People need to realize that this is most likely a test of sorts, to see if F(x) has the staying power for a comeback at this time, especially given the crazy schedules of the other two members with Victoria and all of her promotions in China, as well as Krystal with all the acting and advertisement work she's been getting. Luna is of course popular for her vocals, and Amber with her alternative style and popularity with the international fan basis. So I feel like they potentially COULD comeback, but only if SM sees the financial potential for them to do so. I'm not particularly crazy about this song, but I support them because I would love to see a real F(x) comeback. It definitely seems possible, but only if they make the right milestones in the proper amount of time. It's known that plenty of groups will start to work on a comeback, only to be placed on the back-burner by companies if they don't feel their investment will be returned and then some.

Love Amber and Luna together especially when they're producing quality like this. SM still holding off on that f(x) comeback, so Amber straight up directs this whole thing for us, could not be more grateful.

It's high time SM brings back f(x) for a comeback.

3 years after im still listening to this song every single day

Amber has that kinda androgynous beauty that basically anyone has the capability of being attracted too regardless of sexual orientation.

for u guys who keep demanding fx comeback in the comment section , can u just please leave a nice comment or appreciation first on how great lunber been doing here? better stream this bcs the mv,song is beautiful and to make sm giving fx comeback.

SM have the greatest and talented artists in kpop industry, HOW CAN THEY MANAGE THEIR IDOLS SO BAD??? Little promotion, barely any variety shows, lost Henry and Amber. Recently Jonghyun and Sulli (RIP angels). They need to step up...

I’m so mad that I only just discovered this song. SM did f(x) dirty. They were so unique in their lineup and deserved more promotions.

...Amber didn't rap this time...LOVE IT!!! I'm so glad she chose to show us more of her singing voice! If y'all don't support LunBer and their fabulous voices, you're crazy!

I actually teared up a little. I miss Fx so much its not even funny

where are my 2020 and beyond people watching this? hello! welcome or welcome back to this masterpiece.

This song is so underrated! One of the best songs in kpop for me. And I miss f(x) 😭

I don't understand what is Amber doing to be so sexy while dancing.. *Honestly she's a perfection.*

Amber directed this, right?! 😍 -- P.S. I just came back to watch again and saw 1.2K likes on my comment!! whaaaat! hahaha come check out my channel y'all!!!

4 years has passed since this song come out and I’m still begging to SM make this duo official

Lower 진짜 명곡...엠룬도 정식 유닛 나왔으면 더 대박이었을 것 같은데 아쉽다ㅠㅠ그래도 언니들 사랑해 멍청이스엠

Amber is really hot

My favorite thing in this video that no one's talking about is the fact that you can see Amber's breath during the outdoor shots of her second verse parts - the fact that you can tell she was actually singing out loud while filming :')))

2023년에 다시 봐도 여전히 멋져요.

Luna shine like always, for me she is the best vocalist in SM and one of the best in K-pop, but she's so damn underrated, i'm not a MeU but i love the girls and i know they deserve more love and promotion.

2018 is saved

CAN'T BELIEVE AMBER AND LUNA ALREADY SAVED 2018

Here in 2023 because im still obsessing over Amber and Luna 😂

Luna looks so pretty

Amber is the real definition of girl crush am I right?

2018 IS SAVED

4 walls, free somebody, all mine and lower. These songs are just so cool!

Luna is so hot to a western standard, I'd say. She is perfect! A petite girl with powerful voice.

H&M would play this bop 24/7

stop asking for f(x) comeback and support lunber first they worked so hard for this

I remember I used to listen a lot to this song back in 2018. It was definitely one of the best songs of the year and I can’t believe it didn’t chart very high. It has one of the best beats and it can easily become a globally famous song. I don’t understand why people slept on it.

