"what did you wish for?" "mm.. what did you wish for?" "I wished that next year I'll spend Christmas with a boyfriend. What did you wish for?" "To not spend next Christmas with you" So sad ;;;;

The black haired girl is an amazing actress... Felt her emotions... The confusion for liking same gender the hurt, the happiness with her... It all feels raw.. Wow

wait... that ending.. so sad

The fact this is the Irene's favorite mv

Ah, Irene. Of course, this would be your favorite MV.

this is a great mv with the right amount of human touch, and speaks of the painful truth for those who falls in love with someone of the same gender. it's not just about unrequited love; she showed a lot of signs that she wants to tell her how she feels, but she couldnt because it will ruin the friendship. this is beautiful, SM should learn that music videos dont always require high costs. this video was made with quality and made from the heart.

Red velvet is the warmest colour

can you believe red velvet ended homophobia

2:52~3:05 까지 내 기준 압권 장면... 사진 찍어주려고 하는데 휴대폰 화면 속 피사체에 순간적으로 집중하는... 진짜 찐사랑이다...

다시 또 봐도 대사 없어도 표현들과 노래랑 너무 잘 맞고 느껴져서 울컥하게된다ㅠㅠ 어떻게 담담한듯 하면서 좋아하는 마음이 느껴지고, 상대는 모르는 마음으로 마지막에 눈빛이랑 인디언보조개랑 너무 예쁘다

the short haired girl is cute af

brown hair : What was your wish? black hair : you first brown hair : hmm...i want to be with my boyfreind next Christmas. How about you? black hair : .....my wish is dont be with you next chistmas

me: *having a sexuality crisis* red velvet: *do this* ://///

I'm not surprise why this song is Irene's fav song😆

이주영님.. 그저 사랑.... 헤녀 짝사랑하는 레즈 역할이라니 저 울어요 방금 벽 뿌시고 왔다 이주영님 연기력에 제가 또 눈물로 한강 범람시켰잖아요 그저 사랑.. 이주영님 꼭 행복하시고 탄탄대로 배우길 가시길....... 흑

마지막에 망설이는 장면 연기력 ㄷㄷ

와 진심.. 이게 아마추어 작품이라구요?ㅜㅜ??... 영상미도 스토리도 너무너무 좋다ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 리얼 참 고퀄ㅠㅠ

i relate to the girl w black hair ,,, even I fell in love with one of my best friends but I could never tell her :( not only bc she is straight but also bc I didn't wanna ruin our friendship

The fact that I didn't know this existed until now... I feel so ashamed

it's a shame that not all 'reveluvs' know this one hell of a masterpiece

짧은머리 여자분의 연기가 정말 인상깊다...연기 잘하신다...

와 ...3대 걸그룹 공식 뮤비중 퀴어 뮤비가 있다니...이렇게 애틋한 사랑...레드벨벳 짱입니다.배우분들도 짱입니다. 여성팬들이 대부분인 이유가 다 있다

The short-haired girl looks like a combination of Dahyun and Jungyeon :D

주영언니... 난 이때 알아봤어.... 언니... 톱스타 될 거라구.... 중말 사랑해... ㅠㅠ

This song will really hit you if you experience unrequited love.

I came back here because I remembered that Irene and Seulgi celebrated their birthdays together while trainess and hoping they spent their christmas like how these two spent asvsjucasuvcausk

LEE JOO YOUNG?? Came back here after itaewon class

아 너무 슬프다 쟤는 헤테로겠지 생각하고있으면서 내심 속으로는 혹시 쟤도 나와 같은 마음은 아닐까 수백번 생각하고 고민하다 결국은 또 뼈맞고 나도 헤테로인척 하는거ㅜㅜ

1년 내내 아껴뒀다 연말이면 정말 소원이 이뤄지길 바라는 심정으로 꺼내듣는 노래인데 매년 봤던 뮤비 속 일상적인 겨울의 모습이 너무 그립다... ㅜㅜ

Fun fact : you're here because you miss red velvet in this 20201Christmas 🙂

OMG those waffles look amaaazinggg

이주영님 얼마전에 알게 됐는데 마스크도 그렇고 매력적인거같아요ㅠ 이런 영상도 찍으셨네요 연기도 영상도 예뻐요❤️

came back for Lee Joo-Young after her debut in weightlifting fairy !!! Ah I knew she looked familiar, IM SO PROUD OF HER

hi i am back over here after 4 years just to say that there is no heterosexual explanation for this and that i am successfully bisexual now!

