I'm here in 2024, this song suddenly crosses my mind.

I miss jonghyun, I miss taeyeon.. I miss all old era of kpop😭

still listening in 2021? me: yes, of course edit: i miss him a lot.

i dont care what anyone says but Jonghyun is the only one who can match Taeyeon's emotion in SM.

Jonghyun is the best duet partner for Taeyeon. Vice Versa.

Rest in peace Jonghyun

종현아 진짜 고마워 우리에게 위로되어 주는 노래 많이 불려줘서 너무나도 고마워 나는 항상 너의 노래을 들으면서 힘을 얻어.. 힘이 되어 줘서 너무 고마워 그리고 사랑해♡

Here because ningning and lee mujin will cover this. Huhu i miss jonghyun and taeyeon combo a little bit more today 😢

Thank you, Kim Jonghyun. For the 9 wonderful years being in SHINee's main vocal. We will miss you. Rest In Peace. 1990 - 2017 ❤

When you play this song because it reminded you of Jonghyun so much. It hurts. Jonghyun why do you have to leave? I'll miss you. Every shawol will miss you. SHINee didn't lose a member, they gained an angel. I love you so much. This song reminded me of you so much. #RIPJonghyun

Check out S.M.THE BALLAD Vol.2 BREATH Music Video!

Here, because ningning and le mujin will cover this❤

I miss jonghyun's voice so much. No one can beat his vocal skill, angel's voice

Yoona introduced me to Girls Generation (SNSD) but I ended up falling in love with Taeyeon. Minho introduced me to Shinee but I ended up falling in love with Jonghyun.

Rest in peace Jonghyun oppa T-T we'll miss you so much especially your angel voice T-T we LOVE you

Even in 2025 I'm still listening to this song 🥹 For me, Jonghyun is the best partner for Taeyeon in dueting songs, and she is too. Aaahhhhh.. I miss their collaboration

it just breaks my heart how many sad songs he sang, how many sad, and depressive songs he wrote, and nobody noticed anything until he killed himself. i have no words how sorry i feel right now

No more Jonghyun & Taeyeon collab. Can't stop crying. My heart can't handle this. Really hurt TT

You'll always have a place in my heart. I'll love you forever. RIP Jonghyun, the one who's saved me so many times.

2024 and still in luv with this song - missing the magic of this man's voice 💜

Jonghyun, You have been an amazing human being. You weren't my bias in SHINee, but you always held a special place in my heart. When I heard about your death, it literally felt like something broke in me. The tears just came crashing down. I couldn't stop crying. If only we knew how you feel, then maybe we could've helped. We could've sung this song to you a million times over until you're happy again. We could've done everything in our power to make you happy. But now I guess it's too late. I love you, Kim Jonghyun. We all do. I hope you're finally happy up there. I guess it is true that you always pick the most beautiful flower in a garden first. I'm heartbroken, I will remain heartbroken, and I'll always be heartbroken by your death. I will never forget you, honey. We never will. I could never explain how fucking sad I really am and I won't try to, because I will never be able to anyway. Rest in peace, baby. We will always miss you. We love you so much.

It so sad to watch this knowing that Jonghyun won’t sing this anymore. 😭

Rest in peace, Jonghyun.

리무진 서비스 보고 오랜만에 다시 들으러 왔는데 눈물이 막 나옴....... 정말 좋은 노래를 많이 남기고 갔구나

jonghyun's voice is so beautiful. his eyes are beautiful. he is beautiful. everything about him is beautiful arghhh

I love how Taeyeon can change her voice like from calming to power.

rip jonghyun.. my fave duet of taeyeon & jonghyun.

miss this duo a lot, only jonghyun's voice can balance taeyeon's voice (in female & male collaboration). Their voice harmony is truly a gift for us

Few months ago, I told myself that I want to see Jonghyun & Taeyeon will make an duet again in the future Now one is in pain, one became an shining star

Taeyeon and Jonghyun's voices go so well together

I finally came back here because of the news. I cried a lot lot more after hearing this song, especially jonghyun’s voice. there will be no angel’s voice like yours anymore. but the sky is happy now with the your presence, the most beautiful star❤️ my bias... i love you jonghyun😭 Rest In Peace. stay strong shinee and shawol and all kpop fans especially jonghyun stan

It's been 127 years and they still haven't added this song on Spotify

The what ifs going through my head... ~If only we knew ~If only the cops got there sooner ~If only he didnt feel the pain ~If only he wasnt an Idol ~If only he didnt recieve all the hate and was criticized ~If only people understood ~If only someone couldve saved him If only we wasnt to late 😢😭😢😭 Edit: You should read his last will, it was finally released. Its so heartbreaking because many of the what ifs i thought is what he felt.

