I feel sad because i never knew who was Sulli until she was gone i now knew that she was in the group in which amber was I never said any hate thing about her

I wouldn't say people are hypocrites necessarily because it's not the people who hated her that now give her love. I just think hate shines out a lot more than love and unfortunately, no one understands how much hate can affect and hurt a person until it's too late and the damage is already done. It only seems like she's getting a lot more love now because of the tragic news of her death and online cyber-bullying for being herself. It means the haters have shut up and more people have heard about Sulli and looked more into what she did and who she was and come to love her work. A lot of people are too ignorant or just simply don't care what someone's going through or how their actions/words will affect them until it's too late and that's a huge flaw in today's current society.

even then because fake care about the idols and only doing it because everyone else is

stop commenting about sulli let her rest in peace with out commotion

I stan Jin’s holy forehead FOREALLL

:(

Nasrul Zaffrey That makes me cry

Noo :((

Does anyone know if any of the members still talked to Sulli.

*i know it aches*

Damn this is messed up.

I really thought Jonghyun was the wake up call....😞

@@Ban-nq2gy EXACTLY. How many more people do they need to suicide before they realize things need to change.

ThisKpopGuy 😞😞

@@rain1676 For the loop industry and for fans. This should never have happened. Jonghyun and Sulli and anyone else who commit suicide should never feel as though that's the only option. But they did which means we as fans and companies as those in charge need to do something!

Sulli ❤

And now I'm crying.

무한도전

5 angels

Shinee too

FOR REAL OMG

They were popular, they just got forgotten because of another group.

@@6682j which other group?

@@Madelyn07 kzbin.info/www/bejne/q4ObfqWqZq6jjsk

Yes. Their concept are quite to advanced

This really pisses me off.

😭😭😭

I heard it was the result harassment and bullying. Very sad. Apparently this type of bullying used to be so common that the Korean government instituted laws that people to be identified if they post online. You can’t be anonymous, though that might only apply to Korean sites. There are some very deep problems in Korean society when combined with the suicide endemic.

I'm sorry but which one is Sulli in this music video? Can someone point out what time stamp/s? Thanks.

@@jrandrewortega2861 2:41

True 😂

same 😊😊

저도요

멋쟁이잖아요코디가..😊😊😊

φιλε ναι:(

Damn💔😢😣😣😔😭😭😭

Μαρία Γιορδαμνή omg😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭💜💜💜💜

But she couldn't do it

I never knew sulli and when my mom told me about her death I didnt know who she was until my friend told me it was from FX but wow this is probs one of the saddest comments

동의합니다

Well what do you expect when they are unofficially disbanded? I mean SM also doesn't talk about their girl groups S.E.S. or CSJH, so f(x) is not the only one

Sm forgets about shinhwa too lol

IKR???? Kinda sad whenever I remember about Sulli as well in addition to what you said, I was more into fx than snsd tbh

What you expect? They literally disbanded

2024

Wow, only 25 years old!!

길 돌아다니면 누에삐오 피노키오 나오고 설리 피파2 광고모델로 발탁되서 pc방 들어가면 벽보로 여기저기 붙어있고 보면서 와 천사인가 싶었는데 진짜로 천사가 됄 줄이야 ㅠㅠ

park chaeyoung PERIODT

Yes

YASS.

My mom bring her to kpop with this song

This brought me into kpop.

I start to lose hope and trust ab this life ... it's painful.

Yup me too

Whats wrong with the netizens??!!!

Same😢😢

I too.wept into tears.innocent sulli

Urban legend 😂

I Stan fx forever 😽💕 R.I.P my Angel 🥺

Sorry, I'm from Indo.

mwhaha while i'm not kpopers but i really love this song😂💅

YASSS

People would praising the visual between Krystal and Sulli.

wtf are you talking ??? Fx was one of the most popular groups of their generation

@@yeyosilver7067 but, the company was mistreated this group and all of them were quit the group,also one of the idol of the group was depressed towards the hatred comments while the company were doing nothing to stop them.

