Tbh this song is criminally underrated. It might not be as exciting or unique as Black Mamba or Next Level, and I know ballads aren't everyone's cup of tea, but their vocals on this track are really beautiful and the harmonies are really top tier.

When black mamba releases, everyone is a main dancer and when Forever releases, everyone is a main vocal! No one can do it like Aespa!

This song is proving that aespa can pull off any genre of music

I miss aespa era as a rookie😢 Without realizing, you guys really grew up so fast. Keep chasing your dreams my dear aespa ❤❤❤❤

Firstly, got amazed with Winter's Voice Second, got amazed with Giselle's voice Third, got amazed with Karina's Voice Four, got amazed with Ningning's voice This is proof that all member AESPA are vocalist.

I can see that SME's goal with aespa isn't solely focused on creating or breaking records. SME is showcasing these girls' incredible musicality. I mean, no one saw this concept coming. It's fresh. A Christmas-y song in February? They are defying rules. SME is proud of these talents' vocals. Literally, all of them are vocalists. That part which they take turns in making ad libs and runs is just pure art! SME had always prioritized their artists' singing prowess. I love this music!

These girls are a miracle that fell into the hands of SM

One thing i love for Aespa. All of them are singer. I really like their voice.

Popular opinion: Aespa's rappers aren't just rappers, they're also great vocalist and iconic dancers

Their visuals, their vocals, the MV, the outfits, everything is PERFECT

This basically proves that Karina, Winter, Giselle and Ningning are now eligible to sing for OST's. Like did you hear that? WOW.

i dont get why people dont like this like this is a masterpiece

Giselle slapping those haters why she passed the hardest SM auditions..Main Rapper Giselle did that

Help, now we know aespa can do anything. This is not just any song, it depicts the 90s so well and their gestures are so properly coordinated. It's a very unlikely song for their generation but here they are, pure slayage! Truly SM the master and plays this game too well. Speechless! Brilliant!

I think we all can agree that this remake exceeded everyone’ expectation. What 𝑎𝑒𝑠𝑝𝑎 gives us is beyond our imagination.

This is beautiful.

aespa nailed both Black Mamba and Forever. It makes me wonder what kind of music aespa will bring to us next. Definitely looking forward to it, especially for our rapper Giselle.

SM vocal never fail me. They aren't mere idols who belt shouty notes out or 'selling' vocal timbre. They definitely have the technique! Solid chest, smooth head, nice runs. Super proud orz

black mamba: older sibling that paved the way for the rest of the family forever: forgotten middle child next level: younger sibling that got all the attention

no way aespa has this vibe of songs😭

this is one of the few ballads that I don't find boring, these girls can adapt to every concept can't wait for their album

1)This song showed that they all can sing 2) I hope the next comeback is going to be be a fast song where Giselle and Karina are rapping 🖤🐍 3) There debut Black Mamba was the best debut song of all kpop idols for me

I can’t believe these girls are the ones who sang black mamba and next level

너희가 제일 맑고 너희나 계속 행복하고 내가 너희 옆에 있을게 천사같은아이들아 .. 너흰 내 첫눈이다 ☃️

why aespa is going to be the most succesful gg in this decade: they can DANCE (Black Mamba), they can SING (Forever), they can RAP (Next Level), and they are SAVAGE af.

DAMNNNN, those runs and vocalsss they be flexin' everything as a rookie monster

It's so rare to find a group where each member can actually sing. I'm freakin happy SM created Aespa!

Now this is real music.

This song is like telling the relationship between member and ae-member who can't get together because of the black mamba and also the relationship between aespa and my who can't meet because of the covid-19. It is full of meaning that we will stay together forever. Let's be together forever. aespa and my Will be forever

This comeback is Winter focused as 'Black Mamba' was Karina focused. It's honestly great idea for a concept! Can't wait for Giselle's rap song and Ningning's, probably ballad, song!

The genre of this song is like the OSTs for old Kdramas. This song feels nostalgic, I don't know but listening to this song brings back my childhood memories of being innocent while watching old Kdramas, barbie movies, and old Asian romantic series with kind male leads that made me believe in prince charming and knight in shining armor. (which is I don't believe now AHAHHAHAA)

Best vocal

I like how SM is not just following trends and is giving them songs to showcase their talents

This song is so forgotten and it is criminally underrated

The only thing Christmasy about this is the snow. It fits Valentine’s Day better. The VOCALS overshadowed everything. 🥰

4 Vocalist 4 Rapper 4 Dancer 4 Visual

This actually sounds like an OST for some romantic drama. Ig it is a Valentine's day song. Aespa members are such aces I mean they are slaying everything they are doing.

Aespa showed her dance in the first song, visual and vocal in the second song, then rap era will be in the next song so I hope so.

They're all literally all rounders. Singing bops like Black mamba and then calming music like Forever

one of my favorite songs of aespa

Forever is almost a year old, idk why it doesn't get the recognition it deserves. This song helps me relax and cheer up sm

Their vocal is no joke. Giselle proves that she was on the choir team, her voices nice to hear. Karina, how she rapp and singing has different color voices. And so stand out! Winter and Ningning, no comment, they are amazing!

*"SM may not be the greatest, but SM has the greatest"* Looks like AESPA is continuing the legacy as well! Such great vocalists! Im a Reveluv by the way :)

This songs deserves so much more. 🎀

The main rapper can really sing. Before forever came out. I love watching Giselle teaser cause pf her rap skills but my goodness she can sing

I mean they are SM artists, of course all of them can sing, not just the main and lead vocalist even the rapper and dancer too

Aespa's vocals are no joke. Winter - angelic voice Giselle - soothing voice Karina - calming voice Ningning - 4th gen main vocal AESPA FOREVER!!!

