SM did

Asians don't Raisin lol

Uhh she still does look like a teenager?? LOOK SHE IS 31 NOW AND SHE LOOKS AT LEAST LIKE 21 SHE LOOKS ANYTHING OTHER THAN 31 SHE LOOKS SOOOO YOUNG I CANT BELIEVE IT

how can I sneeze like Sowon? BUT LIKE THATS SO TRUE THOUGH SHE STILL LOOKS SO YOUNG

Natya Shina thank you for supporting the group

Wkwkw ka natya dsini jg

💘

I missed Suili

Now she's dead... 😭😭😭

MrsMarie Orton lol not me I'm living the all lessons life like... Violin lessons Martial arts Pianoist Dancer Music maker Tutor ..... my life yo

MrsMarie Orton Stumbled upon your comment whilst eating cake.

MrsMarie Orton And Sulli

THE FUCK. I THOUGHT THAT THEY WERE LIKE 18 IN THIS MV

MrsMarie Orton omg

Because Sm consistently refuses to believe f(x) exists

Make it as the top comment, everyone, so SM will see it.

Do sm know how to read english 🙄

@@vanillaghtsHow can you make a comment top comment if the video is not your post?

YES

Miss old gold kpop 😭

and into the new world snsd, sm family :)

As well as the other songs listed in the replies, there's also Twins(Knock Out) by Super Junior and Hug by TVXQ! I love the SM family :D

Yes💙

🤗

I'm here everyday

Yaasss

Here from Cambodia

Yes! From Paraguay ❤

sulli - sub rapper too ..

visual ??? You mean face of f(x) ? face of f(x) is not Sulli but Krystal.... SNSD - YoonA, Apink - Naeun, AOA - Selhyun, Girl's day - Yura , 4 minute - HyunA, AS(OC) - Yui,NANA, Red velvet - Irene, T-ara - Jiyeon.....

no !! sulli is visual/face of the group !!!

lovedsjyjw Well, kinda. Usually "Visual" means the one who is the face of the group's covers or the focus in the videos. They're both visuals… Sulli was just the first since she was the face for the "NU ABO" album cover… So you're right and wrong at the same time… :)

Christian Psalms Sorry for my bad english but you are soooo stubborn. We(koreans) never use that word "visual". face or symbol of group is correct. Look carefully! She(Krystal) always appears firstly,frequently in MV and is center of formation during the performance. that's the role of face(symbol) of K-pop girl group.

that golden era where everything is so peaceful 😧

+littlehan ridinghun yes it was😢

Jung Taekwon is bae for life now kpop world is more like comparing which group is better and members leaving and all, lawsuits 😧 kpop used to be my sweet escape from real world though 😢

littlehan ridinghun I know😢😣

t'was a simpler time

i know right i miss them so much i remember watching them in 2013 when i was a kid now im a teen in 13 years old now

Yes! Definitely love that song too

I'm here for Sulli

+Nusly Paola Carbajal it because it was new for them, now it a bit more casual and tedious to perform.

sweetcattv I don't mean they'd go back to the style of song or choreography, I mean they go back to smiling and being energetic. I really hope SM gave them time to rest for their comeback this fall.. I'm so exited I can't wait!!!!

EvilPrincess me too!! I'm going to miss her so much.. f(x) will definetly not be the same but gotta support them no matter what right?

Nusly Paola Carbajal no but i meant performing, it was more new to them then.

Me

haha me, im on an f(x) marathon because i miss them so much 😭😭

wait, are u malaysian? bcs ur dp, isnt that ejen ali?

@@bubblegumjoys iya HAHAHA..org sabah ni

Still here

Sulli is 15 you know

It's concerning that almost everyone were minors

Victoria was 22 and Sulli was 15

WOW... çok genç

@종합편성채널 i was 7…

.

Me too 😭😭

Me too 😭😭😭😭😭

Me to😭

Me too..i have f(x) mv marathon right now..miss them so much😭

Same here... On marathon right now

Same, I was there too. Can't believe how time has flown by since then... The feels of sadness and nostalgia are hitting hard at the same time...

@@zargein thanks for the reply, I made some recordings of the event including f(x) they're in my channel but I haven't posted much since then. If you were somewhere at the front you might even spot yourself in the videos

@@bhytre man you had a really great camera for its time! I just watched your f(X) introduction and nostalgia kicked right back in. I remember having a sore back for standing for so long haha. I was on the right side so I don't think I was photo bombing you

If you want to feel maybe a little better, put the word Sulli into a google search and scroll down through 19 pages of headlines from around the world, all reporting the news of ~20 hours ago, mostly actual mainstream news media. It does feel good to realize how well known she was and how well liked by so many people. New York Times, CBS News, CNN, Cosmopolitan, The Straits Times, South China Morning Post, ABC, Rolling Stone, Washington Post, Insider, LA Times, Entertainment Weekly, Business Insider, NBC, USA Today, Forbes, New York Daily News, DW (Germany), BuzzFeed, News au, HuffPost, Variety Mag, Newsweek, Metro UK, The Telegraph UK, E! News, The Sun UK, The Independant UK, Malay Mail, The Daily Beast, Mirror UK, Daily Mail UK, UPI, Korea Herald, Detroit News, Women's Health ....... it just goes on.

