I hope SM reads this

i think their concept was never cute it was more like you said quirky. even their debut "happiness" was trippy lol and i really love that they are naturally cute without having to try too hard.

장미 You know cuteness is a genre with hundreds of subgenres, right? Like Red Velvet, Twice, Gfriend, and Black Pink are all cute groups but they have different subgenres. Red Velvet is still very much a cute group (I mean, look at all of the aegyo in this choreography), but they are a type of quirky cute. Just like Gfriend is a powerful cute, and Twice is a cheerleader cute, and Black Pink are a badass cute group. It's all the same umbrella just different sub sections

That's my point. Like I said, if you're doing a cute concept you need something to get the public's attention. Red Velvet uses the cute concept as a base and then they incorporate their quirky and alluring sides that fans adore so much. That makes them stand out. I never denied that they're cute I merely pointed out that they also have many charms that distinguish them from other groups and make them the succesful girl group they are today.

장미 they so stupid

this is so true. Rookie's choreo is so complex and fast. You can't really notice that on stage.

Trueee

Oh I though it was just the same as all the other dances cause I just learn it In an hour just like other dances

@@haveyoueverwonderedwhyyour5133 teach me ur ways oml

@@iit3374 is that supposed to be sarcasm??

We stan a queen

FACTS

YES

she always does well with choreo like this! like look and dumb dumb. and kinda like umpah umpah, too. and maybe russian roulette. she can't dance well in heels (it's not easy and it seems to make her nervous and uncomfortable) but she dances perfectly in normal shoes. truly lead dancer material. i stan my ult gg bias

@@Chloe-sb9tf Ikr Ive noticed it too!! Shes even in the dance line. She seems a bit awkward dancing in heels but whenever shes not,, she would dance more comfortably

These are all on top of what their positions are right now (face, main dancer, main rapper, etc.)

that's a fact

I think Joy could be main singer too. Look at her in the Drama „the love and his liar“

@@CheerWeGo I think she can be the visual and the main dancer, so that's why some "reveluvs' don't like her cause they think Joy is outshining their bias

Green Witch Could be. I just never read comments about her vocals. But her vocals made her a protagonist in a music drama

Blueberry Cheesecake boring

Cipher Senpai let her be, she just a shit

IKR? She is full of charisma-sexiness :'))

Ignore Drea iKONISM. They are trolling/hating. I've seen them on other comments.

Drea iKONISM just mad because ikon is a flop,

Yaas, but to whomever's defense, the artists may or may not already be styled up before their own dance practices because it's their routine. I mean, some people get styled up all day as soon as they get out of bed, so can't really judge there.

Toktoktok yeah I'm sure they didn't think that this would get uploaded. You can tell they recorded this awhile back.

InaaFarah If you have your own opinion, just don't give bad words. You are too much. Fix it. You have to respect her/his opinion without saying stupid or something like that.

Louder!

WISH GRANTED SEULRENE SUBUNIT IS GONNA HAPPEN

it’s coming 😁

just coming from the future to tell you, IT'S GONNA HAPPEN THIS YEAR!!!

SM granted your wish 😂

Immyssi A I love Seulgi, but this is kinda annoying... let's appreciate others members too.. *excuse my english

Immyssi A i agree 😍😍😍 my lovely bear is life

dina amalia yass

Hobi's Bean Sprouts nah definitely a fact

@@limitlessizan why is it wrong tho?

Yes, with 4 others.

well hyoyeon with seulgi slays the dance room (actually all SM artists)

Yeri wrote the 'rap' section for Ice Cream Cake, how cool is that ! Check out her small rap section in Sappy followed by Irene filling in the gap, super cool ! Cheerz!

That's true.

Kkkkkkkkkk

Thank god Seulgi didn't give up. One of the top dancer for sure.

ㅇㅈ

I'm just beyond the moon watching her. 💙

Andy Ong SAME

Joe M cuz this song looks more good with dance

ice queen

red velvet's gonna be the group who has a solid stable fandom for years to come cuz theyre really talented

i stan rv but tbh yeri isnt that talented

angelica nned she may be not as talented as the others in rv but she's not far off from Joy and Irene. And compared to other groups, she would be considered very talented because she's very stable live and her voice tone is unique

i didnt say yeri is "untalented" .she has the talent but i realized that there lots of trainees out there who could do better than her. she's just average for me.i hope she improves tho

same goes to some other groups there. Even yeri can sing better than their vocalists

lmao 🤣

I just can’t 😂

Flashback to this one picture of exo with seulgi during her high school graduation 😂

IRENE:SEHUN wife child: LUHAN all of them wear black leggings lols 😂😂😂 yes all of them are pretty and good singer 😍

I see what you did there

IRENE:SEHUN wife child: LUHAN Nice one. lol

ik ik but i personally prefer the one with the white shoes.. sorry, no hate.

