I still can't believe I was there. I still can't believe I actually saw them live. Every time I think about it I get butterflies in my stomach all over again.

New to SHINee? Let me help you(: 0:19-Jonghyun- Bling bling(nickname)- Lead Vocalists 0:29- Onew- Leader 0:42- Key- Almighty Key- Appearance 0:59- Taemin- Maknae- Dancer 1:24- Minho- Flaming Charisma- Main Rapper Debut-2008 with Replay. Oldest to Youngest: Onew Jonghyun Key Minho Taemin 2008 MV's- Replay, Amigo, Love Like Oxygen 2009- Juliette and Ring ding dong 2010- Lucifer and Hello 2011- Japan Debut- Replay, Juliette, and Lucifer, Sherlock, Dazzling Girl. 2012- Korean Version- Sherlock 2013- Dream Girl, Boys meet you (Japanese), Why so serious, Green Rain, Everybody, 3,2,1 (Japanese), Colorful 2014- Lucky star( Japanese) In 2008(Rookies) They won new comer of the year and their journey continued ever since. SHINee Forever.

생각해보니 샤이니 정말 나의 인생의 반과 함께했다고 말해도 과언이아니네..저 당시에는 나는 중학생이였고 2011년에는 샤이니가 국내보다 일본에 데뷔하고 해외로 진출하던 시기라 국내 활동없이 지나간 해여서 그 때는 너무 섭섭하기도 하고그랬는데.. 영상 속 샤이니 나이가 온유가 23 종현이가 22 키랑 민호 21 태민이 19..정말 어린나이에 데뷔하고 얼마나 열심히 달려온 사람들인지.. 당시엔 내가 어렸어서.. 그게 얼마나 대단하고 엄청난 것인지 몰랐는데 그저 나의 멋진 오빠들..이었는데..내가 샤이니가 지나간 나이들을 겪으면서 샤이니가 얼마나 어린나이에 고생해서 쌓아온 것들이 아무나 할 수 없는 . 얼마나 열정적이고 대단한 일들을 했던 것인지.. 깨닫게 된다..정말 멋있고 고맙다..ㅜㅜ사랑해 샤이니 덕분에 나의 인생이 행복해요😽

If you are a new fan...always remember there are 5 stars on a group and family named Shinee :)

지금 들어도 너무 좋은 곡. 대단하다...

its scary how much i love key's parts...his voice is something else

I'm so proud of them. I remember listening to this song on my first day of high school, and after that I was hooked on SHINee. Now I'm in my second year of college and my love for them is still the same. Fighting!

Looking back the've changed so much :'3. Jonghyun definitely got sexier, Onew found his right style, Taemin looks fuller (which is a good thing), Key got fiercer and Minho got cuter; They also improved vocally, so proud! Oppas Fighting!!

Seeing this old videos always gives me more happiness I love how it always pop in recommendation Smtown KZbin channel is full of hidden treasures

Rest In Peace Jonghyun. You always in our hearts.

oh at 2:32 Taemin pass his mic. to Key and Key pass back the mic. at 2:40 .. SHINee doing that passing mic. thingy too when Taemin need to dance break... even SNSD doing it too specially when Hyoyeon need to dance break XD SHINee my favorite boy group XD SNSD my favorite girl group XD

진짜 내가 이 공연보고 종현이한테 한눈에 반했던게 생각난다 웃는게 너무 이뻐서ㅠ 거기서도 이쁜 미소 간직하고 있는거지? 보고싶다

I swear this group is pretty more fair than anyone I've ever seen. Taemin stays in the middle on songs he doesn't sing (because his dancing is just TOO good), Onew and Jonghyun aren't always in the front but they sing main vocals so it's okay. Key sings main vocals too a lot of the times so same for him and Minho doesn't sing main but he always gets his solo rap parts. God I love SHINee :3

Rest well in Paradise Jonghyun.

THEY REALLY PERFORMED THE SONG PERFECTLY !!!!!!!

WILL FOREVER BE THE BEST DEBUT SONG EVER IN K-POP!

My favorite song of shinee!

