A lot of people probably came for Tao and Victoria but do you hear this girl's voice?! SHE IS AMAZING!!!

Rather than fangirling over Song Jae Rim, Victoria, or Tao, can we talk about Zhang Li Yin? Seriously, everybody is always talking about someone else, with small comments like "Oh her singing is nice" tacked on as an after thought. Really since her last single in 2009 her voice has gotten even more beautiful, she looks healthy and not RIDICULOUSLY thin, she honestly looks like she's been doing well in the last few years, AND HER VOICE IS STILL FRIGGIN BREATHTAKING.

I COULD LISTEN TO LIYIN SING TILL THE END OF TIME AND BEYOND OMG TAO AND VIC'S ACTING ;;;;;

I know this mv's main focus is on tao and vic, but let's take a moment to appreciate the handsomeness of SONG JAE RIM too 😍

Wow tao 's acting perfect zhang li yin voice perfect victoria acting perfect sooo its amazing

Zhang Li Yin's voice... Everytime I listen to her voice I want to learn Chinese because It sounds like a beautiful and lovely language when she sings !

I like this MV. I love how this mv shows the love between tao's parents , is quite sweet. Btw, Tao is surprisingly good at acting and song jae rim is really handsome here.

I don't even see them as idols anymore, but professional actor and actress.... I'm crying~~~~😭😭😭😭😭😭 How can a mv be so dramatic and full-story-like.... One of the best mv seriously.... :')

I love the emotion she conveys, and the continuity of the story she tells

everyone's like "taotoria! their acting is awesome!" and I'm just here going "...song jaerim anyone?"

Tao's eyes are the most beautiful things in the world. You can see everything he wants to convey in them.

urrggghh!! her voiceeee!!! guyss!! do u see that solitary tear falling down my eyes??? Damn!!! I understand nothing of the song. But Liyin's voice is enough to convey the message and emotion of the song, regardless of language difference. This is a true talent. This is . . . SM! yooohooo! hello?? your talents are wayyy talented and Liyin is super not an exception. This is the talent that is not brought about by years of training. This is inborn! AND I WANT MORE!!! hwaitiiiinng!!

Victoria is beautiful and talented! Her acting was splendid.

I really REALLY love this Chinese version better. Or maybe it's just because I like Zhang LiYin's voice, it's so pure and powerful at the same time. She looks like an angel here ♡

I am so happy that SM let her sing another song and make another video. The feels i just cant its so perfect. I have a new favorite solo artist. And my bby panda tao, and mommy Victoria. all i can say to this is PERFECTION.

Tao's acting is so GOOD. He is really talented.

ZhangLiYin's voice is perfect!!! Miss her!!!

That automatic alarm clock that wakes you up at 4:20am to check SM's channel because the MV has finally been uploaded on youtube 5 mins ago!! I think I have the sixth sense for everything that smells TAO! I struggled with youuku last night but in vain! This is just beautiful and I love the way it ends! A creative way to end it and the story is by far the most touching I've ever watched! I LOVE THIS. I LOVE ZHANG LI YIN. I LOVE VICTORIA. BUT ABOVE ALL I LOVE YOU TAO. TAO YOU MAKE ME PROUD MY LOVE. TAO I CAN'T TELL YOU HOW PROUD OF YOU I AM!!!!!!! THANK YOU SO MUCH SM!!!! Now excuse me, I have to go cry in a corner over how perfect this is, over how perfect my TAO bae is T____________T

Panda tao is born to be an actor,I want to see him in the movie!! The song is beautiful TTTTTTTT

Another splendid and amazing song by Zhang Liyin.... She sang this song with feel and passion.... Love all her Korean cover songs!

Liyin voice made me cried a river.. And Tao and Vic's acting is on point... Ugh, i lover the whole MV.

Zhang Liyin never fails to amaze me! She looks so beautiful and her singing was absolutely on point :D

Tao walk in the way his parents love story. This song is so touching + nice MV story+ sweet and sad sound from Liyin.