@@agassifarhan774 And ? what makes you think that debuting "today" things would be different ??? What happened to Fx is sad, but Fx was only what happened because of SM and nothing changes the fact that they were big

Agreed. I love their songs and i regret only starting to listening to them.

soleil garcia agreed..i mean i actually don’t know her before she passed away..but then when i saw the news about her that suicided her self because of a depression cause by cyberbully she receive.. i began to watch over all fx mv..watch all her act..and i can tell that she’s talented..she had a good voice..she’s beautifull..she had a nice smile..good posture..good in acting..i mean she is good and i really don’t understand why she receive so much hate with all the criteria i ‘ve mention..she deserve a love not hate..i can’t find anything wrong from her..poor sulli..she’s so young yet gone too soon in a tragic way

that is what society does. they hate you for who you really are and love you for who you're not. so twisted

This case is about illuminati

@@gibra2510 agree with you..i dont understand why..she talented and beautiful..

I am a Korean who liked the music of fx and Sully's appearance lightly. Because she wasn't very interested, she didn't know her insides, and there could be incidents that weren't written on the eagle. I'll share what ordinary people like me know. (It's not very readable using the translator.) Sully was like SM princess until 2013 and she was a promising entertainer. After the scandal with Choi, she was sexually taunted and mentioned as a shining idol and muse, not as a B-list image. SM tried to do Sully both as an idol and an actor. But 2013?There's a rumor about a relationship with hip-hop duo 'choi ja' in 2014. But the funny thing is, the reporter didn't blow it. Ordinary citizen picked up Choi's wallet and there were pictures with Sulli. Their age difference (Suri was a single-parent family, assuming she had Daddy issue in her male tastes) and nicknames ('choi ja' is a big penis in Korean).SM was still trying to hide the rumor about love, but the fact is that the man lost his wallet in a wild way. Of course, Koreans think Choi intentionally dropped it. And Choi continued to mention Sulli on the show, wasting her image and even releasing sex songs. Other rappers continue to use Sully for their rap. Choi is not dissuaded. People criticize Choi, but Sully also begins to tease. But Sully leaves the fx group on her own. So, the activities of the fx were cancelled and fell over. That's why fans of Fx blame Sully, too. Fx was nearing its peak, and Sully was still a promising 19-year-old, caught up in an old rapper and started to deviate. I think the man suggested it. And, although Choi is not already a mature man with the above-mentioned actions, I'm sure she wasn't a good lover. Whenever Choi left Korea on a tour, Sully posts provocative and creepy pictures (represented in the picture of a living eel being burned to death) so she is cursed again on the Internet community. She was too young to be responsible for her situation now. I've often expressed acts of insecurity. I even posted a movie poster expressing sexual assault between lovers (this issue was not in the spotlight, so it's sad.) And then there was a rumor that he tried to kill himself. SM hid this fact, but I think it would be better to get a big report and get sympathetic public opinion. And Sully did a lot of movies, but it's all ruined.The movies are really bad. And the interview and attitude at the premiere were poor, and she was instantly criticized and humiliated by the senior actor. After that, Sully shot a pictorial, and I'm very motivated by the Lolita controversy. At this time, feminism issues were growing in Korea, and pedophilia issues were huge, and it was a photo shoot of a representative writer and pictorial of the Lolita concept. Over time, I uploaded a photo with a nipple exposure without bra. It's an issue again. The events I remember are about this much and there's probably more. I personally think the fx fans have persistently criticized it, even though it was all over the community. This time, the police said there was a personal history of her suicide. Sully's mental health was weak, and she was on a show called "The Night of Bad People" and she was having a hard time. It wasn't a pleasant program. Also, her older brother, who lived with her, left home for a long time, and a very close friend went to study abroad. Many people say she was very lonely and decided to commit suicide on impulse. I ordered food over the Internet until the night before. Koreans thought the reason for the shock was because they thought the character was a nervous battle with the public like Lindsay Lohan and many pop stars." In fact, the public doesn't care much about her, and they think she's just a pretty girl. The Internet is a problem.) And it's also a shame that Sulli's image is getting better. I thought she would mature and become an actress in her 30s. Critics of Sully are also problematic, but many say that Choi, who is vulnerable to war and is unable to take responsibility for a young child, has become a bad turning point in her life.It's obvious. The interviews that Sully said she liked because she had Choi were in the middle of a relationship, and when she was 24, 25 years old, she actively expressed herself and arranged after the breakup, she said, "My old boyfriends are like flies." She was really charming and beautiful, and there was a great possibility that she was sacrificed by ungrateful netizens. In the main article of the portal, people are saying that people should organize useless comments (because there are already many fields of communication), create systematic human rights laws, avoid the culture of treating women as trophies and teasing them in the southern part of hip-hop, create an atmosphere of contempt rather than laughing with such men, and in general, people should refrain from insulting people. And there is a huge public opinion that entertainment companies should actively take care of the spirit of idol groups.