Irene always says Wish Tree is her favourite song and I can understand why:((

The girl with short black hair reminds me of D.O. whenever she smiles

이거 보고 나서부터 엄청 좋아했는데 지금은 엄청 유명해지셔서 좋으면서도 먼가 하 말로 표현할 수 없넹 ㅠㅠ 언니 어제 연기 너무 좋았어요

졸라 슬퍼 이게 모야 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅜㅜㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 진짜 잔인하다..,.,.,.., ㅠ유ㅠㅇ유ㅠㅜㅠㅠㅠㅠ

이주영 배우,,,진짜 사랑스러운 사람같음...ㅠㅠ 특히 여성애, 레즈 이런 역할이 너무 잘 어울리고 정말 사랑을 아는 사람같아 보이고 막.. 너무 멋지고 예쁘심..&&ㅠ

사랑이 이루어지지 않아서 슬프지만, 그 관계성도 마음에 드는 뮤비! 마음이 아리면서도 따뜻하네요

I ship it

RV VOCALS KEEP SLAYING HUHUHU

Cant believe I only saw this now. Now I know why Red Velvet is SO popular with the lgbtq+ community. They have been showing support since their early days! I love them so much!

아니 나는 왜 자꾸 눈물이 나지ㅠㅠ 여자랑 연애 해본적도 없는데ㅠㅜ 아진짜 슬프다..ㅠ

It's December, and this will be the Song on repeat on my playlist for the whole month.

Aw this melts my heart. I love the fact that South Korean entertainment is slowly taking steps towards showing LGBT related stuff.

차가운 유리 창 너머 반짝인 불빛 시린 거리는 첫눈을 기다려 조금씩 또 조금씩 번져가는 기쁨 속에 울던 아이도 잠이 드는 밤 얼어붙은 저 나뭇가지 위로 한 송이 또 한 송이 내려 앉는 눈 꽃송이 그 아래 우리 둘 두 손 가만히 꼭 잡고 소원을 빌어봐요 첫 번째 소원 너와 나 오늘처럼 행복하길 두 번째 소원은 몇 번의 겨울 지나도 꼭 함께 이길 또 세 번째 소원은 지금 바란 모든 게 다 이뤄 지기를 산타를 만나기 위해 줄을 선 아이 반짝이는 눈빛 해맑은 미소 어리던 그 날엔 나도 그땐 그랬었지 향긋한 Gingerbread Christmas Tree 위에 작은 꽃눈이 뿜어내는 향기 그 안에 수줍게 꿈꾸는 봄 한 송이 그 아래 우리 둘 두 손 가만히 꼭 잡고 소원을 빌어봐요 내 첫 번째 소원 너와 나 오늘처럼 행복하길 두 번째 소원은 몇 번의 겨울 지나도 꼭 함께 이길 또 세 번째 소원은 지금 바란 모든 게 다 이뤄 지기를 천사가 내려와 내게 입맞춘 것 같아 눈꽃이 피어나요 Yeah 첫 번째 소원 너와 나 오늘처럼 행복하길 두 번째 소원은 몇 번의 겨울 지나도 꼭 함께 이길 또 세 번째 소원은 지금 바란 모든 게 다 이뤄 지기를

Shut up luvies no one talking about this being in "The 100 greatest music video artists of all Time " billboard?

Came here after watching itaewon class. I can't believe it's been 4 years since i first watched and knew lee joo-young. When i watched this mv, i knew that she'll have a bright future and here she is. She's such a great actress xoxo

after 5 years of listening to this, my wish still the same.. and my besfriend still wishing for boyfriend, while i wish it's me :) i just want to share this.. an hour ago, she's planning bout christmas, i know exactly what she's meaning, and i came here to cry

everyone keeps asking about the new songs and all but can we appreciate how the winner was able to fit the scenes to the lyrics so well? I could actually picture this song being used for a completely happy romantic song, and yet here there's a twist that it's actually heartbreaking- I have to say, this is now one of my favorite music videos-

I really love Red Velvet singing ballad songs, they have such angelic and beautiful voices. Candy, Wish tree and First Time are my three favourite songs of Red Velvet!!

streaming and ugly crying over this on the 6th year anniversary of red velvet

친구들에게 드디어 커밍아웃을 하고 이 노래 또 찾아왔습니다. 다 잘 됐고 그들이 날 위해 행복한다고요... 이 기분이 좋네요.

