진짜 명곡 ㅋㅋㅋ 1000번은 들은듯 ㅋㅋ

2023년..10년째 여전히 내 최애곡이자 애창곡..

이게 12년전 노래라는게 ㄹㅇ 돌겠음 시간이 왤케 빠르냐

갑자기 생각나서 들으러 왔는데 여전히 좋네....

24년에도 미쳐요😭

i love victoria and heechul. came here because heechul mentioned this in his heetube channel. great song.

2010년에 유럽 배낭여행 갔을 때 에미레이트항공 기내 엔터테인먼트에 있었던 노래였는데 가수가 누군지도 모르고 그냥 노래가 좋아서 한참 들었던 기억이 납니다.

제이는 지금 연습생들한테 노래 가르치고 있나보네요. 외국에도 가르치러 가고..! 앞으로도 오래오래 행복하게 살아가세요~!!

2020년 누구 없나ㅠㅠㅠ 이 띵곡을 아직도 듣는다...

하얗게 흐려진 그림 속 추억의 책장 속 우린 그저 스쳐간 안녕 돌아와 끝내 말 못하고 시간 틈새로 흘러 점점 멀어진 기억 몇번의 계절 지나 마주한 두 눈동자 아무말도 못하고 가슴이 차가운 남자가 울어요 이별에 모질던 그녀도 우네요 바래진 추억 유리조각에 베인 상처 흔적만 남아 초라하네요 파랗게 질려버린 하늘 굳어버린 입술 울컥 그립다 널 외치고 미련의 엉킨 인연의 끈 차마 풀지 못하고 다시 묻어두네요 먹먹한 가슴이 참지 못하고 달려 멀어진 니 등뒤로 가슴이 차가운 남자가 울어요 이별에 모질던 그녀도 우네요 바래진 추억 유리조각에 베인 상처 흔적만 남아 머물러 있는걸 oh stay, stay again , oh stay again 가슴이 차가운 남자가 울어요 이별에 모질던 그녀도 우네요 바래진 추억 유리조각에 끊긴 눈물속에 시간을 다시 묶어둘게 To Tie 모르죠 이별한 남자의 눈물 못견디게 난 맴돌던 지친 한숨도 지독한 그리움 목 조르던 엉킨 우리 둘의 추억을 슬픈 하늘에 보내둘게

진짜 어제 술집에서 이노래 나오길래 너무 추억돋아서 들으러옴 ..

Victoria's acting is SO GOOD in this MV. She really was into the character. The voice of this singer is amazing but i never heard about him.

21년 9월입니다 어렷을때 친구들끼리 천원짜리 모아서 노래방에서 부르던 기억이 새록새록하네요

2:27 뮤비는 기타소리 추가되서 지리네;; 거진 14년동안 꾸준히 듣는중

I finally found the MV where Heechul looks depressed You don't want to know how long I searched for this

I wish to see Heenim act in a hardcore drama. Serious roles like this would suit him.

Oh memories. This song remined me of the time I started to be interested into K-Pop. Time passes so fast

2024년 소리 질러엇

학창시절 노래방에서 엄청 불렀는데... 여전히 노래가 좋네요

먼키, 디셈버, vos, m to m 듣다가 문득 생각나서 듣는데...좋다...

노래좋다 오랜만에 입에서 맴돌기에 이게 뭐였지 하다 가사를 검색하니 나와있네. 20대때가 생각난다. 지금 들어도 너무 좋다.

간만에 듣고 갑니다 ㄹㅇ 띵곡

I'm shook Heechul brought me here but I discovered such a gem of a song. I wanna stan this group. Wow.

진짜 띵곡인데 왜 이렇개 유명하지 않지...?

Didn't know it was revived... Love this incredible song. TRAX, you will be forever missed. One of the best groups ever.

i will like all the videos that has heechul in it :D

OMG.. Heechul in this MV... Wow so beautiful😍😙

Victoria is very pretty.....but Kim Heechul.....How can a man be so GORGEOUS???