Amber Liu. The first time I ever saw you, it was through my older sister who was, and still is, absolutely obsessed with FX. I have been a K-Pop fan for about a decade now, but at this time, at least 5 years ago, I wasn’t acquainted with many groups. I saw the absolute glow in my sister’s eyes as she showed me endless FX music videos and talked about each member with such love and inspiration woven into each of her words. Since then, I have been a huge supporter and fan of FX, and I have grown alongside you during your most difficult and triumphant times. I know that you have been through a lot, and even saying that doesn’t even come to close to what you must have been feeling for the past several years. I know you have been in the business and making music for a very long time now, and I know you have experienced extreme tragedy as well as glorifying victories. I have never seen someone respond to any obstacles in the mature and hopeful manner that you have. That, as I’ve gotten to know more about you over the years, might be what I appreciated the most about you. I am so aware why so many people, including my sister who introduced me to you, are so inspired by you and desperate to follow in your footsteps. Amidst all of the pain you have felt, sacrifice you have made, and challenges you have faced, you continue to make barrier-breaking music and share your voice with the world through that music. Your response to the problems in the world is so wholesome, genuine and confident; and you have taught many around the world how to effectively recover from any pain they may have felt. It can be understood that you have gone through what many have not, and yet you have not given up on living out your dreams and encouraging others to follow in your footsteps. What has always stood out to me is that you have always been confident, and done what has been best for you, rather than listen to others. You always came off as so comfortable in your own skin, and that makes you such an iconic performer and musician. Your powerful and bold rapping, combined with your soulful, smooth, and energetic voice makes you an incredibly compassionate performer who is so connected to her audience and music on stage. You are an unbelievably beautiful dancer and have such a demanding stage presence that has been such a privilege for me to watch over these years. I know that your fans love you in a way that’s stronger than anybody else ever could. You have given them a reason not to give up trying when the worst happens to them, and there is no higher form of inspiration than that. I am proud to be one of these fans, and I know my sister is as well. Similarly, your members love you and have such an unbreakable bond with you that I have seen firsthand without even knowing any of you personally. I know that you have all relied on each other in such a way that most people can’t say they know or understood, and I can’t even speak on how unique your relationship is with one another. I can’t even thank you enough for coming into my life and showing me confidence, strength, and reliance on my passion, friends, and family in the darkest times in my life. You are an inspiration like no other, and I know all of the fans, and even those outside of them can recognize as such a once-in-a-lifetime authentic musician. On behalf of your friends, fans, members, and most importantly, your loving and adoring family, I wish you the most blessed birthday ever Amber. I hope nothing but love surrounds you and those close to you always and forever. Please stay safe, and I pray that you continue to live your life in such bliss as you do now and have always tried to. I absolutely love you so, so much, and Happy Birthday! I hope you have as much fun as you possibly can! We adore you so much and never give up on your once-in-a-lifetime artistry. Be safe, and praying for the happiness and health of you and your loved ones always.

BoA is crying like a proud mother but low-key shaking

The VOCALS✅ the BEATS✅ the VISUALS✅ The DANCE✅ every thing is lit♥ *slay Q u e e n s*

I miss my girls a lot. They deserve better.

(내 기준으로) 이 곡은 참 스타일리쉬하다. 이 노래를 다른 듀오가 불렀다면 어떤 느낌일까 생각하고 싶지도 않을 정도로 참 궁합이 잘 맞는 곡. 이런 인재들을 왜 SM은 방치를 했던가 궁금하다, 여러 어른들의 사정이 있었겠지만서도-

SM, please give whole f(x) a comeback, don’t you see their talent? Their talent will be wasted if there isn’t a comeback soon.

AS A MEU I HAVEN'T SCREAMED THIS MUCH IN TWO YEARS

이 노래는 정말 전설이다... 오늘도 보러 왔다...ㅜㅜ

Alas we never got that f(x) comeback :( This song makes me wonder whether their hypothetical comeback would've been lo-fi/chill like this song - Amber and Luna are really selling it here!

Can you believe luna and amber single handedly saved 2018

Luna is such a freakin boss, man. She's the best!

또 들으러 와버림

AHHH I miss these gurls! 🥲🙌🏾 and yes I’m still listening it to in 2023 💜💜💜💜💜

This really sounds like something worth of playing at fashion shows' runways. Love it.

Can LunBer become an official subunit instead of just an smstation kind of thing?? I mean at this point they could have released a whole mini album already

Luna & Amber eran un gran dúo Una combinación maravillosa en visual y canto. Ojalá colaboren juntas ahora que ambas ya salieron de la SM

i'm still in love with this song

W h y doesn't sm promote these two members more. They can sing, can dance, great on variety shows they deserve better. All of fx deserved better

"You're so deep, babe." When I tell you I was SHOOK. You can't just put that in there while Amber is making eye contact with the camera. You're going to give people pregnancy scares. Luna's favorite English phrase is "I'm so sexy," and she's so right. I really want her to join a program like Hit the Stage, so she can showcase her amazing dance skills too. Amber's vocals have improved so much. I'm so proud of her and how far she's come. On top of that, she directed and edited the video! Get those royalties, love. 2018 is already looking brighter for my multi-talented queens.

Its 2024, and I still would like to see this choreography better Cuz this song is iconic, and the little choreography that we can see is also iconic aaaaaa

So I played this at work today and saw my boss bopping along to it....nobody can deny true talent when they hear it 😂

Luna is one of the most criminally underrated Kpop stars out there

The Legend.