eeeeeee

Na na na na!

Kangen

Banyak fan boy yah disini

❤️

❤❤

Meee

Was* only ;-;

She is never forgotten, rest well beautiful angel ❤

Glittered Letuce Yes! This song was and it’s still a BOP!

agree

Ok

odio este tipo de comentarios

•solanei310 aj• Mismaaaa

really?

YEAH.

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fZPbpnWdoduHZ6c

I think so, I mean nowadays a lot of group that release electro pop music style

f(x) was really ahead of their time

What a dumb comment. Like the whole world was prepared for gangnam style weren't they??

@@moa387 dumb comment? are you kidding me :/

@@rani-w4j7w areeeyoukirringmeidiaaaa? - Big Marvel

@@moa387 wth

and now many gg used electric sound...f(x) was a head

she’s much happier because her friend jonghyun is there too

People who commit suicide dont go to heaven Honestly ignore me I didn't know anything about this group or sulli but I'm heart broken it hurts to see the kpop industry do these things to wonderful people

@@victoriaa6140 People who commit suicide should still go to Heaven, and I personally believe that they do. It's petty to send somebody to Hell for suffering in their life. It's not their fault.

@@kaiaros OBVIOUS YES rip sulli

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fZPbpnWdoduHZ6c

@Literatura para románticas no ♥️

She is never in a better place

@@elfosfight884 Stop please

@@chrollolucilfer9904 what death anniversary??

in every era tbh

Especially Sulli in this MV!❤😭

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fZPbpnWdoduHZ6c

En paz descansen ambas estrellas

No their in hell burning for eternity .

@@catsbyondrepair maybe you hani

YUKI JINJUJI you need help. This is beyond inappropriate.

@@stromshell god only forgives sins of Christians

i miss her a lot

​@@cyjanekpotasu9208don't worry we miss her too but the main thing is that she is happy

@@cyjanekpotasu9208 same:(

I will firmly say: Yes.

I haven't heard. What happened to Sulli?

Shut up bot

​​@@Nina-xo555 fr, this bot don't ever know f(x) , story about Sulli. And now he wrote "how mAny lEgEndS arE hErE 😂🤩🏔" It's not funny((

Me off!

well at least the bots recognize f(x)

IVE SEEN YOU ALMOST EVERYWHERE 😭

@@atzfairiey maybe because they really stan too many groups 😭

@@aheartownedbymahidevran2622 TRUE THEYRE NAME REALLY SAYS IT

@@atzfairiey ACCURATE USERNAME HSHAHHAA

Their visual is kind of true,natural 😭😭

Hi there

Me

MeU forever

Hi

Yeah~~ And I came here From MY LOVELY GIRL

Which one is sulli?

@@itsmeh9387 stop on 2:35 She is Sulli

@@Jennieslove-r1c aw she is so cute and tysm for telling me

@@itsmeh9387 ah sulli is the one with the brown hair and rainbow highlights ❤️❤️❤️

@@itsmeh9387 No problem!❤️

Peace*

Jennierubyjane jendeukki Spelling isn’t important rn

7😊😅

ikr!! and even if she was ugly and untalented, she wouldn´t deserve hate. no one deserves hate.

That's true. ..I also can't imagine that how people could hate her and why???

You know, once my late teacher said, human: the nicest can be even better than angel, but the worst is even worse than demon.

