SM don't be shy, give NCT this kind of song again

I hope no one's forgetting about this song, which is also their debut single.

Who's still here even after the OT23 MV today??? Then ur a true NCTzen♡ Thanku for the likes guys. Let's support our boys♡

Unpopular opinion - NCT needs more of such emotional but still upbeat and fast-paced pop rock songs.

So ... Doyoung has a girlfriend and Jaehyun likes the girl, then Taeil is the girl's childhood friend. then, winwin is a cameo sitting on the train.

Doyoung: Without you Teil: Without you Jaehyun: Without you Winwin: 👁️👄👁️

No one: Literary no one: Not even chittaphrrr: *Nctzens: it’s been 4 years, why is winwin on the bus*

3 minutes of silence for people who think that NCT have only 3 members.

Jaehyun is breathtaking. He's just so handsome.

Taeil: The girl is from his past Doyoung: the girl is with him in the present Jaehyun: The girl is with him in the future Winwin: The girl will end up with him in the end, his true love.

I still haven't opened my rice and they've already released a new song.

SM PLEASE. Doyoung, Jaehyun, Jaehee trio version of this song?? We NEED it

SM: Okay so Doyoung has a girlfriend and Taeil knew her before and seems to like her. We'll give Jaehyun this mysterious vibe which will hint that he knows the girl or that she seems familiar. NCT: And...Win Win? SM: Oh yeah...he'll...he'll sit in the bus. More visuals, the better. WHOOP WHOOP!

" Without You" is a poem But NCTzens couldn't read her

The Holy Trinity of vocals

Ok, taeil's voice is perfect, but... we need to talk about his visuals cuz yall are sleeping on it, and he's a snack and a half!

SM REALLY LOVES TUMBLR

This song makes you wanna have a good roadtrip.

ok but taeil's acting skills here is no jokee!

Storyline in the music video : 1. Doyoung and the girl is a couple 2. Taeil is someone from the girl's past life (?) 3. Jaehyun is someone from the girl's future (?) ANDDDDD... Winwin is the reincarnation of the girl, and he is from the very future life (after the girl gone from Jaehyun) then doing time travel 😂

4 years and I'm still here... wonder why this song is not popular yet!

I don't know why, but this song make me feel kind of nostalgic, a mix between being sad and happy, listening to this make me wanna cry but i don't know if it's for good, bad, or both of them. Still i love this song, good memories come to my mind

okAY BUT WHY DOES NO ONE TALKS ABOUT THE AESTHETICS OF THIS MV?? LIKE, FOR REAL??? PLUS 4 YEARS LATER THIS SONG STILL SLAPS----

taeil you just wasted all this talent and threw everything away for nothing. your voice carries emotion but it all seem like a lie now. this is one of my favorite nct songs and idk if i should keep listening cuz i really like his voice. this is just really sad dude

This is just.. Really good music? Gives me Day6 vibes. I love them.

Why nobody is saying how Doyoung is boyfriend material??

TAEILS VOCALS ARE YOU SERIOUS

7 years have passed and this is still my favorite NCT song

Why isn't anyone talking about Doyoung?? He's such a cutie and his voice here is golden!!

the fact that most of the top comments are about sicheng😭😭😭 winwin legend

Still remember 4years ago when NCT not famous like now . And now they really deserve nice treat from company , a lot of fans , more active . I'm literally crying after watching this again . they have been through a lot of obstacles since SM rookie but they never give up and keep making us happy . Lol I'm like parents who proud to my sons sorry for being so emotional

이 뮤비 처음 들었을 때로 돌아가고 싶다 음악하고 싶었다면서 팬들 마음에 대못을 박냐 근데 이 노래 들으면 너무 좋으면서도 치가 떨린다

STOP SLEEPING ON THIS MASTERPIECE!

I can't explain the feeling but whenever I listen to this song my heart aches

In nct I love the most is Taeil and bubu. But what happened today is really shocked me to the core. Now I cannot hear nct song like used to be anymore… 😢 Oh taeil what have you done. Your voice is literally give soul to every nct songs. In the future we cannot hear it again. Regards, momo. 😢

he who shall not be named will never ruin this song for me.

JUNG JAEHYUN'S VOICE COLOUR IS WORTH A LIFETIME SUPPLY OF RICE. or maybe even more.

I'm here to tell SM that we need another Taeil , Doyoung and Jae collaboration ASAP i cant wait for more u know

is it just me or does this song make you feel so nostalgic?

Thank you Taeil for the beautiful memories, i loved you, loved your sweet voice. But now we’re all disappointed in you and will not support you in the future.

Taeil has such a beautiful voice. I really like this song. Why did you do such a disgusting things? Why did you do with your beautiful voice? Why?

i genuinely appreciate kpop music with actual instruments in it

omg Taeil voice is amazing 😍😍😍

Gonna miss this vocal trio. Y'all would have went far

Just my thought about this mv story line. It's like the member have their own time with the girl. Like for Taeil she is his past, for Doyoung is the present and for Jaehyun is his future. I feel like Jaehyun can see the girl in future and Taeil keep remember his past with the girl, for Doyoung he living his time so he is with the girl. But still don't know why Winwin sit on the bus tho.. (sorry for the bad english)

90% of this comment section is about Winwin on the bus and it got me rolling on the floor.