IRENE:SEHUN wife child: LUHAN lmaoooo, clearly the one with brown/black hair is the most talented one...

yeriiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii

Nhi Nguyễn Your words are awesome!

Scarlet Oath Because I use those words for an awesome person, so they were awesome too ❤️

same

Are you talking about another group that I won't mention that does "dance practices" with matching outfits and full makeup😂😂😂

@@robertpatterson9323 maybe 😂😂😂

@@alexraystolyar9983 🤣🤣🤣

@@robertpatterson9323 which group?

EXO's AERI I am pretty sure they're all wearing makeup, just not stage-makeup. SM would never let them perform without at least BBcream in a video meant for release to the public. That being said, it's a very natural look indeed, so props to red velvet for showing a more natural side and making the dance the focus of the video rather than their looks:)

Jozie Charles well ya its sm afterall but still its really minimal :) they look so beautiful though

Jozie Charles i know right! Make up in korea always wants to show that its natural. Im pretty sure they're just wearing light makeup.

no they're all waering makeup it's not a professional one but it's not 100% no makeup

So Eun Considering the camerawork (the way the camera zoomed down from the ceiling in the beginning of the video and then back at the end) I think SM were planning to use the footage:) if you want to see true "not-meant-for-the-public-footage" go watch SHINee's Lucifer dance practice; it was one of the first dance practice videos made public, and you can tell it wasn't meant to be broadcasted, bc there's a toilet roll on the floor in front of them to mark the centre of the room and the stripes on Taemin's shirt create strange visual illusions together with the low resolution :p Ever since EXO's debut in 2012 (the EXO members wore huge name tags covering their shirts in the dance practice video, something that clearly shows SM meant to release it to the public) SM has consciously made more polished and tweaked dance practice videos to put out more material for the fans, and many other companies have done the same. I don't think too many dance practice videos nowadays are shot without the idols already knowing it's going to be put up on KZbin, it's sometimes almost as important as the actual MV:)

Let'smakebaddecisionsandKpop Welcome reveluv 😚

Welcome to Reveluv💗

Soshi Sister almost all dance practice using this kind of outfits tho. Lol

mira abet nope.. many uses more 'sexy' 'coordinated' clothes... like they prepared it before hand (not like it is bad) but revel seems like straight out from their routine dance practice and somehow the manager asked them to try in front of camera without them knowing it will be released

YESSSS! Preach. They look amazing in their PJs and messy-hair-i-dont-care look. This is one of the reason i love RV!

Soshi Sister SM's dance practice always the real definition bout dance practice, not like "eye contact version, blablablablaa version. and the SM kids always dressed casually and no makeup, but still gorgeous

Soshi Sister but I dont like the moving camera... it hard to focus on choreo... SM should just used stand still camera like other group did....

@@이리빈-t6w it's just a joke lmao chill out. Wendy is Canadian and she'd have to change her pronunciation which wasnt familiar to her and it was cringy for her.

@@ahsian3383 She is Korean...

@@이리빈-t6w she's grown up in Canada sis

@@이리빈-t6w yes, and because of that she has a clear pronunciation between r and l.

R r that’s called growing up. Elementary school days start when you are young and high school end when you are basically an adult. She did grow up in Canada so she was raised there. Her ethnicity is korean but I’m pretty sure her nationality is Canadian. She could be korean Canadian. Point is, she is Canadian and she can speak English fluently. Yes she will cringe when hearing people pronounce a language she grew up in. It’s the same as someone from a foreign country teaching a language in America and the students are pronouncing it wrong, ur gonna cringe.

Howard Conte maknae is yeri

I had forgotten her name the time I wrote this , but I knew she's youngest(Maknae) of the group 😅😅😅

Can you tell me who is who?

She is Yeri

you shift to 3:11 of this video From left to right:- Wendy, Seulgi, Irene,Yeri, and Joy

jmas 1010 she cant do a split 😂

Global Kings EXO so true :)))))

Global Kings EXO she can now😂

Edelyn Libuna really where? It would be actually an achievement for her though

Long Minh yeah, i saw it somewhere in youtube, i was shook though😂

yeah! RedVelvet themselves said that this choreo was really hard before.

yes

Who?