I HOPE AMBER AND LUNA STILL BE ABLE TO MAKE MUSIC TOGETHER LIKE THIS AFTER AMBER'S DEPARTURE FROM SM! GOOD LUCK TO YOU BOTH!

OMG F(X) is alive

Ughh the fact that Amber directed and edited this MV...

I miss them :(

Luna dancing is outstanding

So, let's just stop complaining about how SM doesn't do anything about f(x), and actually SUPPORT this and don't let them FLOP. Because if it will, it'll be our fault. MeUs must unite

GUYS! Listen up. We all miss f(x), our girls deserve soooo much better. But let’s support their individual works, cause they have wishes and solo projects that want to make, don’t let them disappointed. Support “Lower”!!!

I'm suppose to be an heterosexual girl, but I have a crush on Amber 😍

their voices are just beautiful and fit together so well, like their personalities

*This is the definition of perfection. Enough said*

You can tell luna's is the most powerful dancer in f(x). Her moves are so sharp, clean , powerful and enjoyable to watch. Her presence is so demanding when she dance tbh. I could watch her dance all day and i won't get bored. Amazing.

Why this don't have 100M views?????

im still so mad everyone deadass slept on them after they talked about wanting an f(x) comeback

I hope this is SM's way of letting us know f(x) will have a comeback this year!

Amber singing is a rare and beautiful thing

Luna is soooooo beautiful

f(x) is one of the best kpop groups of SM, it hurts that they do not know how to value that, they have already passed several years and still do not return, they have abandoned them ... They give more attention to new groups like Red velvet, instead of f(x) that there really is talent in this group :(♥

damn amber. got me shook at the end

GUYS THIS SONG IS TRENDING ON KZbin IN THE US!!! THE POWER OF MeUs!!

Everytime I watch this I wish I could like it more than once

How I miss this duo 😭

Amber and Luna sound so good together

Everyone saying "F(x) comeback" better be streaming this song. SM is testing to see if y'all can finally support f(x) members especially amber & Luna who despite being talented are the least supported members in the group. If SM sees y'all don't care for them then they won't bother with them and you know what that means. They'll retire f(x). So stop complaining bout f(x) for a minute & be grateful amber & Luna came back.

Queen Legend always and forever. f(x) unite Amber and Luna the best everything multitalent always and forever.

this video should have like 100 million views, what's wrong with this world!!

Amber said the night of filming, it was below zero. During Luna’s filming, it got even colder with wind. Luna was wearing less costume than Amber. We love these girls’ dedication!!!!

amber's singing gives me life

2019?? No one ?? ❤😪 AMBER IS SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO CUTE 😭❤

The subunit we deserved but never got..... #smgoingtojailparty

I'm happy that sm finally gave amber something to do instead of telling her "she's not good enough"🙄 ok but am I the only one that think Luna gets hotter? SHE CAN SLAP ME AND I'LL STILL LOVE HER BOI WHAT🌚 I'll support f(x) all the way~

SM, WE NEED A DANCE PRACTICE. NOW.

it's been 84 years... I need them back plz 💀💀😭😭

Amber just make good songs, oh my god! One more good song to my kpop playlist

i couldn´t stop thinking about BoA everytime i saw Luna, she is so talented, one of the most talented idols in the whole industry.

WTF this should have been an official single not an Station track! Such a Bop!

Still love this song

대박!!!!!!!!!!왜 이걸 이제 봤지ㅠㅜ 둘다 넘 섹시하다 춤은 또 왜이렇게 잘 춰...... 분위기 쩔어🔥🔥

DO NOT go on ALLKPOP concerning this MV or Amber's upcoming appearance at UC Riverside. The comment section is so toxic. I don't know why these 2 especially Amber is getting all this hate. But I hope they don't see it and keep doing what they do. They need positive energy now more than ever. We don't need to see another victim of cyber bullying and depression. Some people never learn. Stay strong, girls!

this is the subgroup we deserve

Came here for amber I'll still be here in a decade ;)

I randomly remembered this song and came back to relieve the moment I first heard it 3 years ago. And gotta say. Still one of the best songs I've heard in kpop. Such a shame SM didn't really promote F(x) later on in their career😞

Can Luna and Amber become a sub-unit already please!! They are so amazing!! This song and the MV is so great!! Hoping for an f(x) comeback this 2018 :))

Luna is looking gorgeous, and Amber is so cool as usual. Much love for f(x). Hoping for their grup comeback soon.

Here I am in 2020 (almost 2021) listenin' to this beautiful song! How I miss f(x)!

Went to Amber's tour concert in Atlanta. BEST. DAY. EVER! Shout out to my Llamahoes!

WHY ARE THE VIEWS STUCK??? THIS DESERVES 2M ALREADY