Why do you have to be so perfect Taotao...your acting is wow.. vic too and liyin's voice.. heaven its heaven....♡

我一个人mv里面的妆造比爱的独白中好看太多了，满叔的眼光确实很好

장리인 목소리 독특하고 어린데도 실력뛰어나서 처음부터 참 좋아했었는데. 에스엠에서 제대로 날개 제대로 못핀게 너무 아쉬움...

i really wish sm giv li ying more chances to shine. she has a great voice.

티파니 나혼자서 인가?하고 봤는데 역시ㅠㅠㅠ거기다 타오에 송재림까지ㅠㅠ

Beautiful face, beautiful voice. I'm crying. Why is life so unfair.

This is one of the most beautiful ballads I've heard in a while :) SM should do this kind of music more often. Zhang Li Yin has such a beautiful voice and she is so graceful. All in all, its a wonderful work with the MV and the actors work! Bravo

Not only the mv, the song is really very great!The singer sang very well and soft when i close my eyes and listen to it TT

i miss her voice so much 😢😢😢😢

tao victoria why so perfect ? Zhang liyin voice is amazing... I LOVE YOU TAO THANKS SM ^^

She has an amazing voice, its just so emotional. Good Job.

Zhang li yins voice ahh it's so beautiful ;u; and Victoria and Taos acting was so cute omg 💞

I miss her >< her music is so pure are perfect

why do i always feel like crying whenever i see Zhang Li Yin MV. It's too touching!!!!!!

As expected.. SM used tao's fighting skills whenever they can XD

Such a beautiful and sad song. Tao and Victoria's acting was really good with Zhang Yi Lin's nice voice

THIS IS THE BETTER VERSION OF 'BY MYSELF' !! Zhang Liyin jjang!♥

Zly should be promoted more in China. She have a great voice. I want her amazing voice to be recognized and be popular in China at least. Its a waste if people dont recognize her.

Tao gonna be a great actor. Fighting!!!

her voice so beautiful! That's feeling when listen dis song alone, silent background! No words can effect to use!

this is so beautiful and the way tao fits complete with the role is amazing TAO SARANGHAE EXO FIGHTING

Zhang Li Yin voices is so amazing,,So emotional

2021 still remember liyin voice, realy miss liyin SM plis dont make me hate u SM

I was crying for this, our baby Tao is growing. Victoria, you're always a big "mama" and great noona

I love your voice Li Yin ❤️❤️❤️

her voice sound touching as always. UNNIE FIGHTING

her voice never fail to amaze me... love it

Love these music videos and Zhang Li Yin! The more I see Tao the more attractive he gets!

Tao so handsome!! Such a good actor.. U ruin my bias list again.. T.T

love love love this song and this mv!! Liyin's voice tell the story soooooo beautiful !! I'm crying!! And TAO should be an actor!

Wow--- wow. Can I just--okay. Wow. Liyin's voice plus the acting is just sogoddamnperfecticannothnng, Actually, the first line is just so extremely touching and her voice omg omg HEERRR VOICE. *sobs* perfection

omg i watched this bcs of song qian and zitao but i fell in love with liyin's voice!! she's like an angel. so beautiful :)

TaoToria Acting + Zhang Li Yin Voice ? PERFECT :D *clap

Still watching this and still smiling like a dork :') I can't get over how great this song is and how awesome Liyin's voice is

So proud of tao♥ his acting skill is getting better and better!

Am I the only one thinking that Tao being in love with someone who looks like her mom is creepy as hell?! Anyways, Zhang Li Yin's voice is pure perfection, i love the song!!!