I still love this song but I think people should notice and love Doyoung more he is never really talked about he is so adorable why can't people take some time to know him he is cool and he should get noticed more he has amazing vocals and he is a good person DOYOUNG NEEDS TO GET NOTICED MORE

TAEIL IS PERFECTION

*i'm just literally crying in the corner of how beautiful this song is. this is nothing else but a powerful song of nct*

im a new nctzen but like this song is a banger how did i not know this existed????????

People tend to forget that this is one of NCT U's best songs!!

Why does this masterpiece only have 20M views ?????

this is when i decided that Taeil is going to be my NCT bias because of his beautiful voice but after 9 years of admiring him I regret it. why taeil? why did you became such a bad person?😢

STAN NCT STAN TALENT Doyoung😻😻

LET'S REACH 5M BEFORE TAEIL'S BIRTHDAY! WE CAN!

Petition for SM Entertaiment, please give NCT this kind of song again!!

Jaehyun will never not look good damn.

this mv had so many taeil’s screen time and he deserves that a lot

i still remember how 13y.o me is so obsessed with this song😭 now im 20, the same age as doyoung in this mv... i can't believe how time flies so fast...

Old but will always be gold.

me: never watches music videos me, also: heard this song 567483920 since release me also: watches it in 2019 no one: me again: WINWIN????

why is taeil so handsome? this wasnt supposed to happen

This song made me realize that kpop isn't just pop music. Thank you NCT for expanding my understanding and love of kpop!

4 years has passed and I'm still wondering why this is so underrated (1)

DEAR JUNG JAEHYUN 재현아, 너는 항상 우리에게 자신감을 가지라고 하고 가끔 실수를 해도 괜찮아. 왜냐하면 결국 우리는 모두 인간이기 때문이야. 너도, 우리도 배웠고, 우리 모두 자라고 있어. 항상 우리가 아는 명랑한 재현이 되길 바라. 사랑해 우리는 너를 사랑한다. JAEHYUN-SSI, WE LOVE YOU SO MUCH.

EXOL here to support NCT U and NCT, I love this song ♡♡

I used to feel relieved and happy when I listened to it before, now this song hurts so much 😭

Actor Jaehyun : Check Actor Doyoung : Check We need Actor Taeil and Actor Winwin soon

This song just makes me feel seriously nostalgic. I miss this. Where is NCT U these days?

I hope they'll make a comeback (a year passed already...)

2:14 Jaehyun's voice is soooo similar to Baekhyun's here :O

this song is my fav NCT ballad song , Taeil was once my bias and the reason I got into NCT. Idk how to feel abt that now I am so angry .. I'll nvr forgive you Taeil 😢

1:38 1:51 1:53 2:04 2:07 2:10 JAEHYUN`S STARE IS KILLING ME

I promise NCT is way better than many groups. I just hope people realise that. 😊😊😊 Their voices OMG

Taeil is a precious

Doyoung, Jaehyun, Jaehee version when?

NCT U needs to release something new asap

커버린 아이처럼 혼자된 나무처럼 외로워 지친 누군가의 세상을 봐 바라고 바랬던걸 결국은 찾지 못해 밀려났던 자의 감추려던 상처를 봐 우린 외톨이로 태어나 좀 느린 나와 같이 걸어줄 누군가를 기다려 내 손을 잡아 원을 그려 이 만큼 나눠 가진 거잖아 내 온 마음이 네 곁에 네 꿈이 내 곁에 산다는 거 견디는 거 함께라면 조금 더 행복해져 끝없이 연결돼 다시 can't live without you 조류에 쓸려가듯 바다를 떠도는 듯 지쳐가지만 낙원은 보이지 않아 난 너의 따듯함이 필요해 괜찮다고 말해주잖아 I need you I need you 내 손을 잡아 원을 그려 이 만큼 나눠 가진 거잖아 내 온 마음이 네 곁에 네 꿈이 내 곁에 산다는 거 견디는 거 함께라면 조금 더 행복해져 끝없이 연결돼 다시 can't live without you 눈 감아도 난 온기로 느껴 한걸음 옆에 나란히 걸어준 동행인걸 위안을 주는 너 I'm with you 내가 다시 살아갈 용기는 너니까 어깨를 내주며 공감할 너니까 믿을게 슬픔을 마주할 때면 한번 더 내 손을 잡아 원을 그려 이 만큼 나눠 가진 거잖아 내 온 마음이 네 곁에 네 꿈이 내 곁에 산다는 거 견디는 거 함께라면 조금 더 행복해져 끝없이 연결돼 다시 can't live without you

I swear I am raising the views. I come back here no matter what

Can we go back to these days🥹

Taeil is so beautiful ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ

WINWIN!!

