It is funny though (not ghostly)

Just like red velvet 😹 like bad boy was released on Xmas

i feel like this mv can be mashed up with red velvet peek a boo

@@nctzenid8973 yesss that would be so cool

@@nctzenid8973, hello, hello! I have seen it, I will watch it to see!

ahhh WAE a legendary concept

YESSS!

Grace Mathew I think you mean WAE. okay Im done

I see u-

I See you on every mv in the comments😂 I love your comments tho

How pun-y!

Shawol360 Why thank you :3

Best comment ever!!!!

Olivia Wonka GHOSTN RIDER FLAMING CHARISMA

Loved your comment XD

True

1 thousandth like

@@audreyodonnell166 NICE!

Nah, that's Thriller.

They should have released it on Halloween instead

marwinout say it louder😭 they are ahead of their time, even their debut song still fitted the recent kpop

ikr

I agrre

Please say it more louder.

Totally agree

Yes

I mean where is the lie

It’s like they have a magnet that just draws them in. They have the best vocalists, dancers and visuals in the business. Don’t know how they do it! Devils!

There are many false narrative about it, if you compare their behavior and treat to other Agencies you can easily debunk the false narrative. They are actually one of the best high-level Agencies. Medium and low level Agencies are much worse

lmao

Fr lmaoo

he just wanted a kiss and ended up with his lips stolen like boy

He has no lips how will he get a kiss kiss

and drugs... don't do drugs

The drink is Shawol color

Pink Shawol lol SHINee being drunk on our love. haha

Eureuthong i wouldn't blame them if they thought of that concept xDDDD

StackingTheCup hahaha ikr.

lmao

don't drink milkis and read Stephen king at the same time haha

namjoonhime I all already did Minho* is my drug😏💕

I mean, if you DON'T do drugs, you won't come up with neat shit like this... this is probably the wrong conclusion to draw and all, but... totally do drugs kids.

lmao

ON TO THE FINE BROS COMMENT BOX XD

Yes!! Let's go and request it shawols~!

Trisha Ray it's basically Beetlejuice combined with Michael Jackson's Thriller

Omg yaaasss gurl You right.

_Oh my gawd yes it does. Like teens, youtubers, elders, adults, and definitely not kids._

+kairakia it's Minho's body, key's head, Onew's nose, jonghyun 's mouth and Taemin's eyes

Long story short: SHINee is perfect

+Giereroid It's Key's. It's his head. Jonghyun's mouth, Onew's nose, Taemin's eyes, and Minho's body.

+Giereroid From what I can tell, it's Key's neck, cause Minho's body was wandering around without a neck.

+SakuyaLuigi key's body was wandering around without the neck,check the costume ps. Minho is burned later in the song😆

They can't show gore lmao

AHH THIS IS THE BEST COMMENT NSKAPPAPQ

for the aesthetic

JAJAJAJAJA🤣🤣

Simple answer would be because Kibum is part of SHINee :)

*doesn't determine music quality

@@gangse198 it often doesnt determine popularity too though 🤔

it actually does in todays world unforunately..i mean todays kids stream like crazy and even make mediocre songs hit no. 1 spots

@@avijnaroy8842 yup even rubbish songs like wap get so popular😪

Exactly☺💎❤💮😄 Only Music does💎💓

TheHolderOfTheStory LMFAO!!

With super scary basement.

TheHolderOfTheStory with a huge dungeon for trainees

Black Cat たの

With a random stealing body part lady XD

Actually is horror movies season in Korea right now.

Valerie Ann If you take Taemin, Onew and Jonghyun you get Taeyang-Eyes, Nose, Lips.....Illuminati!

100firetiger Whattttt 😂😂😂

100firetiger hahahha you're right!

Oh my I laughed so hard with your comment xD You're so right÷

Olivia Wonka and Minho's body... that's why they burnt his face xd

77midian I pissed myself when they burnt his face xD

Olivia Wonka The video is crazy as hell but at the same time the greatest !

