Hangeng and Siwon acting together is always amazing. I can't believe SM doesn't use this dramatic storyline type of MV with its other artists/groups.

가슴 절절한 가삿말이 연인들의 마음을 감동시킬것 같아요 장리인의 파워풀한 가창력과 멜로디가 어우러져 한편의 서사시를 읽는것 같습니다 또한 뮤직비디오는 어떠한 영화보다 설득력있고 간절해서 드라마틱한 영화를 보는것 같네요

이 띵곡 오랜만에 듣는다 .... ㅠㅠㅠㅠ mp3로 듣던게 어제같은데 ...

typewriter98 There are two videos for this story. In the first video named "I will"... it's shown how the two boys (Hangeng & Siwon) became friends, also shown you how the two boys started to like the same girl. Hangeng plays the shy and quiet boy, and Siwon plays the charismatic and sociable boy, both from different status, one seems to be rich (Siwon) and the other a kind boy (Hangeng). Siwon always tried to wins over or get the girls attention while Hangeng just tried to be with her. While the girl was getting confused about who she really loved. The three of them were actors in a theater and there was a show coming. When they were practicing, the bad guy appeared and pushed Siwon to the floor looking for a fight. Hangeng tried to defend his friend but Siwon stopped him. The director of the show appeared and told the bad guy to leave the theater and the shows, so in revenge the bad guy changed the fake blade they were going to use in the play, with a real one. The girl had catch him leaving the room of props but didn't pay so much attention. There was a part of the show were Hangeng have to stab Siwon, as no one didn't know about the change, they used the blade carelessly. So the show end up with Hangeng stabbing Siwon in reality. The girl scared of Hangeng being arrested she took him with her and leave everyone behind. Here is when it comes this video. Hangeng and girl were living in hiding while Siwon was recovering from the incident. When Siwon wakes up, he remember what happens, how his best friends stab him and how the girl he likes decided to run away with his best friend instead of staying and taking care of him. In resentment and bitterness Siwon decide to search both of them. While the bad guy was follow him behind. When Siwon found out where they were hiding, he saw how the two of them were living "happily" and careless if he was death or not, so he walks to Hangeng and began to complain about everything had happen. While they were arguing the bad guy takes the chances to finally kill Siwon. But Hangeng saw him first and turned his friends and put himself between the guy and Siwon, so he was the one who got shot. Siwon saw how his best friend risked his life for him. He finally understand what the hell it's happening and goes to the bad guy and had a fight with him. Because Siwon was still weak from the stab, the bad guy has another opportunity to kill him, but when he was about to stab him, AGAIN, Hangeng save Siwon's live by shot him the bad guy. And after that Hangeng die.

요즘은 저런 영화같은 뮤비가 없어... ㅠ

OMG!!! Zhan Li Yin's MVs deserve a k-drama! My favorite would be Timeless.

not that i dont like special effects and flashy clothes but these MVs back the are still the best now. a full blown mini movie for you. miss it!

Very sad 😢😭...miss ZhangLiYin's voice 😢😘

어우 진짜 명곡인데 아는 사람이 없어.... ㅠㅠ

장리인 흥해랏~~!!!

her voice is really unique❤ ZhangLiYin❤

노래 너무조아ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 최애곡

Love the song, love the voice, love more the MV. Whenever I watch it, tears just fall down, especially touched by Seewon and Hangeng's performance, they are amazing! At the end, seeing Seewon's face expression is just like a dagger stabbed in my heart, then tears fell...

22nd official sm video ive reviewed. This is my favorite song sung by Zhang Li Yin. Its calming start and doesnt overpower you with too many large high notes at once. Its a continuation of the storyline from her song "i will" which gives it bonus points. Somebody always dying in her mvs 😭 i wish someone would get to remake this song, i wish for wendy or boa to sing it.

This still makes me cry even after so many years. I'm so happy I finally found this again. :-)

Zhang Li Yin is a great singer!!! miss her voice!!

이노래 제일좋아하는데 라이브없고 노래방에조차없네요 ㅠㅠ좀슬프네요.. 10년째듣고있는데

Timeless 보다 이 노래가 진짜 찐임...

It's really sad. When someone died for you,saving you until last second of his life Another Thumbs up for this Mv

Zhang Li Yin eonnie I Really miss you 😭😭😭💗💗💗💗❤️❤️❤️💙💙💙💚💚💚

I love you Zhang Li Yin.♥

Zhang Liyin MVs always makes me CRY T____T

10년도 더됐네 학원강사때부터 종일 들었던추억이 있네요

애써 그 오랜 시간을 숨겨왔던 내 눈물들을 다시 감추려 눈을 감아도 이내 그칠 수 없이 흐르네요 내게 그대가 그래요 애가 이렇게 애를 써도 내 눈물에 흐르는 그대를 끝내 감출수가 없어진 연인이여 사랑 그 둘레에 우린 서있어도 조금의 안위도 난 누릴 수 없죠 가질 수 없는 시간 앞에 또 무너져 내려 바람에 날리는 저 꽃잎 같아 그저 이 오랜 시간을 참아왔던 내 긴 한숨을 더는 멈출 수 없어진 지금 이제야 토해내듯 내쉬네요 내게 그대가 그래요 내가 이렇게 애를 써도 긴 한숨에 내쉬는 사랑을 끝내 감출수가 없어진 연인이여 사랑 그 둘레에 우린 서있어도 조금의 안위도 난 누릴 수 없죠 보이지 않게 다가오는 이 사랑 안에서 다시 무너져 내려도 끝없이 돌고 도는 이 계절과도 같아 사랑 그 중심에 우리는 서 있고 그리움 가득한 이 마음 그 앞에 가질 수 없는 시간 앞에 나는 울고만 싶어 바람에 날리는 저 꽃잎 같은 사랑하는 이름 연인이여

Zhang Liyin,I love her for seven years......