Cos ppl had nth to do

I can’t stand bullies in real life... screw the haters

Kimbap Kidding1998 . Don’t let F(X) disband chng.it/rFsM2dWfVj petition share with everyone you can please :)

i think its too late cause amber joined a different company

@@naiyagarcia8060 WHERE HAVE I BEEN?? REALLY???

@@brxnd1s yup its steel wool entertainment in california

Brandis Chavez no that’s for her us releases only. I think it’s too late though since their contract ends soon

helllllllll yes :)

çok güzel

: } xD good

yeahh.. fucking true.. forever!!

preach

Now people are pretending that they love /d and care about Sulli (and Hara). Their fake love 😭

Fake love-BTS♡

@@taengsic0805 what does that have to do with Sulli / f(x)?

@@vivaevermore Because he said Dont show your fake love.

@@taengsic0805 I'm asking you what it has to do with Sulli or f (x), not the reason why you put that comment

2ne1*

@@deckafraidgrunge4541 Its an opinion (actually fact) so don't correct them.

@@deckafraidgrunge4541 one of the best implies there are others too. As a Blackjack myself, I recommend you to shut up and fuck off and learn how to comprehend simple English sentences.

@@deckafraidgrunge4541 sis be quiet

Queens of concepts, mothers of Red Velvet.

me: eLectRic SoBs

@@ryujinsshoulders5662 electric simpforcutegirls

Should i laugh or cry at this comment?

@chiron affirmations wtf

this is literally me

A lack of empathy leads to the bullying. Stop telling people to stop feeling bad about this.

sbndgkokncp

@@starcrafter13terran it is really disrespectfull tho. We come here together to enjoy the music. Not to get likes from Sulli.

Can we stop acting like ppl are only allowed to miss her in the first few months?

I heard about her death on tiktok on October but did not know she is was part of f.x group until now, PRAYERS TO HER FAMILY

MeU💜

Where is sulli ?

walaa mohamed, wdym? She is not on Earth. 😔

@@cherrysoyaa8126I know, but I can't tell them apart

walaa mohamed, oh sorry! Sulli is the one with Bangs.

I miss sulli😢

Factsss

I am honestly here cuz yt recommend this to me…I just got into K-Pop in beginning of 2019 and I still try to know more abt older groups, thats why I clicked. I actually know nothing abt f(x), but it's very sad to hear that another Idol is gone…especially because TST lost their member Yohan just a few day ago…I just feel like I'm late almost everywhere. Btw I know you didn't mean everyone, no need to explain that and I completely get what you mean. It's really just disgusting somehow. Well uh…bye I guess, dunno if anyones gonna read this lol Stan ATEEZ qwq

We are allowed to pay our respects. The news of any Kpop idols whether we knew them or not is upsetting to hear always.

Not everyone is ready to enjoy their music again after what happened to Sulli. Don't force people to be positive when that's not how we feel.

It's really annoying and disturbing when a Idol passes away, suddenly everyone was a fan and knew them. While Sulli was quite known, before everything happend she didn't had so much people on her side like now. Why do people support when it's too late?

Thalia -Ann same here society murdering idols wasn’t even a thing during the 2nd gen years of kpop. I just wish knetz (not saying all) should be careful of what they’re saying because what they say leads to depression of other people specifically idols 😞😭

Sangita Sutar omg thanks i got into victoria song's dramas and i was curious what she looked like in f(x) and i was so confused because she looks SO different

@@thatunloyalkpopstan6152 She is still same actually. f(x) members didn't change.

They really have all American names weirdly hhh

@@Salma04445 Only Krystal and Amber have an American name. Victoria, Sulli and Luna haven't an American name, that is only their stage name. Victoria's real name is Song Qian, she is Chinese. Sulli's real name is Choi Jinri, she is Korean. Luna's real name is Park Sunyoung, she is Korean. Krystal has both American and Korean name. Krystal is Korean but she was born in USA so she has a American name. Amber has both Chinese and American name. Amber is Taiwaniese but she was born in USA

thank you for this, I dont know much about the group, but sympathize...also interested about they're history/future

Can you plz tell me why they did not making a new song?

aarya s SM ain’t promoting them anymore

@@gi4nnanana why?

aarya s I don’t know why SM did the same thing with Girls Generation they’re probably going to disband soon :(

@@gi4nnanana ok that is so sad 😢😢 BTW thanks for answering my question

She was murdered by illuminati

@@sanghaitwist9844 get your disrespectful ass outta here.

stole my comment

Sanghai Twist Don’t be such a disgusting person show some respect!!