23년 지금 와서야 흥엉거렸는데 대체 제목이 생각 안나는거야,,,, 그래서 화장실 앉아서 한 30분 생각하다가 갑자기 생각나서 드러왔는데 지금도 띵곡이네,,,,😢😢

2022년엔 누구 없나요? 명곡이다...

This should really have more views. TRAX is an amazing band and they definitely deserve more recognition

원곡 감성이 너무 좋다 특히 더 스테이 이후 기타 솔로부분은 압권

during these times, Heechul could still purposely make himself cry, now he hates crying the most because he thinks he looks ugly when crying, when nothing really changes. HE'S STILL FRKN PRETTY AND I THINK THAT'S VERY UNFAIR!!! anyways, it breaks my heart seeing him cry like that or just crying in general bc it makes me imagine of how he actually cries like what he said in his twitch and YT lives, whenever he feels scared and alone and when he's reminded of his friends who're already gone. 아프지말고 행복하자...

노래 너무 좋네요… 2022년에도 여전히 듣습니다 ㅎㅎㅎㅎ

This song reminds me my early months in Seoul all by myself. I saw Jungmo at KBS and people actually shoved presents on him through the car window~ Missing those times. I hope Jay and Jungwo are well ❤️

중독성 갑이었는데 이 노래

I just love heechul with long hair

You're all here because of the viewable sm. i already knew this song since 2012. Like for those who already knew this song ☺️

It's 2022 and I'm still listening to this song!! And I'm also still crying every time I listen to this. So sad knowing that this song is unavailable in spotify. Missing TRAX so much :((

The man who has cold heart.

오늘도 듣고갑니다

TRAX’s songs are always good

So great acting skills of Heenim.. Makes me cry too.. miss him so much!!.. It's like he's in real pain.. :'(

I saw this being featured in Arirang early this year and I wasn't a fan of Super Junior back then. I didn't even know who Kim Heechul was (I know, grave sin). I remember I kept on commenting how awesome TRAX was and how amazing the actors were in this MV but I didn't know who those 2 were. I became a true ELF just this July and I just visited this now. I was so surprised to see Heenim!

When I heard this song from The Viewable SM i said that it's a beautiful song. And now I love this song so much. Even if I don't understand the lyrics I think that the song seems to be so sad.

This song is beautiful ^_^ Thank u Trax~ Heechul,this isn't your character!!...no,this is real Kim Heechul ♥

추억이 생각나서 다시 듣고보니 역시 명곡❤️

2:28 changed my life forever back in 2010

i just discover trax today cause of snsd and im glad cause their song is one of a kind

The Viewable SM brought me here First time i listened this song, it was sang by Heechul oppa on Family Outing Season 2. No wonder.. hahahah Heechul oppa is the model of this MV jjang!!!

still in love with this song a decade later , still waiting for a comeback and still in love with heechul's acting

시대를 안타는.. 명곡이라기보다 물리지 않는 곡 10년 넘게 듣는 중

오래만에 듣고싶어서 왔어~ 아주 좋아 ㅠㅠ

Omg why is this the first time I watch this ?! The song is totally good !! Trax is really a one of a kind korean band ! And heechul's acting is so good !

I watched Shinees replay, super juniors u and now this and i think Victorias acting is very good. Its sooo natural without trying and realistic. She would be a great actress.

I think many people just watched this video while ago, because of viewable SM. Honestly, I've just heard that TRAX is member of SM from that show. How pity they are, less people know a lot about them

i waited for TRAX comeback for years today i'm so sad .......but i wish you good luck

노래방에서 처음 친구들에게 배운 곡인데 아직도 스테이 어겐이 해결이 안되는 곡 ㅋㅋㅋ 노래는 여전히 좋네

I love TRAX where are you now? still watching 2018 mis him ,his voice is perfect for me , love u more ❤❤❤

너무 좋아용

22년도에 들어도 여전히 세련되고 좋다...

This was on Heenim's depression era... that's why his act looked so natural here like he was in pain for real...

간만에 핵명곡 듣고 갑니다...