Dear SM, please read this carefully. I'm listening to Kpop since 2000 when BoA-nim debuted. I grew up with DBSK, BoA, Shinee, GG, After School, BEG... My first Kpop concert was this day in Paris. I didn't know anything about fanchant but truly when the song began, I screamed "Shinee, Shinee, Shinee". I'm still watching this video and only me knows that I spread the "Shinee" vibe. I feel emotional every time and I'm still a old school kpop songs. May our JongHyun rest in peace. Please respect our idols, they are humans, we are all.

I have a hard time watching SHINee's old videos every time I watch one especially performances of replay I get so nostalgic and I SCREAM WHEN I SEE LIL TAEMIN HNG

TAEMINAH!!!!!"! OMO.. I remember... It's been a long time since I first watched this video, and I also remember it was the first time I watched Shinee and I immediately felt for them

Old but gold, i really miss this moment

SHInee still shining💎

Taemin kills me, he is so cute ;)

I don't know why, my heart just fluttered when i saw replay performance live. Just bring me to Junior high school that i can't realize who's SHINee🥺 maybe i'm being Shawol for 2 years.. ahh i really miss this moment why i didn't realize on that time.

2019 !! Anyone?? Love the song really miss them

Our boys look and sound tired here, but still did a great job!

Just going back to this video and realizing this is the moment I fell in love with Taeminie! See you back soon. I miss Shinee ☹️

RIP Jonghyun, I miss you!

At 2:45, I love, like really really love, Jong's part ("Oh yeah yeah yeah yeah") and Jong's high notes (that's what made me love him)....2:50 Jjong almost dropped his mic. Cute!!!!!!

A year ago, this was the first k-pop video I have ever watched. I just wanna say thank you shinee, even though you may never see my comment, you guys have opened my eyes to the DAEBAK-ness that is Korea:) SHINee FIGHTING!!!!!!

Me alegro mucho de volver a verlos y ver qué el de la chaqueta roja baila y canta felicitaciones son un lindo grupo 😘

vivement votre retour à Paris 💕 la France vous attend 👍

I love their outfit here🤩 i suddenly miss shinee the legendary kpop🥺 watching 2022

2:51 Jjong almost drop his mic 🤣

OMG i love these 5 adorable idiots sooo much

この曲いつ聴いても色褪せないなぁ

At 2:33 I was like how the hell did Key get a second mic and then I realized taemin was dancing XD

jonghyun ❤ is very handsome❤❤❤❤

I love how they grow in confidence as this performance progresses.

just remembered good old days (T ^ T) ♡

Jonghyun 💖

can't believe shinee came to france when i was 10 and i missed them

The Part I Really Like In This Song Is : Taemin Dancing Solo !! I Mean I Like All the part but when taemin danced so awesome

I'm Onew-biased but I just can't get my eyes off of Taemin whenever they perform Replay.

I couldn't take my eyes of Key!! Oppa, your awesome I love your voice and you really should get more solo's

2:50 Jonghyun almost drops his mic

Taemin best dancer

I keep watching this over and over because I miss them so much... SHINee comeback soon :/

I wanna be your NOONA!!!

Jonghyun

들어도 들어도 질리지 않는 샤이니의 노래!! ^^

i Love ♥ SHINEE!!!! ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥

종현아 너무 슬픈밤이다잘가~~~

와 10년전 미쳤네ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 눈물 난다

Jonghyun fail 2:50 :')

Las piernas de taemin se mueven como si fueran de gelatina wn!

this is ma favorite shinee song, this goes for sure to ma lifetime soundtrack.

Onew, I love you, but I hate that haircut xD

11 years already ! It was my first K-Pop concert ! How I miss this time, I wish I could go back.

i think i'm falling in love with shinee since they came to jakarta last month *.*

Cool performance prince shinee!!

uploaded on my bday! BEST GIFT EVER!

SHINee are soo awesome. im very new to K-pop, SHINee was the first group that i listened to. they really are something.

Replay is really the best debut song for me.