퀴어물은 정말 취향에 안맞는 사람인데... 이 영상만큼은 마음이 너무 아프네. 절대 이뤄질리없는 사랑

Is this the first lesbian MV??? OMG yassssss At the end the girl with the longer hair wishes for a boyfriend and the girl looks disappointed because she likes her

아직도 겨울되면 가끔 보러와요🥹 특유의 몽글몽글한 감성이 진짜 좋아요..☃️🧣

숏컷트 여배우분 어디서 많이 뵌거수같았는데 '게임회사 여직원' 에서 주현이하고 같이 나오신분이네요 노래는 언제들어도👍

red velvet paved the gay

It's 2019 but i'm still crying over this mv

Red Velvet songs are nostalgic. It's 2021. I better leave a mark.

아씨 이즈ㅜ영 미쳤나봐 어ㅏ

for those who are curious the short conversation at the end: longer haired girl: What was your wish? short haired girl: well, what did you wish for? longer haired girl: Hmm, spending my next christmas with a boyfriend or something like that! What about you? short haired girl stops for a second then says: me, mine was spending next christmas not with you. (or without you).

They recorded this song for christmas 2015 project and i think then they made competition for the music video and this one win. Really suits the vibes, wish tree really a nice songs. I wish more people found this

크리스마스가 오면 생각나는...유독 추운 올해도 모두 메리크리스마스!!

이주영씨표정연기너무좋아요!!!

I love that SM Entertainment choose this entry that has a lesbian theme. Bisexual and proud 🤘🏻

와...진짜 감정선 여운이 오래남는 영상이네요ㅠㅠㅠ 영상미도 좋고 배우분들 연기도 너무 좋고 굿..

I'm glad that SM and RV adopted this FMV as the official one. It's beautiful.

Deserves more views. This song is so touching. Plus having a girlxgirl theme MV? Brave.

anyone here after psycho cuz it's christmas eve?:)

I'm so happy that this is LGBT and SM is supporting the LGBT community.

Literally one of my favourite songs from Red Velvet

❤come back and listen to this song every Christmas

진짜 주영언니 ,,,,,,, 나의 마음을 받아줘,,,,,,,,,

I came back after watching Game Dev Girls with Irene and notice the girl who plays the role of Pudding is the same short hair girl of this mv

lowkey proud of her for telling her that at the end so she doesnt hurt herself anymore... self love first

that short haired girl looks so much like Jungyeon from twice^^

Lee Joo Young so freacking cute. I love her from the first her mini drama Home Sweet Home, fighting lee joo young

well i fell in love with my best friend(we are both girls) who has a boyfriend and now i can't stop crying while listening to this song

Came back here 'cause i fell in love with my friend who is the same gender as me 🤩

Man, this is so cute, but I wish this got more recognition. Not enough know about this masterpiece.

Probably one of those simple yet heart melting music videos. Thank you for this 😭

크리스마스 기념으로 아주 오랜만에 다시 보러왔어요 여전히 노래도 뮤비도 좋네요 닿지 않을 그 사람도 모두 메리크리스마스

I just now know that this MV existed. Yet another reason to love Red Velvet even more.

OMGMGMGFMMGOFMF IVE BEEN LOOKING FOR THIS MV!! The short haired girl, i think she's from weightlifting fairy kimbokjoo!!!!!

진짜 이런거 쫌 제발 쫌 해 스엠

This is the first red velvet song i've ever heard. So this song has a special place in my heart 💖

I'm back here to say Merry Christmas to everyone Merry christmas to all reveluv🎄

추워지면 꼭 봐야되는 뮤비,,

Red Velvet’s 3 wishes: 1.Forever Together 2.Comeback with fans 3.All members are healthy and without any bad news *Merry Christmas everyone*

Hello.......LGBTQ+ community✨

It’s really painful falling in love with someone, but you can’t or it’s difficult to tell them because you don’t want to ruin the friendship that you have with that person;( I love Red Velvet so much for making this❤️

헤녀 좋아하는 퀴어잖아... 내가 다 눈물 나네...

here because lee jooyoung (the short hair girl) is in the movie Broker which was shown at the cannes film festival 😮 i know it’s not her first big role or anything but i will always remember her in this video ❤️🫶

날이 추워지면 젤 먼저 떠오른다...

i hope that SeulRene is filming this MV

난 스엠이 이래서 좋아... 정말로... 이때부터 이주영 나오는 영화 다봤다

I missed this song! I hope next Christmas we still here

Ok why is this song so underrated... this song deserves so much more than this. 0% curses 0% nudes 100% pure vocals