Tao is really cool. His acting is excellent. Love him so much

A great present for my birthday :) Thank you SM, Tao & Victoria

Zhang Li Yin's voice perfect ! The song is very nice. Tiffany has a great voice like the sound of.Tao and Victoria was very good.😊😍

I'm waiting for her comeback

That's a long love story.Tao and Victoria sweet.Zhang li yin voice of agape and not alone are awesome and powerful

Tao and his cutie smile he looks like a kitten he's so cute uggh

OHMYFEELSSSS.. this really gives me goosebumps.. aahhhh this MV is soooooo touching!! Liyin's voice is goddess plus that moment when Tao gives Victoria the flower, his smile *o*

Loving Zhang Li Yin's MV's, they're so heart clenching, and touching :) nice work

her voice was beautiful just like an angel

TAO! MY FEELS DOE!!!!! I'm starting to like Tao a lot now! :)

my heart just melt when tao gave victoria the flowers... god, his damn smile! he's so cute ;-; and li yin~ her voice is so beautiful

btw, jaerim couldn't be more handsome in this video

Awwww i loved this! Tao and Victoria did so well!

when Zhang Li Yin sings her lips doesnt move alot its like shes frozen or something but i like it lol

The first time when i heard zhang li yin song i really love her vocal so much .. her singing still the same nice vocal she have ♥ zhang li yin 加油♥♥

I wish Liyin would release a physical album!

Keep support zhang li yin 姐姐.. she has an amazing talent .. she also has a strong character voice .. for Tao, I hope he can play the movie or drama soon.. his acting really great .. victoria 언니 I love you .. support from ELF _with love _*_ELF_*

Victoria is a beautiful actress

Cant wait to hear her live performance! Queen of Ballads!

OMG so beautiful :') the song is beautiful too :)

Zhang Li Yin is indeed one of the greatest talent (in vocal term) that SM ever had! Even Tiffany already sung the korean ver, i still love this one. ZYL's voice give another color into this song. Meanwhile, Jae Rim was so hot! Even he had short scene

I felt the chemistry between Tao and Victoria ♡♡♡ I felt inlove with this video ♡ I may not understand the lyrics but I can feel what the song is all about because of the wonderful musoc video :D SMENT surely is very unique and creative

Zhang Li Yin's voice is seriously amazing! It's so powerful!!:))

I keep seeing all these comments about it being disgusting that he falls for someone who looks like his mom, but if you think about, wouldn't anyone want to be near the person who reminds them of family? He probably at first wanted to be near her and protect her, which eventually blossomed into actual love.

I love how Victoria was able to divert her role as a mother, to a younger lady.

Shes my fav female singer in sm Why sm didnt give her enough songs T^T On top of this there is tao omeyged

Music indeed a universal language. I enjoy listening to this even i dont understand any word out of it. I love Zhang Li Yin :*

Zhang Li Yin has a beautiful voice. This music video made me cry. Aww Tao and Victoria. The ending 😭💕👌 I still don't really get the story line, yes I saw the first one but it's still kind of confusing.

i shed tears like a river .. OMG this mv is great and Agape too .. sooo much chemistry and feelings going on there ,, great job zhang li yin

can someone tell me the full story in detail plis? ZHANG LI YIN'S VOICE IS MMMMHHMM. HEAVEN. TAO AND VIC PLIS START ACTING.

Li Yin is amazing~ I really wish she received more love and attention from SM. She is such a gem! I love this version of hers too, but also wish that she would have original songs just for her. *sighhhh

Tao and Victoria should do a proper drama together!! Would be epic

Song jae rim

After reading these comments. I see people like first version By myselft by Tiffany. But I thinkbthe Chinese version Not alone by Zhang Li Yin also not bad. Each person has a different sings style. Song By myselft by Tiffany was singing with her characteristic raucous. Song Not alone by Zhang Li Yin was singing with high voice and has a thickness of only she could

I understand nothing, but Tao was awesome! Vic too, and Liyin's voice is amazing!

The MV is so beautiful wow! I like it when MVs have their storylines not just people dancing in a box lmao. Btw Liyin's voice is so precious oh god why I didn't notice her before? T_____T and omfg Vic umma's acting is daeback >____< ofc Tao panda's acting too

I miss ZhangLiYin and her voice 😢

zhang li yin is really beautiful. wow. and victoria umma and tao oppa

Still here only for Zhang Liyin and her amazing voice!!! =)

OMO!!!! Is so beautiful ^^