How can there be people who don't like this song?

This is something the old SM would do. Not beeing affraid to release mv for ballads like not searching far SNSD's Time Machine.

people really can't appreciate this kind of music that much? compare to their other songs ,this is my vibe.

this BLACK MAMBA girls are on the NEXT LEVEL and will be FOREVER in my heart

i will never be tired of this song

vocals, visuals, giselle’s black hair, short haired ningning, aaAaAaa everythinggg is just perfect!!!!!!

I cannot stop listening to this song and it’s such a different pace than what their peers are currently releasing that I’m surprised that I actually like this so much. BEAUTIFUL LADIES ❤️ old school or not I STAN

Usually I don’t really like ballads, but this song stuck with me

this is aespa's year no one can change my mind. banger after banger

Aespa, the rookie group who’s doesnt afraid to showcase their vocal ability instead of releasing a loud/noisy trend songs.

Gisselle's perfect vocals even when she's the main rapper ????? Aespa vocal line = all the members

*Popular opinion: Everyone in aespa is a visual and talented*

This song so sweet

I feel like we haven’t seen songs like this (slower kinda throwback songs) as a single and this makes me happyyyyy

1st time when i heard Aespa's Black Mamba, i shocked with Winter's pretty voice. And this time i got a goosebump by Karina and Giselle. So refreshing. And ofc Ningning our main vocal, i know her unique voice from the start. They're so talented ❤️❤️❤️❤️. I can't wait for their comeback

So in AESPA : all members are visual, all members are main-vocalist, all members can be main dancers. Why I wouldn't be surprised if all members can rap. That's AESPA. Stan Aespa, Stan Talent

이제 곧 2024년이야 ,, 🥺🥹

NINGNING AND THE COMPUTER SHOULD JUST LIVE TOGETHER FOREVER

I don't care if Christmas was 2 months ago, this song is still beautiful

OMG ...GISELLE PROOF US THAT HIS VOCAL ARE NOT PLAYING WITH US

they've grown so much ahhhhh can't wait for the full album

Their vocals are so relaxing I'm crying🤧😭

Karina's charismatic and elegant voice, Winter's sweet and pretty voice, Ningning's powerful voice and technique vocal, and Giselle's charming voice, makes me more fall in love with aespa.

They all are visual and vocal. No one can't sing. Amazed with karina too cause she is rapper

2024년에 듣는 사람 나 밖에 없나..?

This song is a remake of Yoo Young Jin's "Forever". It is not a cover nor their original . The remake ver is theirs but the song is Yoo Young Jin's and he himself rearranged the remake. This is a promotional single and the main cb will be after some time

This is not the actual comeback of aespa. Forever is a song by Yoo Young-jin which was originally released in 2000 and now aespa made their own version. Forever is a great song. It showcases their vocals. Wait for their actual comeback. There is a rumor that aespa will comeback with their first mini album. And in their comeback we can already hear Karina and Giselle rapping. I hope you can wait! MYs, let's be with aespa forever!

black mamba: dance forever: sing next level: rap

ほんとに好きな曲✨いつかはLIVEで聴きたいな❣️

Only in aespa we get visual with killer voice, rapper with killer voice, main dancer with killer voice. No other group have that. So conclusion stan aespa

Karina high note seriously surprised me is like she was meant to do vocal but since she can dance and rap sm gave her that ,i also feel the same way for Giselle lmao

This is the proof that every member can be a Main Vocalist.

i wonder when i can finally say "Congrats FOR 100M!" to this MV

IT SEEMS LIKE THEY ARE ALL VISUAL AND VOCALIST !!

People saying that It's still Christmas season because of this song,, it extends to Valentines Day celebration! AESPA SAID THERE'S FOREVER💖

Agree with me on this, SM really knows how to train their vocalists.

she's not only powerful,

This proves that aespa is not just a knockoff group.

Their choreography for Black Mamba showed how talented they are at dancing, while Forever shows how amazing their vocals are ♡

AESPA doesn't realize This, but they are making everyone's day better.

4 vocalists, 4 rappers, 4 dancers and 4 visuals

10M - Complete 20M - Complete 30M - Complete 40M - Complete 50M - Complete 60M - Soon aespa is FOREVER in MY's heart

10M views nicely done MYs I mean it wasn’t our goal but this song isn’t a lot of people’s taste but this is a huge step for us. If we can get views on the ballads then imagine the mainstream songs

This isn't really aespa's first comeback, it's just continuing the tradition from SM, to re-record their old songs. so please wait for the next real 1st comeback from aespa, please give more love in the future, aespa will show the next level from black mamba :D

다른 에스파 곡들은 에스파!!!!!!!!!하는 느낌인데 이거는 에스파♡하는 느낌임

I don't get why people didn't like this song, it's amazing

can we all agree that aespa have the best vocalists in 4th generation of kpop? even their main can be a main vocalist

If someone asks "Who's in Aespa's vocal line?" . The answer would be, ALL of THEM!!!! SM vocals 💯

i remember that back in 2020 when i first saw this mv for the first time i thought they were androids because of how unreal & how synchronized they were lmao

It's hard to find these type of soothing ballads by 4th gen groups, but aespa is an exception for this!!!They can confidently sing any type of songs... What a VERSATILE QUEENS 🤧💗!!!

Ok but this song should has been released during Christmas period cos this song gives me so much Christmas vibe in it

Aespa is a whole package group. To those who disagree, argue with the wall idc idc

So comforting.