Please read this is Important: I heard the news first thing in the morning. I thought it was some sick prank, but as I scrolled through my timeline it was everywhere. This has been the longest two days of my life. Every time I remembered I couldn't believe it. Even right now I still can't believe it. Shawols, I'm so sorry. Jonghyun was the sweetest person I've ever seen. His music got me through my hard times. To know he felt this way and was rejected help opens up our eyes a bit. Mental Illness is serious, my dad has PTSD and Depression and I worry about him a lot. There isn't enough help for people suffering like this... Jonghyun was open about his depression, he advocated for human rights. He was an amazing person. He was never afraid to speak his mind. I feel like a complete idiot. All the signs were out there, yet we couldn't see it. The moment we heard the news it was too late. We can't turn back the clocks as much as I would love to we can't. Many of you may have conflicted feelings about this. Some of you may feel angry, dazzed or depressed. Jonghyun wouldn't want us to be depressed. Jonghyun would want us to live. Jonghyun couldn't battle his demons any longer. He didn't have help. Please look at all the signs Jonghyun showed. We couldn't save him but we can save others. We need to pick up where Jonghyun left off. A sweet boy who would comfort others before himself, he was someone who was lovely, honest and kind. He fought for women's rights. for LGBTQ rights. For mental illness. Jonghyun would want us to turn something so sad and crushing into love. Love those you come across. Love and guide those who are suffering. Love and stand up for the people who can't get through life alone. But most importantly please love yourself. You who should go before others. You need to treat yourself with care. Reach out to people when you feel down and lonely. Give yourself time to heal. Don't overwork yourself. Always have a healthy mindset. There are so many people who have left this world the way Jonghyun has. We couldn't save them but we can save others, we can save ourselves. I love all of you. As you mourn make sure you still look after yourself. Crying leads to dehydration, please drink water. Please eat something healthy to keep you strong. Let us bring happiness and love to this sad and dark time. You've all worked hard. Jonghyun, mi amor, you've worked hard. Please find Peace. Stay safe everyone, I love you

It's hurt me because, deep in my soul, i felt like, "I won't be able to see his bright smiling face anymore, listening to his music, voice without feeling empty." Jonghyun, we love you. I love you. You'll be missed. I love you. I really do. Rest in peace, love. Stay strong Shawol ❤️

who's here. i miss him so much. i stanned him for so long and now im stanning someone who looks like him but my childhood and this feeling was so different

Rest In Peace Jonghyun :(

Who still listen BREATH in 2019 & miss JONGHYUN ?

Taeyeon's & Jonghyun's voice, is there anything more perfect than this? I'm just sorry I didn't know about this song early on.

10년 전 나온 숨소리가 아직도 이렇게 좋다

When Taeyeon came in a 0:47 I literally stopped breathing. Their voices blend beautifully. Jonghyun wrote "Lonely" with Taeyeon in mind and it's heartbreaking to listen to them sing it together.

You’ve done well You’ve worked hard You’ve really gone through a lot 아녕 Angel You’re no longer hurt anymore 🌹

Here's a thing . For everyone out there especially K-Pop Fans . If you hate some idols , never comment or bashing them . Because you never know about their problem or their struggles , being a K-Pop idols mean you have to be "PERFECT" for everyone especially for their fans . We , as a K-Pop fans have to understand them . Never judge them whenever they dating with someone , or involved in some scandal . Even, if you are disappointed with them , never judge or bash them . They are human , they also make a mistake just like us . We should support them even if we are disappointed . I'm not trying to show off , I'm a 2nd gen K-Pop fans , and in fact , i don't really like a 3rd gen K-Pop group, but i never jedge them . Just because i hate them that doesn't mean they are not talented, i just hate'em because their fans don't appreciate the 2nd gen K-Pop group . I'm not a Shawol . I like Key more than Jonghyun actually , but i love Jonghyun voice . It's so sweet and so addicting for me . Everytime i feel sad i always listen to his song . He's a talented singer . R.I.P Jonghyun Oppa :'( . You've done a wonderful job . This is not the end , this is the beginning for us , to always support our idols , we love you Jonghyun , but God loves you more . p.s Sorry for my broke English:(

이렇게라도 가끔 숨소리라도 들려주길

A star that shined brightly for 10 years, now shines brightly in the skies. R.I.P my beautiful Angel Kim Jonghyun

RIP JONGHYUN. 😭😥

Terima kasih, Kim Jonghyun. Kau telah melakukannya dengan sangat baik. Kami akan merindukanmu. Beristirahatlah dengan damai. 1990 - 2017 ❤ #roseforjonghyun