Olivia Wonka Lucky that i could see this comment. I paused and tried to recognise for over 1 min and still didn't get who he was LOL

Olivia Wonka People said that 3:43 is the combination of Key's Head, Minho's eyebrows, Taemin's eyes, Onew's nose and Jonghyun's Mouth

It's the best song for celebrate Halloween >>> 🧡🖤🧡

dogieTA try listening to bigbang :D they're pretty different too

dogieTA As if other groups can't sing. try listening to INFINITE :D they're very different and really CAN sing.

***** Although I strongly agree with you he didn't mean it THAT way. Infinite really is good at live, they "eat their cds) ;)

***** LMAO

***** so you said that infinite are more talented in singing than shinee? No way hahahahah

Girly Mae A. Carretas they actually are :)

The way they carried him in at the beginning of the video is SHINee in my head, forever. The four of them standing in a row, held together by their grip on Jjong. I will never see them any differently. Love you SHINee

Wordddd Odd eye was mad hot

No MV for this one please. I could barely watch the live performance. Anymore and I say so long to my poor little soul 😱😱😱 #toomuchhotness #slappedthescreen

Chizom Anime they should just use their live performance where they all look *ing hot and were minho was wearing only a jacket as top, like wtf are they trying to do to us T_T

Yeah same, at the end frame where it shows the ladies face for a brief sec then a SHINee member, it's all of those features she's collected into one. I just figured it out. XD

Your not alone

Elena Ruiz Damn that's creepy

SJ if you are mentally disturbed by this watch ikon b-day

***** Zoinks!

+Ever Halloween Jinkies

I agree

Yessss! I checked just about a hour or so ago Elaine Yeo​ and there was over 800,000..... O.O

Lisa Minshew I am streaming it since this morning! Watching closely at the numbers! LOL!

Elaine Yeo Jaja same here, I didn't sleep enough because I was waiting for reach the million of views :v

1 260 347 right now :3 💖

Now you can sleep peacefully Ambar Luna :)

Iate Onewschicken I've got this video on repeat all the day but the views increase soooo slowly D:

FelineFriend83 living life? maybe they're just lazy our fandom is the worst

Do I vote ON Mnet?

19merah19 obsessing over views is really petty, though, and the fans that do it are obnoxious 100% of the time. quality > quantity.

Realest comment

Misha Schene on hold? they've been away from the kpop scene yes, but they weren't on hold. They relesed two full albums including promotions in Japan, a tour in Japan and also a world tour. But they sure could use some more promo! :D

+Misha Schene I totally agree.

You make a good point, but part of that was due to Onew's surgery. Happy to have him back :)

They wanted Minho’s body 💀

@@kiararose8896 yeah so Minho has the best body

Milan Shidae yes exactly

WELL SAID!

Milan Shidae SHINee World~!! PLEASE FOR SHINee ON MBCSHOUCHAMPION!!!!!!!!!!!! AND KEEP WATCHING THIS MV DONT JUST WATCHING IT BECAUSE OF SOME SURPRISE~!!! WE ARE SHINeeWORLD!!!!!

Milan Shidae i don't get it.. what do you mean by my favorite mv "with" snsd, suju, rv??

Sampada Sherchan i think she means that SNSD,SUJU and red velvets MVs are also her favourites

TASNEEM IFKHEIDEH it is:(((

I am..

Snakeketchup after listening to this song but also to others, it's just reminding me so much of what huge part his voice has to all shinee songs. Without him, is musically but also physically and mentally a huge part missing. I still can't believe that it's true. I thought for the first hours, that it might be a gruelsome rumor which spread, but the news are still the same 🙏Rest In Peace

Snakeketchup me 😔

I cried after hearing the news my Aunty told me that it was a blond guy I was thinking Jimin and then she told me he was in smilie I knew she ment SHinne

You're so welcome honey ❤️

i love him so much....

