She’s so underrated. SHE IS STUNNING! I BET HER ANTI WOULD AGREE HER VOICE IS SMOOTH AND SILKY

这首歌让我想起那年在大学，在网吧里的时光。。。11年了，我的天！

I like the MV with slideshows because they're past memories. This song is really nice. I'm glad that Zhang Li Yin is back!

2019? I still love this song 💙

I'm still here in 2023. Love your voice Li Yin...

I love Li Yin so much! SM must promote her,she's so talented,her voice is amazing! Thank you for your hard work Li Yin

Donghae and Zhang Li Yin look really cute together. As long as Donghae and Zhang Li Yin are happy I dont mind who they love. Imo, they really fit eachother. Both are very talented and sweet to others. This song was so beautiful her voice.. amazing! His looks.. gorgeous. Zhang Li Yin looks very cute, kind and beautiful. Haeyin fighting!

She is a really beautiful woman and has amazing powerful vioce.

Donghaee T.T my heart krek krek And zhang li yin your voice really gold

I dint understand a single word but her voice is so silky smooth that I was just humming along with her. Really very lovely voice.

i'm liking this song more and more. its really nice to listen to and the lyrics are really good. especially with zhang li yin's emotion whilst singing this song has expressed the lyrics well. hope sm starts promoting her really well so she can get what she deserves coz god knows she deserves success.

Beautiful voice.. looking forward to her live performances... Donghae looks gorgeous..love that smile of his!

Her amazing voice sounds good in every language

When i heard this song i almost cry.. love her voice .. this song is meaningful too..

09年出的这首歌现在还存在我手机里面，张力尹的“夹子音”不错哦，真的很甜，跟08年时期的声音完全不一样的感觉，像是两个人的感觉，太棒了

how i wish Liyin can be part of a company who will promote her a LOT! and get what she truly deserves T^T Liyin ah~ always keep the faith.

Love her voice!!! Miss you ZhangLiYin

somehow the still and the photos make it seem more real and the song more beautiful.

終於在最近又回韓國節目唱歌了！🎉🎉🎉

I love it! ^^ I got gosebumps! LiYin looks so pretty and the song is beautiful ^^ Finally she's back! ^^ We missed you like a crazy LiYin ♥

i like zhang li yin's vocals...im starting to like this song. she is underrated and under promoted by sm. i wish sm would spend as much time for her (and The Grace) as all the other artists in SM

she has such amazing vocalsss

i wish SM would promote her more. she has so much talent and she really needs to be able to showcase it. i love her voice and her song style. it totally fits her.

she has a really nice voice... and they look good together....

uh, such a beautiful mv , such a beautiful song, such a beautiful language ahg; am i going crazy ...

I love this song. Full of my memory

nice song and great voice,, i miss her voice

2024 and I’m still here 💙

I LOVE HER VOICE ITS SO SOOTHING!!!! WE LOVE YOU Zhangliyin!!!!!!

it's great to hear her voice again, and i hope that sm will promote her in the taiwan market....

this is such a beautiful song. so emotional.

Your voice so amazing Li Yin I wish you comeback soon ^^

장리인 컴백 축하 응원할사람 손😊

i love the concept of this mv :) plus donghae looks soo innocent

Beautiful voice!!! really miss her!!!

this is my fav song of her

Wow, her voice is really really sweet!

i was watching timeless & i will ,all part in a row before watching this 1...i begin 2 like zhang liyin,mostly cause her mesmerizing voice... & of course, suju boys in her vid...LOL~ spat my drinks out of my mouth when i see donghae in this mv...luckily i didn't broke my computer... gosh...she have such amazing voice...she's lucky been able 2 work with the boys,when most of us girls & fans only manage 2 dream about it...sigh~

:( I think she deserves more than a slideshow. She has an amazing voice and is super talented.

a lovely voice. nice MV Donghae, you kill me ^^ love to see Hae and Lin together. I like this MV

omg!! hae's so handsome!!! and liyin's so lucky~~ i envy her,, i like the song~~~

是東海欸❤️❤️❤️ 天啊～小時後看的MV😂

this song makes me cry because is very beautiful

her voice wets my eyes (:

angel's voice..

YAY! the mv is finally out! i feel like i waited for so long! i really wish it was an actual video instead of just pictures but at least she finally has a MV where she is the lead. i also love that donghae is in it! JIA YOU ZHANG LI YIN :D

zhang liyin.. fighting!!