@@kiera8449 a famous choreographer, he is now debuted in a Chinese Produce 101 variety show called "Chuang 2021". And the group name is INTO1. (He is a Japanese) Hope that will help

@@beiicyu6083 thanks:)

61 which one?

The girl who appears first, 0:05 :)

naaahh hahaah hyoyeon always

Roldan Legaspi hyoyeon too hahah :) ♥

Wait wth why isnt there any reply and this comment is 4 years ago...weird haha

@@waffle-ydunkedcat6105 Hey I love your username! =))

@@minhmole7640 thanks!😊

💛💛

CAN'T DENY IT

Thai Huynh She is "SM's Secret Weapon" for a reason :)

yeah! but don't forget about how talented wendy is.......

Red Velvet Fangirl For LIFE No one forgot that.

Yes she is.In fact SM artist are all rounders.

Farah Zana i love it😍😍😍

Farah Zana yasss😍😍😍😍

Farah Zana she is the center right?

usually the lead vocalist starts the song tho

juliana midlej they look good when they pick their own outfits and not by the stylists

I actually prefer these clothes to their stage outfits. A lot of the outfits that get chosen for them look really awkward or unflattering. >_

Saucy Sailor its like you picking your own outfits vs your parents picking for you haha

I think they used light make-up

Puddie Su light makeup as if foundation, bb cream or powder, yes. seeing yeri and irene face, look like zero makeup on it but who knows. I like these natural look more

Retno Dwiariyanti may i know they went Japan to celebrate Seulgi birthday or what

Retno Dwiariyanti AYEEEE

for kpop festival

Zhou Jia Hao they went there to perfrom in a festival

Retno Dwiariyanti for the Korean festival do you know The lineuo?

infires cat WELCOME

infires cat 😂👍👍👌

infires cat Me toooooo! My favorite girl group is ♡Redvelvet.♡ too

WOW SAME

They are amazing right? 😍

ins't the choreo from Rino and Ryu So-hee?

dhangplings yes

dhangplings We've been waiting for two years.

Mar Mar the intellectual jumped out

Kaori Nakano fuesjcjdjzkoweifii ufduu hv hrjfj h hrhfu j

Kaori Nakano all RV member actually

Kaori Nakano kkkk those are all ture...

me 1) you definitely cant 2) go to number 3 3) The answer is on no 1

I just fall for her 😍😍😍 I can't escape I can't even I tried but I can't I'm fall for her I love KANGSEULGI my wifeyyy 😅😅😍😍😍

we all should be suspicious they're dropping everything at 2017

I don't really understand why took so long to just post a dance practice... I mean, whyyyy~~~ Btw I'm so happy for get a fandom name and a lightstick

Amulet maybe because SNSD could possibly disband since their contracts end in August

seominty That's it! I'm afraid because if RV didn't make it to SM's expectation they're gonna be f(x) 2.0 and soon will debut a new girl group after 4 years.

This is really a shit, RV has such talented and beautiful girls, they all have good personalities, in this comeback they reached the top charts in various sites and SM still don't recognize the girls... They didn't have any concerts or reality shows, this is sad.

The Violet boring

Drea iKONISM what you got against rv tho? lmao

kim killua that person is a hater/troll, I saw him/ her on another comment.

slaygi indeed

Brianna Carter, same.

Miss my LuHan mine tooo💜💜💜💜💙💙💙💙

queen seulgii

CORRECT SEULGI = beautiful and very talented♥

Miss my LuHan slaygi 💕

queen ♥

She does get attention for everything except her dancing skills, she's so overlooked in that part.

Indeed!!!!

@Vrene i looked at ur username and now I can't stop imagining irene and V doing a dance duo

I doooooo

Irene really great dancer, I was mesmerized by her footwork here..

so debuting RV was something sm didn't do right? Lol

Chaeyoung Twice go

Chaeyoung Twice lol. debuting them ofc the right thing sm do but the TIME when they debuted RV isn't right.

^ another immature probably fake Once but yep // anyway cant wait to see Twice solo debuts oh w8

Oh raihun 666 likes 😱😂

Hwang Parlend Ik. I wont say manlier, cos no. Id say more dedicated, sharper and more professional. Smth like that

Bangtan, Suga & Tae we have own opinion, but in this one i'm also totally agree with you,, that's why she's main dancer 😊😊

Drea iKONISM you have your own opinion,, so, just go with that,, i won't ask you to like them tho, you shit!!