Sanghai Twist i stg humans are so cruel nowadays and stop being disrespectful!!!

Why the comment made me cry..

Every other girls is real song these type of music nowadays. Every other company is doing what SM has been doing in the past.

The mv set tho, its like come out in 2020

Yeah.Even Western Mainstream music has some elements of this jam.

@@weruenai2647 true!

🙏🏽😓

💔

Si 😭🤧

😭😭😭❤

Пусть покоится с миром. 🙏

+Florence Guille Mier Then repeat & repeat

+Florence Guille Mier Sulli is the only one that i can see #_# Love sulli

+Florence Guille Mier I have focused Sulli and still I cannot take my eyes from her. Repeat button is going to break.

are you sure thatpressing the replay button increases views? last time i tried that it didn't work

Melodi Halim don't replay, it doesn't work actually

F(x) is now forgotten :')

Same here

Alina Salvator - same

Came here from Alina Salvator!

Ikram Chenaf same here I miss all of them 😩

😭😭

😭😭

😭😭😭😭💔

Where is she now? I don't see her around anymore.

@@AtticusAng she based away 4 years ago 💔

Doesn't even have to be of childhood memories. This is one of the first time I've brought myself to listen to f(x) since. They weren't the foundation of my Kpop love. But they were the bricks laid on it. I'm 48. And it's all I can do to not cry listening to this. I still haven't brought myself to listen to Step (Kara). That song always made me smile with glee no matter my bad day. Till Hara. One day I'll be able to hear it again. One day.

I was wrong. I am crying

Me to...😭

maryam haq Amber isn't Korean?

A User she is actually American.(American nationality )..she is an American rapper active in south Korea..she is Korean by race and origin

She's Taiwanese-American!

Google it smartypants...search Amber Lui and see what comes up

maryam haq Haha Amber Liu is Taiwanese. Anybody could guess that by her family name (her name Amber shows that she has western nationality, but "Liu" is in no way a Korean family name like Hong Joshua, Hwang Tiffany, Jung Krystal etc all have an American name but Korean family name). Just look it up on Google. ^^

I heard f(x) was just an experiment for them to do new concept. thats why

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fZPbpnWdoduHZ6c

Lol. They supported them by having Luna's solo debut, amber solo debut. They also supported Sulli departing in the group and went hiatus because of her depression. Don't say something like that as if u know everything about SM and their groups

@@jaeode even Red Velvet had experimental music with their cb's. That's why their discography is unique and don't stick to what made them popular. Look at their b sides and zimzalabim or monster they try different concepts and perform r&b like fx also

Shame on you for being so passive and kept talking nonsense with the company. As an SM stan yes, sm sucks at promoting but they do take care of their artist. They have consistent cbs, multiple mv even NCT's album as Yoo Jaesuk said in refund sisters looked likedba novel.

In fact, we'd better just enjoy these songs instead of just talking about it. not only in this video but in all sulli and f (x) songs are just with these comments ...

@@ligabue4245 you don't like it? Oh no I guess we should all just forget what a lovely person she was and stop commenting. If you "dOn'T LiKe" it get out of the comment section

@@victoriaspooks1383 It's not quite forgetting what I meant, it's just trying to enjoy her work ... and maybe trying to look the happy side, it's very depressing but we have to think that maybe she wouldn't want everyone to be so depressed about it... Maybe now she is in a better place ( Sorry for bad english :/)

Victoria spooks They mean rather than be sad that she’s gone. We should be happy that we had the chance to experience her voice. We should be happy that we got to see her talents rather than be sad knowing she’s gone. Because her beautiful music will live on forever. In the hearts of fans, friends, and loved ones. We should celebrate her life and everything she’s done.