Love her voice ......waiting her coming back

GO GO ZHANG LI YIN!

這首歌聽不膩~超好聽

She has a really nice voice .... this song is really good .... SM really need to promote her more and have come back for her

I think it's a really nice song... the way the MV is done is showing the memories

i miss li yin she's the only sm artist that i personally think has such a great talent

it's magical how i dont get jealous of liyin and im like, a crazy donghae fan. she just have the power of making you feel calm as well as her song. when you get tired of all the other industrilized idols, relax and listen to her song. liyin has rised SM's music to a whole new level. they seriously should start realize liyin's talent and use it properly

Love Riin ❤

This is amazing! Usually, this kind of videos would get me bored. Even though she didnt put on sexy makeup, no dance moves. zhang li yin voice is just too amazing , so catchy!!! And shes just so pretty in a very natural way!!!!! She's like the best singer in SME . Even tho this video is really simple, i still cant stop watching it!!! I'll support you Zhang li Yin! =]

glad she is back!!!

I miss Zhang LiYin~! hope she'll have a great comeback soon! =)

♥ Donghae is so BEAUTIFUL in this MV *___* ♥

I'm glad she's returned! I quite enjoyed this mv because Liyin and Donghae are just adorable together. XD I was just hoping that there would be actual acting rather than just pictures though.

Donghae Oppa is such a cutie! lol love him!

很好聽 很漂亮

she's very talented!

i can't watch this without getting a tiny bit jealous! hehe ♥ donghae zhang liyin really has a nice voice :) i like this song and the simplicity of the video!

Oh! Li Yin why so beauty? I really love her~

LiYin babe! You did well at your recent recording for DayDay Up! When you played "I Will" with your Violin!!!!

This song is more than beautiful!

i like it. atleast she's back. i believe that she has the best voice among the sm artist for girls along with CSJH. but they're so under rated. i miss her. :)

Watch all the videos again! I remembering staying up waiting for SM to release this video! It's been way too long! SM please let Zhang Li Yin have her comeback soon!

2021 and still watching this

those were sweet pictures.

중국에 있을 때 항상 듣던 노래였는데 ㅠㅠ 추억 돋네

actually her albums sales were quite impressive for such a solo rookie singer who was only like 19 -. it was because of her stage performances. she was super shy on stage, they fixed that a bit by getting her promotion in china where shes more comfortable. i mean, she had the weight of being the first solo chinese singer in korea on her shoulders. (:

Después de tiempo, volví a ver este MV, voy a recomendar a las demás ELFiñas.

Miss her voice!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

actually, after watching the MV for the countless times, i am starting to like it. it's simple and the pictures tells a really sad story (from my point of view), and with the accompaniment of Liyin's song & voice, i almost cried. Good job liyin^^

COMEBACK NOW..as in NOW it's been almost two years already..Chocolates miss Li Yin :(

Wow, his career is definitely growing! Proud of you LDH!!!

aw they are so cute

wow, such a nice voice!

No, I actually think this MV is fantastic and so creative. It tells more than motion pictures.

I envy Zhangliyin.. I wish I was her doing this MV. Oh girl, how lucky you are to be hugged by Hae. >.

Amazing MV, very creative!!!! Praises~~~

zhang lin yi must be a big fan of super junior, since they always act in her music videos

I love Li Yin's vibrato >_

Please COMEBACK NOW!!!Chocolates miss you!!

please add this song on spotify, and the other songs too! :(

beautiful

I feel that she's totally under-rated...

Omg... Zhang Li Yin... I miss you. T.T

She looks soo different! :o but she's still cute and talented! :D

It's a typical love story. They're together and then it's over, but she still has feelings for him. It's really too bad she's so underrated. She has such an amazing voice! As if they gave her slide shows for her come back, damn SM!

Wow, I just found out about her after wondering who was singing with Jonghyun in "Wrongly Given Love". I'm stuck on her now!

her vocals are something to die for! strong vocals.. pretty~ nice personality.. i really hope sm will promote her more~ i miss the timeless days~ ri in HWAITING~

Ri In ah~ Chocolates really missed you soooo much! You're the best!!!!!

very nice song...i want the new album already.

I watched that mv just because of Donghae... but i must to admit, that she have really good voice, and this is really good song. :D

Maybe I have watched this because of Donghae

I miss her, I miss my SM Town. SM make them back!! I miss them! DX

Cute cuteeeee !! LOVE IT ! But it would have been so good if it was really a vid of them too and not only pictures...