Drea iKONISM 아니 지금 존나 찌질해보이니깐 충고해드릴께요 ,, 안티시면 당당히 악플을 다시지 이렇게 유치하게 ' boring' ' flop ' ' ugly '라고 말하시면 누가 보면 유딩인줄 알아요 , ㅜ

I totally understand that dance practices are absolute bomb an dI love it myself. Usually however it diverts the amount of attention and views that should be gained in the original mv, where they put their most efforts. But i do love to xsee more dance practices

Hahaha! :) Yup. ^_^

agreed

장미 stupid

Drea iKONISM Talk about the pot calling the kettle black.

Drea iKONISM, don't talk about yourself like that!

rosé is yg's floor mop lmao 😂😂

rosé is yg's floor mop your username LMAO XD

rosé is yg's floor mop you got a great username

Been looking for this comment for so long. Finally, someone noticed bae's dancing skills. She's so underrated.

Bts v Up10tion right the choreography looks tiring and they looks very energetic

Thats SMTown for you, they hardly go easy on they're girl groups' dances, thats why they're my favorite!

Kaleidoscope Dream kyungsoo taught her well

Kaleidoscope Dream yes goodness gracious

Kaleidoscope Dream sʜɪᴍᴍʏ sʜɪᴍᴍʏ ᴋᴏᴋᴏʙᴏᴘ

trash우석 I think I like it(。･ω･｡)ﾉ♡

Kaleidoscope Dream multitalented beautiful natural

Let Joy Sing YES

Let Joy Sing I'm so happy. 😢👍🙏

Let Joy Sing lol :v Yeah 😂😂😂

Let Joy Sing Enjoy it while you can

Let Joy Sing ME TOO!!!! I'M SO HAPPY!!!

I'm here. :)

Lol l So before they were not perfect?

No, finally for their practice video. I should used comma after finally. It seems like wrong means. Sorry~

They've always been perfect lol

Yes I definitely agree. I'm their fan since Happiness. All of girls have their own charm^^

wow...

I'm looking for this comment, glad that I found it skskakaks

It's my favourite RV's dance =)))))

I T ' S A M A Z I N G

Yep lol. I can kind of see his style in the choreo

As 0109 seugi is flop

Drea iKONISM who's seugi

yes, seugi is flop but seulgi is slaaaayyy....

she kills me 💀

As 0109 Same

ikr

Afqh. syj she has make up here though. its just minimal. but yeah i agree she still slay otherwise

Anyway, good job Red Velvet. I hope SM release more practice videos in the future.

Rabia Y. yeah most of girl groups' choreographies are boring.

respect with your comment.

Rabia Y. okay but isnt that because of the korean girl group concepts? most girl groups are expected not to have super hard choreos in korea...just because other girl groups dont have hard choreos doesnt mean they arent talented in that area (: SM has always tended to focus more on choreography compared to other groups anyway! just my two cents (:

yes thats why i love sm. sm is art

X WALK same....she even used to be the most underrated member (when was no yeri) and people recognize my Bear unnie now...I'm so happy

X WALK me too

김블리 ugly?

haha! no.

Drea iKONISM tf u a hater?

Quilgem Entertainment Slaygi

derrick wilhoite agree

derrick wilhoite blackpink in your area (im sorry i just had too)

SomeoneDumb wew

David Dadoali || your comment is making me sad lol. Yes, i do exist at the same time with them, but for me, it's still 0% chance to see them in person 😧😭😂

Oh my gods, I didn't think of it like this...

Melody Cen yasss my bear is on fire😍😍😍😍

Melody Cen she is always in the centre of EVERY song lol

@@owenljj no she isn't? What's your point?

Roberta Mathiasㅉㅉ

Roberta Mathias ㄴ9ㅣ니ksopㅐㄷㄷ메9l7l2pX

she shined in happiness era, let seulgi shine in this comeback they all have their time

Shabrina Febriani *say it LOUDER* 📣📣📣

ice queen true let my Seulgi bear shine

I wouldn't say that, actually... I live on the opposite side of the planet from South Korea. But because I live in a city with a massive Asian population, there's a little ( and extremely busy ) Kpop store within walking distance of my home. The girls who work there tell me the versions of Rookie that they've sold the most copies of are the Irene and Wendy versions. Our Canadian dork gets LOTS of love, don't worry.

Shabrina Febriani I've been commenting about her here a lot but my comments are always unnoticed and always drown deep down