This reminds me of when I watched SMTOWN's I AM. Made me cry realizing how much each artist has grown since their debut... Now at every concert hey go to and perform Replay it's like watching them grow while performing the song... from 2008-2012... Look at Taemin. Was still in middle school when he first auditioned with a dream of becoming a singer, then this happens and it's like watching your son be successful. But instead of that. It's a SHAWOL watching their oppas :D

Sooooooooo awesome!! Come back in France whenever you want ^^

I was there!!!! LOVED it! And i was thinking jjong was looking so happy :) And it was so cool beeing so close to Key!!!!!!!!

The queen of debut songs

watching them perform this song now just makes them look a lot older than they really are....for some reason. makes me sad and happy. they came a long way since their debut in 08. so proud of them!!!

I was there 🥰🥰🥰 my first concert

i love how they put this in a playlist so it will always replay when your finished!

I came. Like 10 times watching this. SHINee world 4 life!!!!

TAEMIN♥KEY♥ONEW♥TAEMIN♥KEY♥ONEW♥TAEMIN♥KEY♥ONEW♥TAEMIN♥KEY♥ONEW♥TAEMIN♥KEY♥ONEW♥TAEMIN♥KEY♥ONEW♥TAEMIN♥KEY♥ONEW♥TAEMIN♥KEY♥ONEW♥TAEMIN♥KEY♥ONEW♥TAEMIN♥KEY♥ONEW♥TAEMIN♥KEY♥ONEW♥TAEMIN♥KEY♥ONEW♥!!!

Ahhh this rright here~ SHINee im shitting tears of joy right now....out if my eyes.... Yesss yess 💕💕💕💕💕💚💚💚💚

god usually i dont like watching live performances but goddamnit SHINee chagned my mind on this one >.< im loving this performnce to damn much to actually press the replay button

Did anyone see it??In 2008 replay ,when tamin danced,he gave key his mic,but he forgot to take it back.But now,they doesn't have any miss.they're really improve their wrong.They're become the best idol!!Love SHINee~!!!

These 5 diamonds always shine for us ( SHINee world ) ♥️

When i watch this performance , i remember Shinee's first perfomance ..

love the way how key moved his hand/fingers....KEY

from their dancing alone....SHINEE IS THE BEST!!!!!!

The circular finger movement serves two purposes: expressing 'replay', and wrapping me around their fingers

Key isn't even breathless, it's amazing! I know it's hard to sing and dance, it takes a toll in your breathe rhythm and all that, but he sings as if it wasn't a problem!

진짜 열심히 살았다 우리 이니들.. 이때 넘애기애기하구 풋풋하네♥️ 일본 데뷔 했을 때가 벌써 몇년이 지난고야~~ 지금까지 너무 고생많았구 앞으로도 잘 부탁해♥️

most valued person. it's also the name of Onew's fanclub.

This is one of my favourite shinee performance!! Their clothing, hair, is just perfect. omg

A song this awesome in their debut? no wonder they are idols...

Bling Bling,rest well. Happy 11th anniversary,dear.😊 Love you,stay well.

I always love their hair! i dont know why but I LOVE IT

WoW, Key has strong live singing skills. They all do but he especially stood out to me!

Great performance. Please come to Florida in America

. . . .i do believe that if i was at that concert, that on top of crying blood at being able to see my fav singers live, i'd scream my lungs out, cry some more and then attempt to jump on stage lookin a HAWT mess SHINEE

I watch this everyday about zillion times on my iPod

Flawless performance! IDK how they do this and sing at the same time :)))

I donno why my tears down when I see u sing as the first one. I really miss you😊

This is pure gold 😍😭

My Jong shining star !!!! miss him , Shinee keep shining !!!

This was the first k-pop video that got me into everything and where I first fell in love with Jonghyun's voice ~

It is extremely hard to sing and dance at the same time. I tried it once and i didn't even survive in the first few verses. I praise them for doing that! YES! Even if their voices crack a lot!

If i could have all 5 members from shinee. I would be the happiest girl in the world!

Everybody in Paris were sooo lucky !! XD I wish i could see them all ! :)