This song makes me so emo

Winwin is like time traveler who looking for his lone and screen time. Besides, Taeil is truly vampire who never getting old.

"Without You" Keobeorin aicheoreom Honjadoen namucheoreom Oerowo jichin Nugungaui sesangeul bwa. Barago baraessdeongeol Gyeolgugeun chajji moshae Millyeonassdeon jaui Gamchuryeodeon sangcheoreul bwa. Urin oetoriro taeeona Jom neurin nawa gati georeojul Nugungareul gidaryeo Nae soneul jaba woneul geuryeo I mankeum nanwo gajin geojanha. Nae on maeumi ne gyeote Ne kkumi nae gyeote Sandaneun geo gyeondineun geo Hamkkeramyeon jogeum deo haengbokhaejyeo. Kkeuteopsi yeongyeoldwae dasi Can't live without you. Joryue sseullyeogadeut Badareul tteodoneun deut Jichyeogajiman Nagwoneun boiji anha. Nan neoui ttadeushami piryohae Gwaenchanhdago malhaejujanha. I need you, I need you. Nae soneul jaba woneul geuryeo I mankeum nanwo gajin geojanha. Nae on maeumi ne gyeote Ne kkumi nae gyeote Sandaneun geo gyeondineun geo Hamkkeramyeon jogeum deo haengbokhaejyeo. Kkeuteopsi yeongyeoldwae dasi Can't live without you. Nun gamado nan ongiro neukkyeo Hangeoreum yeope naranhi Georeojun donghaengingeol Wianeul juneun neo. I'm with you. Naega dasi saragal Yonggineun neonikka Eokkaereul naejumyeo Gonggamhal neonikka mideulge, Seulpeumeul majuhal ttaemyeon hanbeon deo Nae soneul jaba woneul geuryeo I mankeum nanwo gajin geojanha. Nae on maeumi ne gyeote Ne kkumi nae gyeote Sandaneun geo gyeondineun geo Hamkkeramyeon jogeum deo haengbokhaejyeo. Kkeuteopsi yeongyeoldwae dasi Can't live without you. 커버린 아이처럼 혼자된 나무처럼 외로워 지친 누군가의 세상을 봐. 바라고 바랬던걸 결국은 찾지 못해 밀려났던 자의 감추려던 상처를 봐. 우린 외톨이로 태어나 좀 느린 나와 같이 걸어줄 누군가를 기다려 내 손을 잡아 원을 그려 이 만큼 나눠 가진 거잖아. 내 온 마음이 네 곁에 네 꿈이 내 곁에 산다는 거 견디는 거 함께라면 조금 더 행복해져. 끝없이 연결돼 다시 Can't live without you. 조류에 쓸려가듯 바다를 떠도는 듯 지쳐가지만 낙원은 보이지 않아. 난 너의 따듯함이 필요해 괜찮다고 말해주잖아. I need you, I need you. 내 손을 잡아 원을 그려 이 만큼 나눠 가진 거잖아. 내 온 마음이 네 곁에 네 꿈이 내 곁에 산다는 거 견디는 거 함께라면 조금 더 행복해져. 끝없이 연결돼 다시 Can't live without you. 눈 감아도 난 온기로 느껴 한걸음 옆에 나란히 걸어준 동행인걸 위안을 주는 너. I'm with you. 내가 다시 살아갈 용기는 너니까 어깨를 내주며 공감할 너니까 믿을게, 슬픔을 마주할 때면 한번 더 내 손을 잡아 원을 그려 이 만큼 나눠 가진 거잖아. 내 온 마음이 네 곁에 네 꿈이 내 곁에 산다는 거 견디는 거 함께라면 조금 더 행복해져. 끝없이 연결돼 다시 Can't live without you.

Taeil vocals are seriously so under appreciated LIKE HE SOUNDS SO ANGELIC

He was my first favorite in NCT at the time of this release. Glad it did not last long. Change thumbnail

Nct nation fighting.. speedy recovery MOON TAEIL

I hope SM would show more Taeil's real talent. His vocals is just astonishining. (Astonishing+Shining)

jaehyun is more than his handsome face everybody. don't sleep on his vocals and also rapping skills

Jaehyun sounds like Baekhyun Doyoung sounds like Luhan ...and Taeil sounds like an angel

This song deserves 100 million views.

NCT Vocals are just out of this world!

cant believe they debuted with THIS song and NOBODY has given it the attention it deserves czennies you had ONE job

I want someone to look at me the way Taeil looks at that girl ❤️

Since they are going to perform songs from 2016 until now in their beyond live concert, I hope they perform this masterpiece

i can´t find anything i don´t like about this song. Taeil´s high note was amazing!

i’m not part of nct fanbase, but considering all the songs that i ever earned of nct, this is the best one so far

This is the sort of song which is just pure nostalgia for no apparent reason, even when you've only just found it. It reminds me of my happy childhood.

so they recreated this again and made a video, hope everyone won't forget NCT 2020♥️