사랑아 사랑할게 너의 아름다운 목소리 나는 계속해서 너를 그리워하고 고통은 잠재되어 있어 그치지 않고 끝나지 않을 것이다. Jonghyun

Who else came here after hearing the tragic news about Jonghyun passing? 😭 #RIPJonghyun #StayStrongShawols 😢

After I heard the news I immediately came here to hear his voice. Rest in peace :(

Came here after Jonghyun's death 😢 May he rest in peace

진짜 둘 목소리 합은.. 천상 조합이댜

[Jonghyun] Nado moreuge jeonhwagireul deulgo marasseo Naya cham oraenmaniya Neomu himi deureoseo japgido mianhaeseo Neoreul bonaen ge huhoedwaeseo hansumman swineungeol [Taeyeon] Neomu nollaseo mari naojido anhasseo tteollineun gaseumman butjabasseo Manhi himdeunji jigeum eodi inneunji mutgido jeone nunmuri heulleosseo [All] Ne sumsoriman deullyeodo geurae [All] Nunmuri ireoke heulleonaerimyeon [Jonghyun] Akkideon nae jageun chueokdeulmajeodo [All] eojjeol jul molla Neomu apaseo seoro nohajugil yaksokhaetjiman [Jonghyun] Jasin eobseul ttae [All] Gakkeum sumsorirado deullyeojugil [Jonghyun] Sumeul swineun ge maeil nuneul tteuneun ge gyeou harureul saneun ge [Taeyeon] Jungneun geot boda himi deundago nege mareul motaesseo Geokjeonghal geot gataseo [All] babocheoreom hansumman swineun geol [All] Nunmuri ireoke heulleonaerimyeon [Jonghyun] Akkideon nae [All] jageun chueokdeulmajeodo eojjeol jul molla Neomu apaseo seoro nohajugil yaksokhaetjiman Jasin eobseul ttae, gakkeum sumsorirado deullyeojugil [Taeyeon] Hagopeun mari manhado nan amu maldo mot hago… Da gwaenchantago seororeul dallaego [All] apahaesseo [Jonghyun] Da doedollimyeon urin haengbokhagiman haesseo [All] nochi motago isseo [All] Nunmuri ireoke heulleonaerimyeon [Jonghyun] Akkideon nae jageun chueokdeulmajeodo [All] eojjeol jul molla Neomu apaseo seoro nohajugil yaksokhaetjiman [Jonghyun] Jakku nega saenggangnal ttaen [Taeyeon] Chameul su eobsi himdeul ttaen [All] Ireokerado gakkeum sumsorirado deullyeojugir

Watching this because of Jonghyun. So talented, so young. Gone too soon. Depression is real, let's not ignore it. Rest in Peace.

Jonghyuna pls take care our princess sulli 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

2023년 봄날의 새벽에 듣는데 눈물이나네

shawol always love u jonghyun 😊 rest in peace

two best singers of SM

everytime i listen to this song, I'll cry..but now I even cry more...RIP Jonghyun :(

Can't believe it's already 1 decade passed. I still remember the day I sat in cinema room watched this documentary. These people nourished my teenhood.

although I don't listen to Shinee much, I read an article about his death, but instead of just lingering about his death, the article also stated why he was loved by most and what type of singer he is. In it, it also wrote what a wonderful songwriter he is and named this song. This is one of the most beautiful songs I've heard and well written. Although I never experienced what shawols did just now, my condolences and prayers to his family and shawols who both must be going through a tough time. From what I read and saw few vids, Jonghyun seemed such a caring and kind hearted person. May he Rest in Peace.

Oh my actual goodness!!!! I've been a Shawol for so long, how have I never heard this!!!?? And Jonghyun's and Taeyon's voices were made to sing ballads dear lord!!! They blend together so beautifully and delicately!! ❤❤❤

*Jonghyun .. I miss you* *Taeyeon .. Be strong*

2025 when I saw this video again. I miss this sm era. Wherre they treat each other as siblings. Though you can still see it but still it's feel different. And I miss you Jonghyun - oppa.

this makes it even sadder

종현아 니 목소리 들을때마다 눈물이 이 왜 이렇게 나니ㅠㅠㅠㅠ마음이 너무 아파ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ제발 거기서는 아프지말고 ...사랑해

I just saw in Instagram a paid ad Jonghyun displayed in one of the Seoul Metro stations « Spring is beautiful because it is the season you were born ». Beautiful. It is on display until April 30, 2020.

