SamMagic97 she sings this way lately... i think she actually changes her way of singing in general. i agree both of them sing this duet song very well. i actually miss hearing this.

Agree with everything you said... I can't imagine how difficult to memorize all the lyrics for him :'( However now he is wonderful whenever he sings in Mandarin and Korean :-)

Karen S. And i think he was so lucky to has been a member of exo-m.. at least he knows how to be friend w/ mandarin 😅😅

Karen S. What’s hard is he also sang it with so much emotion even though it’s in a different language

Then u must think how much difficult chinese trainer at SM to learn korean and practice

@@emmacho6470 ofc that's great he's in EXO-M and having great time with them... also kudos to chinese / non korean trainee who must learn korean ...And fans who can memorize all of their idol's songs even though the languange is different🤣🤣👍

Li yin also made the song even more difficult to sing compared to Tae yeons version. What li yin did was she exerted even more vocal control then taetae did and she knew when to drop the note to as low as possible and raise it to high and deep as possible which is difficult and requires really precise vocal control. Not to mention she matched Chen’s tempo perfectly. She let him dictate the tempo and she matched it. Li yin’s vocals are powerful

@@AznIntegra521 and she was singing with a high fever

***** u could check it out from exoticsub's channel. it's called IQIYI interview :)

The way she was looking at him, especially near the end, was heartwarming. To me, it seemed like she was smiling at him and telling him that he did well ^^ I loved this version. Chen's pronunciation sounds magnificent and Zhang Li Yin's voice is amazing

dont worry.. its not only u.. me too.. i even converted this video into mp3. XD but i have the habit of listening live version when it sounded so much better than studio version.

Me too..their live is much better than the studio ver. I think.

you can tell artists are good if you prefer live over studio :D i can only listen to their live versions. studio version just pales in comparison (even though i know it's still them). i also convert the video lives to mp3! XD even though the sound quality is overall lower i just love the vocal quality so much more

this, and set me free are soooo much better live

Also, the fact that she sung this when she had a fever and went to the hospital just before this performance. I don't is she is better than Taeyeon though. :P

And J-Min.

im not saying that she is better than anyone artist in sm what im saying here that she is the ONE of best sm artist ASIDE from taeyeon and tiffany and other female vocalist in sm.

@shigh96 well everyone have their different opinions haha

Honestly, the only problem with her (watch Zhang Liyin's old videos) is lack of stage presence, which is VERY unfortunate. Her voice is beautiful, and I'm glad she is no longer AWOL, because I miss her a heck of a lot.

If it was a normal love song I'll be 100% in agreement with your comment but the Korean song is about a couple who just broke up, they're regretting their decision, but they don't want to let the other person know so instead of saying I’m sorry or let's get back together they just breath trough the phone. Do you think a couple like that would be making eye contact and laughing, no they'll be awkward and frustrated I think that's the feeling they were trying to transmit and you can see they're effort at the end when they're trying their best to not smile and have a grim face. (Taeyeon even had to close her eyes because she laugh easily, lol that dork :P).

I don't know if the Korean and Chinese version have the same lyrics because they sometime change them but the main theme should be the same, if we analyze just base on than Taeyeon and Jonghyun version feels more natural, it feels more like a sad ending witch go very well with the lyrics.

Yoyo Armani I disagree. Singing with emotion doesn't necessarily mean singing with happy emotions. Chen and Liyin perfectly portrayed the emotions of heartbreak and pain while singing to each other with a feeling of yearning and regret. They broke up, and are apart, but they still look to/for each other. And really, that's the interesting part of a love ballad performed by two people, their interaction/eye-contact and exchange. If that's not shown in the performance, what's the difference between the performance and the studio version of the song? Might as well just listen to it on iTunes if there's no interaction in the performance to make it stand out in some way.

gigo518 Ok I think I didn't express myself well on my last comment I didn't say vhen and Liyin sang happily, they expressed the sadness of song very well Chen voice is the best for me it suit the song perfectly and Zhen Liyin I didn't know about her till now but she's definitely on my radar now. What I was trying to say is that compared to Taeyeon and Jonghyun version, they looked more happy (their way of acting nor their singing) when you see their performance it feel like they broke up in the heat of the moment but now that they calmed down their love for each other is stronger than the reason they broke up so they're most likely geeting back together while in the korean version even thought they haven't forgotten each other at all they haven't gotten over the reason they broke up so it feels much sadder. As to the reason why the korean version lacked so much interaction is obviously because she was having problem with her earpiece, if you've seen some of Taeyeon live performance you should know she tend to close her eyes when she's singing high notes or difficult parts but in this case she had them close almost the whole time, if you looke close you will notice she start acting weird after pressing her earpiece that mean she couldn't hear herself very well that's why she lost track of her surrounding, this of course is not an excuse as she is a professional and she should be prepared yo handled all kind of situation but even if is not an excuse, it is the reason of why she did that. Now if you watch some of Taeyeon and Jonghyun lives on inkigayo(best one) or music bank you may see why I say their version suit better the lyrics(or the korean lyrics at least) or you might not as it just a feeling I get so it doesn't mean everyone will feel as I feel. I love both version thought because they feel loke to completely different songs to me (only when watching then live).

Anh Nguyen forget about the techniques she sings with her heart out i trembled while she was singing that's what it means to be a singer for me.

i think she isnt underrated. but she is so popular in china

Not really

her voice is rich and more womanly, it's so sad that she's not well promote and she left now bcs the contract come to an end 😭😭😭 i wonder if she enter the final revision line up of SNSD, she must be really famous and as favorite as Taeyeon. Both are amazing.

i recently came across this song, is zhang li yin still active in the music industry?

Mei Chu her name is zhang li yin

Agree, I think it's better than Korean version

Mei Chu her name is Zhang Li Yin

I didn't know that Kyuhyun sings in Mandarin,but I just checked a video where he talks with Chinese people,like talks

I hope chen can speak well of chinese 😍😍

I agree with you, Chen has the least number of fans. However, it't not like what you think. In my opinion, the reason are: 1. Chen doesn't have a baby face like Luhan or Xiumin in ExoM. He has a manly face and most people (espically in Korea) like baby face idols. 2. The people who like Chen is in their 20's or mature, cause they admire his powerful voice and efforts. They have known how difficult did he experience when he choosed ExoM. 3. He can't speak Chinese. That's a problem. Luckily, he can understand now and maybe, we can wait 1 or 2 years to listen his Chinese. 4. In China, he has mature image and not usually smile but in Korea (his country), he smiles too much (>v

Lol, Chen is one of the more popular members in Korea.

I don't think he's the least popular at all - just scan the crowd during their performances and it's not hard to spot a fair few Chen signs. He might not (yet) be one of the most popular members, but he's definitely not the least popular, either. I think the reason it still appears that he's not getting as much attention as some of the others is because his popularity has taken longer to build - it wasn't until Growl era that fans got to see the real bubbly & chatty Chen on Korean shows, and Miracles in December + Breath really got fans acquainted with Chen's talent (which was previously hidden). Just look at how quickly the number of Chen fansites have grown since December!

Chen is actually growing very popular in China. During his performance with Exo M on the Chinese Immortal Songs, he was actually the one member who got the most cheers singularly from the audience!

I don't understand I am ELF..and Jongdae is my bias..:D...and his popularity has risen recently so don't worry.

They have. They performed on SBS The Show and Simply Kpop. :)

ohh! thanks i will look that up! ^^

To add to that, Liyin was actually sick that day. That's why her face here is a bit puffier looking than how she typically looks because she went to the hospital to get a drip before the performance.