Farisha Kris thanks, sones. please.

thank you

He's Jonghyun if I'm not mistaken and welcome to the fandom :)

His name is kim jonghyun

He is the wonderful Jonghyun! Welcome to the fandom, there's no turning back now! :)

+Coach Couchu lamb skewers business There are tons of them. The boys are funny dorks and are so good in variety. For starters I'd recommend HELLOBABY (Its a must watch for every shawol), maknae rebellion, weekly idol, Star golden bell, Ultimate group etc., seriously there are tons.

Cool new shawol

Minho is so handsome. They're all great

3star4life I feel exactly the same, cant wait to see the dance, definitely an upgrade from "view" dance, no offense ian eastwood but I know if he had gotten this song, he could have come up with a lot more :)

***** OMG IFKR

+Cℓ_ 여왕 I wonder why no one mentions Kibum's hair... :DDDDDDDD

Stefi Vaszilev hes hair is bae too, kibum is bias :D XD

Cℓ_ 여왕 yeah, for me to along with Taemin:P

Suman Jash no I meant sex. It's a saying

Thank you so much.... exo l 's help is really needed. Plis vote for shinee in live performance charts..... they are against big bang.

Lana Sefi i view much times every day but stil 3,2 views... how to make degree again? T_T

Thank you for supporting ^^*

***** You're welcome; they are more than worthy of our support. : )

Lana Sefi Same!! A bigger EXO-L even though I've been a Shawol longer (guilty ;-;)

CheerUp2 i love him so much I'll never accept this

CheerUp2 It’s tragic that it had to be that way. Before this all happened, I was a new member of this fandom. If I’m correct, his therapist told him that it was his own fault he was feeling depressed, right? That’s what I’ve heard. If someone just kept reminding him that what he was doing was good enough, he could have still been here right now.

Why did u have to ruin this song for me

I think it's mostly because of the pressure idols go through in general. To get attention they need to show not their pefect side but THE perfect side. Just yesterday, Yeri didn't show that perfect/happy side of her in SBS Gayo Daejun I think, and people criticized her for it saying stuff like "it's important to know how to differentiate personal and professional life" and that "a kid will always be a kid", and finally "She’s had behavior controversies before and she will continue to have these in the future. She only thinks about herself". They know that she is oh so sad about Jonghyun's death but that still didn't matter to them. She's hurting and sad but she still need to smile and seem happy although it's fake lol. He was very passionate about his music and he wanted people to love him for that and for who he really is not for what they think of him. This is the lyrics of Taemin's pretty boy written by the one and only Kim JongHyun : I won’t pretend to be innocent like a puppet - Everyone talks so easily The excessive worries and rumors that surround me - I may always seem pretty, I may always seem good I may seem nice, I may seem soft, But that’s all a part of your imagination that’s over my head They say pretty boys are always like this They say pretty boys just follow along the flow of things I’m above the imaginations in your head. In one show he litteraly cried and said that not so many people want to see the real him and that no matter what he does people will always judge and have something to say. And we all know, idols just can't speak their mind and give their honest thoughts and fire back when they're being accused of something if they do so they can ruin their carreer easily. Dating news is scandal in korea and SuperJunior's Sungmin got boycotted by the fans because he got married can you just believe how stupid and absurd that is. and what's even more worse is that SM, being SM, pushed him and made him stop all his activities because the fans said they won't attend any SuperJunior's activities if he will partcipate in them. So all in all, JongHyun made his decision because he was married to the music and because he wanted people to see only that. He wanted them to care for his music and that for they make him show them. I know for sure that he is resting well and in peace right now, he's batteled this for soooo long so now he's resting in peace. It's just sad that we'll miss him and his talent and the koreans will never change their system and will always be hard on their idols. I hope these idols will all realize in the end that happiness will come from within themselves and not from the others.

he/she didn't ruin the song for you. you ruined it yourself by letting it.