Same here.

@10,000 subs without any videos NEENJA WTF

@@sapphireevie shes not going to hell. the ones who deserve to be in hell are the people who bullied her to this end. her soul was in so much pain and shes free now. she is definitely in heaven. and the fact that you believe some phony nonsense that people who kill themselves go to hell is disgusting. You should be ashamed of yourself. You know nothing.

10,000 subs without any videos NEENJA You’re a terrible person, just saying.

@10,000 subs without any videos NEENJA Not necessarily. God is merciful. If she killed herself because she was unable to cure her pain on earth, then He will see that. It is likely that she will spend more time in purgatory as punishment for taking her life(she did end the life He gave her) but she will go to heaven. God may be a harsh judge(given the ultimate price for our sins is death at only a time that He knows) but he is not unreasonable.

@@KayleesKZbinThing With all due respect, I think they honestly didn't know. Christians are taught that suicide means a sentence in hell. I myself thought this until I consulted religious leaders that were far more educated than me in that sect. While their timing may have been inappropriate, I think they were genuinely curious. I apologize if that hurt you at all. I know it doesn't help to hear while we're grieving. 😭

She changed the way people see female kpop idols. 👏💫

Choque !voila un vrais fan de kpop

Trop

Coolest kpop idol 😎

Yassss

We will never this masterpiece behind 💫

Hehehe

i LOVE old kpop songs especially hate you by 2ne1😭

This song is legendary and shall never be forgotten

Periodttttt

Bom Frost most kpop songs now are just mindless edm that you hear everyday. F (x) is really different

F(x) is different, your style is different and only 😊❤

yup. kpop now sounds more "westernized", if that makes sense. trying to appeal more to intl fans now that kpop is big.

Baerene kpop is already "westernized" since its emergence. You know that SoKor was heavily influenced by american colonizers, right? Trot is an example, it came from japanese colonizers as well as western foxtrot. Kpop is just a derivative of western pop.

Jomer Bongalos there maybe already a western influenced from the getgo but they still had their own distinct sound. but what im trying to say is most kpop songs now are like any other american pop songs out there.

ESP what's happened?

And Amber??

@@generaldona3916 I don't know

Donato Dementito Jr Amber is girl, hey.

MEEEE!!!^^❤

Essa música é atemporal ❤

👋

Me eu

저게 아녀 ..아니였어 저게아님 ...

Miss A were never underrated idk in which planet you were living in-

@@jiyeonpark6595 I wonder what planet too when I saw the comment 😂

Jyp has day6

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fZPbpnWdoduHZ6c

@@elfosfight884 no👄

Which one is sulli in this mv?

@@wanda8209 the one in braid/white shirt

Rip sulli

sulli :( relax and vaccation :'(

Rip sulli

I'm agree with u

It's not that old btw 🙄

​@@zeh_edits_shaaTo us kpop fans, it seems like a considerable time of old.

timeless queens

@@zeh_edits_shaai mean, it’s more than a decade old…

@Elio Kim TMI but okay?

Yes😌💅

That's awesome

FQBULOUS

so fabulous

Andrea Kim What, I K R😭😭

...

@@ysha781 yeah, :( but at least no one can hurt her now 😊

Did she say that she wants to be a mother?

Blane Frider yup

Ring , Ding , Dong

SHINee is the girl version of f(x)

@@catalinapulgar4571 That doesn't make sense

@@ablambdadelta it's a joke.

@@catalinapulgar4571 Oh, ok

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fZPbpnWdoduHZ6c

She is dead

@@raindoset5408 Shut up

@@raindoset5408 que mierda tenía que ver?

@@raindoset5408 and? We can still celebrate her birthday

@@raindoset5408 Fu

korea lovers YESSSS I feel bad f(x) has everything yet they get nothing from SM

It is on my playlist so I get an electrical shock frequently.

korea lovers electric shock still nice even at this year, love Amber and sulli so much

Yes

korea lovers Martín garrix Best dj of World King of electrónica

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fZPbpnWdoduHZ6c