I love this song...and I love Kim Heechul

Sudah 13 tahun yg lalu, dan 2023 ini saya kembali mendengarkan nya, dan itu akan membawa saya terasa kembali ke masa itu

Heechul with his (could be if he less stubborn back the) band. I love Heechul, Jay and Jungmo. Please give them lots of love. 트랙스 화이팅!! 💙💙💙

Iam here because the trax but I really miss the trax wen they were in the Japanese rock stell but I still love them and still listen to them

I forgot about this song and The Viewable SM brought me here, bringing back the old memories and feeling.. This song is so heartbreakingly beautiful~ :')

오늘 친구 보내고 이노래가 생각났어요 마지막 소절이 너무 슬프네요 "슬픈 하늘에 보내둘게"

2020 and this is still a gem!!

From elementary school to uni i still remember this song 🥺

I love TRAX ❤️

I happened to see a clip of this MV in a compilation of Kim Heechul's MV appearances recently and his acting impressed me. I often see him acting as a goofball or a heartthrob, but this MV shows that he actually has a potential for heavier drama. The song sounds great. The MV was done really well. It tugged at my heartstrings.

지금 나와도 반응 좋을듯한 명곡

This video actually made me really teary eyed. It's very touching to walk and listen to, plus when you think about it, things like this really do happen and it's so sad.

2018 and still loving this song and Trax. They need a comeback, seriously SM. I know that they change the genre now to EDM but please SM, let Trax bring back this style too. They're a rock band to begin with.

와 중학생때 진짜 많이 듣고 부른노랜데 지금들어도 촌스럽지않고 좋다ㅜㅜ

와 진짜 옛날에 노래방에서 무지 불렀었는데..추억이다

Arte en música .. excelente colaboraron ❤❤❤ la voz de Jay es muy buena❤

2019 is the year when this MV finally reaches 1M views 😭😭 why did it take this long??

I really wish Heechul would act in a drama with a good story like secret garden, something that would get high ratings so people would know how much of a good actor he is, I really like the way he acted that crying scene, Victoria is good too, and that is a beautiful song indeed.

I got here bcuz of jungmo, i cant belive i didnt kniw this group, all i know in sm is EXO,SNSD,SHINee,SUJU,NCT i kennet THEYRE SO GOOD I WISH THEY COMEBACK 👻👻, ITS LIKE MY NO.1 BALLAD SONG NOW WOW JUST WOOW!! I CAN'T BELIEVE IT !! I REALLY WISH THEY COMEBACK ❤❤❤

aish...im crying..........can't stop my tears even i don't understand this mv..... heechul is such a good actor TT^TT i miss you heenim oppa

2023 I’m still listening to this song

I came here because of The Viewable SM, but I already knew this song since 2010 because of Heechul and Victoria. This is really sad how SM artists get this kind of prejudice in South Korea. Many hidden songs in SM artist's album which is really good T.T

트랙스 20주년 축하드려요

Hee Chul and Victoria are have good action in this MV. TRAX's singing voice is very softy

신기하네요 이 노래를 들으니 그 시절의 기억들이 다시 살아나요. 좋은 영상 감사합니다.

Love MV version .. Guitar solo part is the greatest !!!!!!!

no wayyy 12 years already ??????? please come to California for showwwwww

magnifique chanson avec Heechul dans le clip

I'm so touched with Victoria's acting, I'm a theater member but when i act drama?, my tears won't fall, ahehe :), I'm impressed with Victoria's acting. GO VIC.

2010~2011년 중학생때 생각난다

This video always gets to me...Such a beautiful song...It's hard to see Victoria like that...She's always so energetic and happy.

I cried when i finished watching

I loose my cool every time I listen to this song. When that solo part from Jungmo´s guitar starts...my tears starts to fall.

아니 이노래 나만 좋은가..

heechul is such a good actor, but seeing him crying makes cry too. i think heechul will be a good boyfriend XD. saranghaeyo kim heechul oppa.

2017,and I still watch this

My favorite Trax song...it's just so pretty (and it has Heechul starring in one of the saddest MVs ever)