11 years of this masterpiece thank you jonghyun and taeyeon

8 years ago... I was a fans of Jonghyun until I realized I must focus to my real life. I stop listening his or shinee's songs. And I think I was really stop loving him. Until I heard that news. It broke my heart so much. I was wrong. I still love him. I still adore him. I couldn't believe it. It's bring so much pain :(

I love this song. It puts me at ease. I will always miss your voice Kim Jonghyun. 😔😔😔. Well done, and be at peace. Watch over SHINee, as they prepare for their concert. You are an angel. Thank you so much. 🌷🌷🌷

since there’s no comment abt the mv let me just say- moon ka young and changmins acting skills doe

Taeyeon and Jonghyun singing together is such a blessing..

We lost a beautiful soul and voice...

Rest in Peace Jonghyun. You have no idea how I like you because of this song. 😢 I fall in love with this song admiring Taeyeon's & your beautiful voice. This is forever the best duet song in kpop world (in my heart). Even before you passed away, I watched this MV multiple times, I even have this song in my playlist and listen to it almost everyday. After hearing the shocking news yesterday, I was so sad... I couldn't had imagine the owner of this beautiful voice was in deep sorrow. May you rest in peace. You will certainly be missed by everyone. 💝

THIS IS MY FAVORITE SONG EVERY NIGHT. BUT ITS NEVER BE THE SAME AGAIN. RIP JOGHYUN I JUST CAN BELIEVE YOU ARE GONEEEEE ;(

Taeyeons visuals, Angel Jonghyuns voice, the song itself, everything about this is perfect

Jonghyun and Taeyeon harmonize really really well together!! Beautiful song!

Who still watcching this on 2020

r.i.p jonghyun 😭😭😭 thank you for everything 😭

Cette chanson est tellement belle même le drama mimi ma fait beaucoup pleuré et la voix de jonghyun sublime c'est dommage qu'il a voulu partir quitter cette vie alors qu'on a une seule vie

I think this is the best among the three versions. Jonghyun’s and Taeyeon’s voices blended so well. I love listening to this over and over again. You did well, Jonghyun :)

Hey Jonghyunnie, you saw Taeyeon's msg on ur instagram yet? She said she misses you today (july 17, 2019) And we do too

It is not a competition between who sing the highest note, but is harmony. Both have excellent singing skills. Time does not pass in vain and Jonghyun is not resting on its laurels

너무 좋은노래..한때 이노래에 미쳐있었지ㅋㅋ 지금. 다시한번더 미쳐본다.

I left with my girlfriend, and I quit my job... Just to tell Shawols that until I die: I will just love SHINee

They're the best sister and brother. Rest in peace Jonghyun and stay strong Taeyeon noona 😭

I really missed you, Oppa. When i was younger, I always tell to my mom that I'll become a successful architect one day so that I'll be able to design a big concert hall for you. I wasn't able to watch your concerts because i don't have enough money. I really missed seeing you all perform. My birthday is coming, (Dec.10) and I still wish that someday I'll be able to meet shinee.

ジョンヒョン、会いたいよ😭 あれからもう５年が経ったなんてまだ信じられないくらい気持ちが交差してる。 どうかそこでは少しでも穏やかに安らかにあたたかくいてね RIP 2022.12.18

kim taeyeon!!!!!! giọng hát của chị thật tuyệt vời nó như đang gậm nhấm trái tim người khác vậy

Who still listen to this in 2020? I miss you so much Jonghyun..

종현아... 그동안 정말 많이 힘들었지 진짜 고생많았어 난 항상 너의노래 들으면서 위로 많이받았는데 정작 난아무것고 못해주고 또 못해줄수밖에 없었다는게 너무 슬프다.. 누가뭐래도 넌 최고의 가수였어 정말로. 지금 그곳은 편하지..?? 이젠 더이상힘들지 말고 푹쉬었으면 좋겠다.. 마지막으로 이런 음악을 우리한테 선물해주고 가서 정말고마워

Coming here after ningning's cover, reminds me this song is so heartbreaking and masterpiece

Taeyeon's voice is like from heaven

My tears keep falling

This is the best out of three versions. Fairly to say, the duet part of this version is so much better than these two other versions. As a Cass I really hope Changmin can duet with a better voice. Krystal obviously is not experienced enough in processing her voice.

와 근데 뮤비 처음 보는데.. 서사 대박이네.. 최강창민 님이랑 문가영 님 영화 한편 뚝딱 찍으시고.. 거기에 종현오빠랑 태연언니 듀엣이라니... 이거 너무 완벽하잖아

Rest in peace jonghyun

to our dearest ever jonghyun, thank you for making us strong even if you're in so much pain. we're sorry we can't make you happy the same way you do to us. i'll forever treasure the memories. thank you for being one of the pillars of my kpop life. you will always be remembered as one of the greatest people. please be in no pain from now on. i love you so much. we will miss you.

This song hits so many emotions within me ;-;

Even after all these years, this song still makes me cry just like the first time I listened to it.