Zhang Li Yin's MVs are so beautiful! SM should promote her more and make more of these MVs.

Wow when will sm ever do these types of music videos again

Sequel of I WILL.. Poor Hangeng, he's always be dead, same goes to Timeless.. But he will always live in my heart..

I cry everytime I watch this..... Hangeng and Siwon are such amazing actors, I fall for the plot every single time. That makes them great actors in my book

siwon is so cute here

Zhang Li Yin

2018 and for me she is one of the legendary SM vocalist👍👍

This song is very good and touching~ Hope Li Yin will have a comeback in Korea soon!

Hangeng & Siwon

Makes me cry every time ... Hangeng and Siwon: Sworn Brothers

감사합니다

OMG everytime i see this mv and timeless i cry like a baby. Han geng don't die on us even if it just a mv =( Han geng i so just love him!

ストーリーに切なくなってしまいました😢

Han Kyung is so cute

Wow ; this is really a great series!!! I absolutely just love these 3 together... They are just the perfect acting group! I want more of them~

Li Yin , i miss you.......

I love the song and it's emotional and touching ^^ siwon and hangeng are so amazing :) Super Junior fighthing~! Zhangliyin you're a gifted because u have a beautiful voice :)

I'm watching a cdrama with the similar house to the one in this mv so logically I have to listen to the song with both version

This is my first time watching this video and i'm crying a lot

2023년도에 듣는 나..🙋‍♀️

This made me cry more than timeless- I think it's because they all knew each other before and Hannie actually saved Siwon's life! TT_TT

ahhhhhhhh it actually made me cry T_T i really really miss hangeng

it made me cry SO hard. I had to go get a box of tissues.

Really good acting on Hangeng and Siwon's part. It was painful seeing Hangeng's character die :( Great video Part 1 and 2!

aww this MV is such a tear-jerker. hangeng saved siwon's life TWICE. whoa. they're both so cute in this. ...although during the final scenes when they were all in pain and agonizing it was kinda weird seeing liyin's face kinda smiling while she was singing...just didn't fit. love her voice so much. i wonder why she doesn't play the actress in her MVs?

Hello from 2022 🙋‍♀️🙋‍♀️

2019 anyone still listen to Zhang Li Yin?

또 울었다

She's finally back! Her teaser looks amazing!

Aww.. this video made me CRY.. :'(( I MISS YOU HANKYUNG OPPA!! :((

Still crying watch it TT

i haven't cried this hard in a long time... this video just made me miss hangeng an infinity times more T.T

I cried for real T-T they are such good actors! and the song is so sad, it isn't really helping when you are almost crying

i miss u hankyung oppa 😢

I'm crying D:! Love yoou Hangeng and Siwon!

SM, I hope someday you will reupload the better quality of this MV and "I will" MV. These two MV were my first encounter with Korean Ballad music. They are really important to me.

Love the MV and the songs... I like how some of her songs has parts to it that make a series.

this always makes me cry...

so sad , siwon n hankyung you're so HANDSOME

명곡

Hankyung is an amazing actor!

이 뮤비 첨봤는데 왜슬프지..

Haayyyy...i'm from 2021 😆😆😆

2024 who here?

I'm here to start stream this MV

I cried. Why doesn't SM make these kinds of videos anymore?

thumbs up if you think zhang li yin has the best MVs

113k videos after 13 years…SOMEONE CALL THE AMBULANCE

i miss you

my friend show this to me while we was in class i cried sooo much after watching everyone was staring at me like im crazy but gosh i couldn't help it its sooo good and emotional ^^ hangeng T^T

GEGE ;; I CAN'T TELL HOW MUCH I MISS YOU ;;

the first few seconds i was cracking up seeing geng's make up but really, this mv is lovely

幸福的左岸

my God! this mv made me cry!!! I wasn't expecting that one! T_T

it so sadd =( but i have to say that siwon is extremly handsome here !

Did not really understand the story, but i cried at the end. beautiful song, and video.

이연희 수수하게 입고 대사 안치니까 왤케 예쁘냐;;;;;

Siwon siwon.. I don't have any other words.

Hope it can be a full of drama.. 😭

I never cried so hard in my life. TT^TT

He is good in that!

i'm miss he and want to cry hankyung show everything MVs when he is come ...? wait until the last minute will wait he is back

I Miss

gosh , i'm crying

hangeng. the girl always bring siwon's necklace and hangeng's drawing she was confused which guy she really love (sorry for my bad english too) =]

Cry again

난 이거 지금도 들으러오는데...

this is even sadder now that hankyung isnt longer in super junior....hankyung oppa saranghae.....fighting :'(

Liyin said in an interview back in April 2008 that she wished to act in her MVs but Mr. Lee Soo Man thought that she should act later.

Ending siwon got the girl again

oh my gawd this video made me cry

สรุปภาคไหนคือภาคแรกง่าาา ดูจนงงไปหมดล้าว 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 #คิดถึงป๋าฮันนนนนน🥲

im crying ahhh

@khkra The song is called The Left Shore of Happiness. She has a Korean and Chinese version of this song.

I'm crying so hard Hangeng Siwon T.T