@@BioCosmic--Dust I know, I've been scrolling through all the headlines already. She even appeared in my country.

Ugh sm are just the worst

@@ancermet6734 ùiùliijuukylļuu1lùqpkkķlļki7k

Please.... Please... Please... Come back. All 5 😍

Yes

Yes

Yes

Who would dare let the rap happen on top of the final chorus nowadays? No one else could ever

hostage I agreed plus erased them off this face of earth , hate those cyber bully plus company for cruel to those idol they work hard to be successful if it were me as chairman of those clue I would do something to protect our idol and also actor as it my children

Amen

@A For Apple what do you mean ??

A For Apple I know it’s true there’s 666 days between, but please don’t say offensive things like that, it’s really upsetting

Omg really? All the years, I thought it was "Warrior", and I was so sure about it. Thanks for telling me^^ BAP fighting :D (I hope they'll manage their current crisis well)

I'm sorry but What is Love was not a debut song. EXO's debut song was MAMA but it a good song. ^_^

Juana Aguilera For me (or inofficially), it's What Is Love

Juana Aguilera MAMA came out after What Is Love, so WIL is maybe their first song with which they debuted. But MAMA is still the "official debut song", that's true

Ah, i see. And it is an exceptional song! ^_^

Me🖐️

그건 니 생각일뿐.

@@부정선거선관위구속 니댓글도니생각일뿐이잖아 사람마다 느끼는게 다른데 니도 멋대로 판단한거면서

@@부정선거선관위구속 연간순위보면 인기있었던거 팩트임

Also Luna not continued the contact 😞💔

@@Callmebaby2111 Yes. I made separate comments for Luna and Victoria after it was announced that they were no longer with SM. I also made a comment for Krystal, knowing she still has time left on her contract. It is sad that SM treated them so terribly since the first day. I am glad they are free to live and work in a better environment. Both Victoria and Amber will be releasing albums/mini-albums and Luna is busy writing songs. I think of them like childhood friends who have gone to different colleges. They may not see each other like before, but they still stay in touch and their friendship remains. I hope the members' and the Meu's hearts can be at ease in the future.

itsthelasttime13 I’m really miss them 😞💔 I’m really hate Sm coz they always care others artists accept fx wish they have a good bye song

뉴진스 잇자나

@@art-jo-history 뉴진스가 어딜 봐서 실험적이람. 그냥 s.e.s. 재탕해서 떴지

@@dreamdrum4004 ㅋㅋ음 그래

TRUE

so true

People like me never scolded her for leaving the group. By jumping to conclusions and criticizing people this way, you are engaging in exactly the kind of cyberbullying that killed Sulli.

@@dorinriki 1. This wasn't directed at you personally, this was to those who said this like "who's here after the news" and everything. 2. You are actually jumping to conclusions because you as accused me of doing such when I'm literally defending the poor girl. I didn't generalize every single person. 3. You generalized me and my statement and completely misunderstanding. I didn't directly say you did at all. It's a statement that was just mentioned, not for every person who reads it to be taken personally

Yeah,this is so bad

It's today!!

Hey!!Have you watch it? Kbs has upload a new music video about f(x)singles!!!! Go watch it! Its really great

Too bad Sulli is no longer with us...

@@anafujita4345 😭😭😢😢

I realize that Victoria appeared in Produce camp 2020 and now Amber appeared in Produce Camp 2021

How old was Luna?

like 16 or 17. same as Amber, Kristal and Sully was 14

Luna had recently turned 16 when this came out, Sulli was 15, krystal was 14 almost 15, amber was almost 17 and victoria was 22

Still blows my mind a bit. There usually seems to be a small age gap between one member to the next but with Victoria (oldest) to Krystal (maknae) it's about an 8 year age difference.

that era was golden i remember being so hype about kpop

Sheila Mae yes 2009-2012 was a golden era of kpop :((( i miss those good old days

Same to me😭💔

Or SM at least let aespa cover some of the songs of f(x) like Hot Summer, Rum Pum Pum Pum, La chA TA or 4 walls.

oh gosh me

me

Literally going through a f(x) nostalgia marathon after the news ;_;

me

alysael same man at this point im just hurting myself

A tip: you can watch series on Flixzone. Been using them for watching a lot of movies during the lockdown.

@Brady Zion yup, I've been using flixzone} for since december myself :)

They didn’t disband luna said it herself

Me lmao

Yass

lol yes! :D

yes haha

me 😂

2009 was a year with good kpop songs...

parker łane wym almost all the kpop music was lit

2009 was the golden year of kpop

제 벅스 재생목록에 fx노래중 유일하게 살아있는 라차타..

Nasrul Zaffrey i swear i saw you on SNSD into the new world comment section

2019 also

well, I little bit understand what you mean, first I thought she was a man xD

Hamtatiek Princess hahaahah

same

Exceltiaawesome hahaha well i am bisexual so

***** ok true